agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Correcting trollish fallacies Darwinist rhetorical tactics Logic and First Principles of right reason Media Manipulation, Agit-Prop &/or Lawfare

Logic and First Principles, 12: The crooked yardstick vs plumb-line self-evident truths

Let’s propose a silly example, that a certain Emperor (maybe, just before he went out in his new invisible clothes) decides that a certain crooked stick is now the standard of length, straightness, uprightness and accuracy, a crooked yardstick. Suddenly, what is genuinely such things will be deemed the opposite. And then, suppose that somehow […]

brains and computation vs contemplation Darwinist rhetorical tactics Logic and First Principles of right reason matter, thus atoms, ions, molecules, phases etc Mind Science, Mathematics, Philosophy and (Natural) Theology Selective Hyperskepticism

Logic and First Principles, 11: The logic of Ultimate Mind as Source of Reality

After we headlined and began discussing PS on hearing and consciousness yesterday, H raised a significant issue: H, 15: >> . . . the invocation of a Creator who “beautifully designed what each sound should sound like” and “put the special program that can interpret each frequency pattern of air vibration into each sound, thus […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Correcting trollish fallacies Darwinist rhetorical tactics Food for thought Governance & control vs anarchy Logic and First Principles of right reason

SM on Gerrymandering of definitions and the breakdown of responsible discussion

Sometimes a gem of a comment gets overlooked, but is well worth promotion to headlined status. Here, let us belatedly highlight SM on gerrymandering definitions in the slippery slope thread: SM, 13: >>If three successfully interbreeding populations of finches on a single island are separate species then whenever a Japanese person marries a Sicilian we […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Atheism Darwinist rhetorical tactics Ethics Free Speech Freedom Logic and First Principles of right reason

The problem of anti-conscience, anti-theistic prejudice driving opinion, views and policy

In a current thread on the morality or otherwise on the Pagan practice of infanticide, frequent, objecting commenter BB gives us a summary of a common prejudice of our time: BB, 69: ” The fact that we no longer blindly accept discrimination based on the justification of freedom of conscience or freedom of religion is […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Darwinist rhetorical tactics Governance & control vs anarchy Logic and First Principles of right reason

SM: Is the slippery slope argument ALWAYS fallacious?

In the fallacy thread, Scuzzaman has raised the issue of the slippery slope argument, which he argues is not necessarily fallacious. Let’s pause for a vid (without necessarily endorsing all that is said, this is food for thought): Benjamin McLean here connects the issue to the principle of induction and so also to the post-Hume […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Darwinist rhetorical tactics Logic and First Principles of right reason

Logic and First Principles, 7: The problem of fallacies vs credible warrant

When we deal with deeply polarised topics such as ID, we face the problem of well-grounded reasoning vs fallacies. A fallacy being a significantly persuasive but fundamentally misleading argument, often as an error of reasoning. (Cf. a classic collection here.) However, too often, fallacies are deliberately used by clever rhetors to mislead the unwary. Likewise […]

Back to Basics of ID Darwinist rhetorical tactics Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Logic and First Principles of right reason Mathematics Science, Mathematics, Philosophy and (Natural) Theology Selective Hyperskepticism

Logic & First Principles, 4: The logic of being, causality and science

We live as beings in a world full of other concrete entities, and to do science we must routinely rely on mathematics and so on numbers and other abstract objects. We observe how — as just one example — a fire demonstrates causality (and see that across time causality has been the subject of hot […]

Back to Basics of ID biosemiotics Darwinist rhetorical tactics Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Logic and First Principles of right reason Mathematics Selective Hyperskepticism

Logic & First Principles, 3: The roots of right reason and the power/limits of entailment

Why is this topic important? (Why a series, now on no 3 (see 1 and 2)?) Here at UD, the phrase “first principles of right reason” and similar ones (e.g. “reason’s rules”) have often come up. Others talk about “the laws of thought,” which in a post-Kant world hints of “the ugly gulch” between the […]

Back to Basics of ID Darwinist rhetorical tactics Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Functionally Specified Complex Information & Organization Intelligent Design Logic and First Principles of right reason

Logic and First Principles, 2: How could Induction ever work? (Identity and universality in action . . . )

In a day when first principles of reason are at a steep discount, it is unsurprising to see that inductive reasoning is doubted or dismissed in some quarters. And yet, there is still a huge cultural investment in science, which is generally understood to pivot on inductive reasoning. Where, as the Stanford Enc of Phil […]

Darwinist rhetorical tactics Design inference Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Logic and First Principles of right reason The Design of Life

Logic & first principles, 1: Analogy, Induction and the power of the principle of identity (with application to the genetic code)

One of the commonest objections we meet when we discuss design inferences — especially concerning the genetic code, is that a claim is “just an analogy” (with implied conclusion that analogies are weak or fallacious). This then extends to inductive arguments used. This common error must be corrected and (as will be shown) the principle […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Darwinist rhetorical tactics Food for thought Logic and First Principles of right reason Media Manipulation, Agit-Prop &/or Lawfare Naturalism popular science and science education Science, worldview issues/foundations and society Selective Hyperskepticism

Revealing in-thread exchanges on the imposition of evo mat scientism/ naturalism (and on the tactics to deflect attention from that)

The imposition of evolutionary materialistic scientism (aka naturalism) is one of the key issues driving the march of folly in our civilisation. It is also very difficult to discuss as there are some very powerful rhetorical deflectors at work. Sometimes, then, the best thing we can do is to clip from one of UD’s exchanges […]

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Culture Darwinist rhetorical tactics Food for thought Geo-strategic issues Governance & control vs anarchy Logic and First Principles of right reason Politics/policy and origins issues Science, worldview issues/foundations and society

The propagandist’s paradise . . .

is our ruinous nightmare. This can be seen through a game, from the conspiracism thread: KF, 86: >> . . . there is a silly little mental game we can consider. [The Crooked Yardstick Effect:] Step one, define that a certain crooked yardstick, S, is the standard of straight, accurate and upright. Once that is […]

academic freedom agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Darwinist rhetorical tactics Free Speech Freedom Geo-strategic issues Governance & control vs anarchy Intelligent Design Media Politics/policy and origins issues

ID vs the shadow-censoring (“shadow-banning”) digital empires, 2

ID is a proposition that, first, it is reasonable to inquire scientifically as to whether certain features of the world of life and/or the physical cosmos can or do show observable signs of design. To which, the answer has long since been given, e.g. by the well known OoL researcher Orgel in a significant 1973 […]