Back to Basics of ID Design inference Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Food for thought For Reference Functionally Specified Complex Information & Organization ID Foundations Intelligent Design Logic and First Principles of right reason Science science education

L&FP, 55: Defining/Clarifying Intelligent Design as Inference, as Theory, as a Movement

It seems, despite UD’s resources tab, some still struggle to understand ID in the three distinct senses: inference, theory/research programme, movement. Accordingly, let us headline a clarifying note from the current thread on people who doubt, for the record: [KF, 269:] >>. . . first we must mark out a matter of inductive reasoning and Read More…

academic freedom agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Economics and policy issues Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics governance Logic and First Principles of right reason Peer review

L&FP, 52: Fallaciously “settled” (=begged) questions and the marginalisation of legitimate alternatives

Nowadays, we are often told “The Science is SETTLED,” as though Science is ever finalised or certain. To go with it, those who have concerns or alternative views and arguments are marginalised and too often smeared, scapegoated or even outright slandered. Sometimes — as Dallas Willard warned regarding moral knowledge — in this rush to Read More…

academic freedom agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason Moving civilization forward

L&FP, 50: The error(s) of telling ‘truth’ by the clock

In a given time and culture, characteristic fashionable fallacies too often gain persuasive power by mutual reinforcement, and/or by swinging from one extreme to another; bypassing the point of responsible balance. So, too, we end up in a thorny thicket of errors, a hard-to-escape problematique. And yes, that often includes the [neo-]marxist version of the Read More…

Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Intelligent Design Logic and First Principles of right reason Mathematics Philosophy

L&FP, 49: Debating the validity (and objectivity) of infinity

Steve Patterson, among many points of objection, is doubtful on the modern concept of infinity (or more strictly the transfinite): The foundations of modern mathematics are flawed. A logical contradiction is nestled at the very core, and it’s been there for a century. Of all the controversial ideas I hold, this is the most radical. Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48m: The legitimate authority of knowable moral truth in service to justice, thriving and prudence

In the current thread on an unfortunate event with a newborn, there is an exchange of comments: BA, 45: Suppose the overwhelming majority regarded dumping newborns in dumpsters as good. Would it then be good? Sev, 56: Presumably, it would be good in the minds of the majority who approved of it. It would not Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48L: Can we restore confident knowledge of moral truth?

Yes. But it will be contested. As Dallas Willard highlighted: Human life has an inescapable moral dimension. That is, it essentially involves choices with reference to what is good and evil, right and wrong, duty and failure to do what ought to be done . . . . What characterizes life in so-called Western societies Read More…

Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics governance Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48k: Dallas Willard on the key self-referentiality in the Relativist thesis that there are no generally knowable, objective moral truths

In the preface to his posthumous The Disappearance of Moral Knowledge (2018), Dallas Willard begins: Human life has an inescapable moral dimension. That is, it essentially involves choices with reference to what is good and evil, right and wrong, duty and failure to do what ought to be done. Any human community, whatever its scope, Read More…

academic freedom agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics governance Governance & control vs anarchy Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48j: Dallas Willard’s (partial) list of reasons for the unwarranted disappearance of moral knowledge

As we continue to explore the issue of the marginalisation of moral knowledge, let us highlight from 48b, Willard’s (incomplete) list of key causes: (2). How did this disappearance [of moral knowledge] come to be the case? Not through a discovery of some kind: e.g. that there was no such knowledge. But through a lengthy Read More…

academic freedom agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Atheism Defending our Civilization Education Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Geo-strategic issues governance Governance & control vs anarchy Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48i: Dallas Willard on the legitimate authority of knowledge (vs the radical narrative of oppression)

In the course of exploring the marginalisation/disappear-ING of moral knowledge, Professor Dallas Willard gave an expanded definition of knowledge that also draws out the legitimate authority of knowledge; including, moral knowledge, i.e. knowledge of duty to right conduct etc. As we can see from his handout for a 2010 video lecture: What is knowledge and Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Geo-strategic issues governance Governance & control vs anarchy Laws Lessons of History Liberty Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48h: Building sound Government on a built-in, Natural Law base (The US Declaration of Independence as a case study)

The natural, built in law framework in 48g culminates: . . . in civil society with government, justice is a principal task of legitimate government. In short, nihilistic will to power untempered by the primacy of justice is its own refutation in any type of state. Where, justice is the due balance of rights, freedoms Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Governance & control vs anarchy Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48g: Is a child the moral equivalent of a fish we catch and eat for lunch?

Here, we follow up from the yardstick case of a child kidnapped, sexually tortured and murdered. No 60 in L&FP48a: >>Compare to such, a fish, that we lure to bite on a hook, then land, kill and eat for lunch without compunction. (And even for those who object to so treating a fish, they will Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Evolutionary materialism's amorality evolutionary materialism's self-falsification Governance & control vs anarchy Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason

L&FP, 48f: Orwell exposes how Language and meaning are being relativised, too, with hints on how to correct it

When we have to resort to Orwell, it is a sad sign of how far the rot has gone. LF&P 48, no 146: >>it seems language itself (so, dictionaries and other reference resources by extension . . .) is under the gun of the elephant game. Orwell wrote about Newspeak replacing Oldspeak in the interests Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Atheism Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Evolutionary materialism's amorality evolutionary materialism's self-falsification Governance & control vs anarchy Logic and First Principles of right reason Moving civilization forward

L&FP 48e: Plato’s anticipation of and exposure of radical relativism (and linked evolutionary materialism) c 360 BC in The Laws, Bk X

Now that the six blind men and the elephant paradigm is broken, we may look at Plato with fresh eyes. Here, 92 in LF&P 48a: >>Plato . . . is highly relevant to our own mutiny on the good ship civilisation. For, the lessons of sound history were bought with blood and tears; those who Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Education Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Logic and First Principles of right reason Moving civilization forward

L&FP, 48d: The failed six blind men of India paradigm for relativising thought, truth and knowledge

Again, let’s go out of chronological order in 48a (Plato comes later as there is a dismissive attitude) and speak to a paradigm story used to radically relativise our thinking from elementary school days on. Here, 143: >>In a world in which abstract processes such as logical inference and explicit argument are increasingly “other” and Read More…

agit-prop, opinion manipulation and well-poisoning games Defending our Civilization Epistemology (the study of knowledge and its conditions) Ethics Governance & control vs anarchy Lessons of History Logic and First Principles of right reason Moving civilization forward

L&FP 48c: Supplement, addressing the disappearance of core knowledge of first principles of right reason (aka Logic)

In the course of speaking to disappearance/restoration of moral knowledge, I realised that there was need to stop the rot on core right reason also. Accordingly, I commented at 153 in LF&P 48a, and as it is obviously logically prior, I now headline out of rough chronological order: The issue of self-referential incoherence, regrettably, does Read More…