Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

My Thought About Justice is Not Justice: Easy for ID; a Deal Killer for Materialism

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

At ENV Neurosurgeon Michael Egnor exposes how materialist metaphysics flounders on logical grounds in its theory of mind:

As an example, let us suppose that a certain pattern of neuronal activation in my cortex were shown to represent my thought about justice. Obviously that pattern is not my thought about justice itself — justice is a concept, not a bunch of neurons. And if that pattern of neuronal activation represented my thought about justice, it must map to my thought of justice, which presupposes my thought about justice and thus cannot explain it.

Succinctly, mental representation of abstract thought presupposes abstract thought, and cannot explain it. It is on abstract thought that materialism, as a theory of mind, flounders. Abstract thought, classically understood as intellect and will, are inherently immaterial. Any representation in the brain of abstract thought (while it may exist) necessarily presupposes abstract thought itself, which must, by its nature, be an immaterial power of the mind.

Comments
F/N: On the problem(s) of evil vs good, kindly cf. here in context on what is now a significantly de-fanged issue. KFkairosfocus
February 7, 2018
February
02
Feb
7
07
2018
02:54 AM
2
02
54
AM
PST
Further correction: The sleeping brain experiment is at the 16:30 minute mark Through The Wormhole s02e01 Is There Life After Death – video (16:30 minute mark) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7XhrDrqmXE4 Of note, the preceding video, after you sign up, can be watched in much better quality at this following site (season 2 episode 1) https://www.sciencechannel.com/tv-shows/through-the-wormhole/ Researchers: Deep sleep short-circuits brain’s grid of connectivity - September 29, 2005 Excerpt: Tononi and his team observed the disconnect when brief, magnetically generated pulses of electricity were directed to specific regions of the brain. The pulses stimulated an electrochemical response from the targeted cells, which, when the subject was awake, rippled across the brain, traveling along networks of nerve fibers to different cerebral destinations. But when the subject was in deep sleep, the same response was quickly extinguished and did not travel beyond the stimulated cells. When consciousness fades, according to Tononi, “the brain breaks down into little islands that can’t talk to one another.” https://news.wisc.edu/researchers-deep-sleep-short-circuits-brains-grid-of-connectivity/bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
07:24 PM
7
07
24
PM
PST
Whatever J-Mac, I'm happy with this 'possible' state of the evidence as it currently sits as it, i.e. life after death, is, as far as our best science can tell us, indeed very much a plausible possibility that has only gotten far stronger as our science has progressed. Guess for you personally, you will have to wait until you die to know for 100% certainty if you live after your material body dies. Myself, since the potential consequences are so great, I wager all on Christ in this life. i.e. Pascal's wager Matthew 10:28 Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell.bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
06:50 PM
6
06
50
PM
PST
Correction, Hameroff also holds to 'long range' quantum coherence in the brain, not just short range as I mistakenly thought: Quantum Entangled Consciousness - Life After Death - Stuart Hameroff - video (1:55 minute mark) https://youtu.be/jjpEc98o_Oo?t=118bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
06:40 PM
6
06
40
PM
PST
BA77@98 Possible? That's not what you've said... "I sure do wish people would stick to empirical evidence”. Remember? So, physician, cure yourself first!J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
06:18 PM
6
06
18
PM
PST
J-Mac, he said what he said,,,
"then it’s possible that this quantum information can exist outside the body. Perhaps indefinitely as a soul.” - Hameroff
spin it however it makes you feel better, but those are his exact words. You then said
"if consciousness is quantum, as he believes (he has no empirical evidence for it),"
First off, contrary to what you are implying, Hameroff's model was empirically confirmed:
New Study Favors Quantum Mind - Quantum coherence in brain protein resembles plant photosynthesis - 18-Sep-2014 Excerpt: Photosynthesis, the ubiquitous and essential mechanism by which plants produce food from sunlight, has been shown since 2006 to routinely utilize quantum coherence (quantum coherent superposition) at warm temperatures.,,, Back in the brain, microtubules are components of the cytoskeleton inside neurons, cylindrical lattice polymers of the protein ‘tubulin’.,,, now it appears quantum mechanisms eerily similar to those in photosynthesis may operate in tubulins within microtubules. In an article published September 17,, a team of scientists,, used computer simulation and theoretical quantum biophysics to analyze quantum coherence among tryptophan pi resonance rings in tubulin, the component protein in microtubules.,,, (They) mapped locations of the tryptophan pi electron resonance clouds in tubulin, and found them analogous to (the quantum coherent superposition of) chromophores in photosynthesis proteins.,,, Along with recent evidence for coherent megahertz vibrations in microtubules, and that anesthetics act to erase consciousness via microtubules, quantum brain biology will become increasingly important.,, http://www.newswise.com/articles/new-study-favors-quantum-mind#.VBusnOKcVcM.google_plusone_share
Moreover, there is further empirical evidence for a correlation between quantum entanglement and consciousness, (just not how Hameroff originally envisioned it i.e. he only got part of it,,),, At about the 21:45 minute mark of the following video, an interesting experiment on the sleeping brain is highlighted in which it is demonstrated that there is a fairly profound difference in in the way the brain ‘shares information’ between different parts of the brain in its sleeping state compared to how the brain ‘shares information’ in its waking state. i.e. In the sleeping state, the brain shares much less information with different parts of the brain than the brain does during our waking state.
Through The Wormhole s02e01 Is There Life After Death – video (21:46 minute mark) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7XhrDrqmXE4
Simply put, long range quantum correlations are present in a conscious brain, whereas in the sleeping brain the long range quantum correlations in the brain are, for the most part, missing
The Puzzling Role Of Biophotons In The Brain - Dec. 17, 2010 Excerpt: It’s certainly true that electrical activity in the brain is synchronised over distances that cannot be easily explained. Electrical signals travel too slowly to do this job, so something else must be at work.,,, ,,, It’s a big jump to assume that photons do this job. http://www.technologyreview.com/view/422069/the-puzzling-role-of-biophotons-in-the-brain/
You further stated
"then that quantum information after death dissipates into the universe at large…"
If you are trying to claim that quantum information 'dissipates' in the sense that quantum information spreads out and loses its coherence when it leaves the material body, then you the one who is making a claim for which you have no evidence, but are only making a claim to suit your own philosophical bias. Whereas, on the other hand, I can point to the fact that this quantum information is what maintained our material body's coherence during this temporal existence in the first place (not the material particles of the body). i.e. Darwinists, with reductive materialism, have no clue how the basic ‘form’ of any particular biological organism might be achieved during embryological development, or how that basic ‘form’ might be maintained for precisely a lifetime, and not a moment longer,,, whereas, on the other hand, I can point to evidence from quantum biology to support the view that it is quantum information that cohering the body into a 'form' for 'precisely a lifetime'
Darwinism vs Biological Form – video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyNzNPgjM4w The Unbearable Wholeness of Beings – Stephen L. Talbott – 2010 Excerpt: Virtually the same collection of molecules exists in the canine cells during the moments immediately before and after death. But after the fateful transition no one will any longer think of genes as being regulated, nor will anyone refer to normal or proper chromosome functioning. No molecules will be said to guide other molecules to specific targets, and no molecules will be carrying signals, which is just as well because there will be no structures recognizing signals. Code, information, and communication, in their biological sense, will have disappeared from the scientist’s vocabulary. ,,, the question, rather, is why things don’t fall completely apart — as they do, in fact, at the moment of death. What power holds off that moment — precisely for a lifetime, and not a moment longer? Despite the countless processes going on in the cell, and despite the fact that each process might be expected to “go its own way” according to the myriad factors impinging on it from all directions, the actual result is quite different. Rather than becoming progressively disordered in their mutual relations (as indeed happens after death, when the whole dissolves into separate fragments), the processes hold together in a larger unity. per – The New Atlantis Darwinian Materialism vs Quantum Biology – video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHdD2Am1g5Y
Moreover, I can produce evidence from thousands of Near Death testimonies that testify to the fact that a person does not 'dissipate' into the universe at large after the death of the material body, but indeed stays 'cohered' as a person. Thus, whilst you may not like the implications, as is evident in your post, the empirical evidence, none-the less, does indeed support my position.bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
06:13 PM
6
06
13
PM
PST
Kurx @96 Quantum consciousness is the closest science ever got to explaining it... I love Hameroff's passion... I think quantum consciousness could be real but I don't thing quantum information on it's own (quantum soul) can constitute consciousness... It needs a functioning brain... I think near-death-experiences are hallucinations... Thanks to quantum information conservation, resurrections described in the bible finally make sense to me...J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
06:08 PM
6
06
08
PM
PST
Hameroff himself explains quantum conciousness in an elegant and easy to grasp way: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQBpQaAGkno I don't think the "soul" exists, at least not in the usual conception, it seems that the concept is more linked to the ego and the natural desire to preserve one's personality and memories. But personality traits and memories are just burdens when you see the whole picture. Before embracing nonduality, at least in my personal case I've suffered a lot with my asperger's condition and my fears. Now I have more peace, more compassion... I meditate to escape de the self and try to grasp the nondual state of mind for a few moments. The concept of a "soul" may not be entirely wrong but is too limited, to conditioned to the western worldview.kurx78
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
05:55 PM
5
05
55
PM
PST
BA77 @92 "I sure do wish people would stick to empirical evidence". Empirical evidence? As you see it? Once you wrote empirical evidence I knew the "empirical evidence" for the Shroud of Turin was going to be mentioned somewhere... BTW: Hameroff is referring to consciousness that is generated in microtubules of brain neurons by quantum vibrations... https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/01/140116085105.htm Hameroff believes that quantum information doesn't get destroyed as per quantum information conservation... So, if consciousness is quantum, as he believes (he has no empirical evidence for it), then that quantum information after death dissipates into the universe at large... Now, he said it many times that he doesn't have a problem with peoples' beliefs, like yours, that quantum information after death continues on as a soul... That's not his inference. It's people like you who make this inference... Hameroff also believes that quantum information surviving after death supports many other beliefs of afterlife, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and many, many other beliefs that support reincarnation that quantum information conservation is useful for, especially when 300 pound Schwarzenegger gets reincarnated as a cockroach... It all makes perfect sense now...J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
05:32 PM
5
05
32
PM
PST
RVB: What happened to my mind when I was drunk last night? Did it sit that evening out? Large parts of an occasional evening are lost, and my physical brain has lost them, has the mind? RVB likes to use maybe his favorite mind altering substance to "prove" consciousness depends upon the brain. Its like when you unplug a flat screen TV, the TV show is over. In his mind that is. Conversely when the RVB show is over as it will be, he thinks his mind is over, tee hee. His life depends upon that belief. Life as he thinks it should be, and death too. Funny about how some of the other mind-altering substances around maybe have something to teach RVB about his mind, but he dare not go there. Doesn't want to learn too much about the mind after all. Quite interesting to ponder that conundrum. But guess what: people addicted to the above substance of the RVB post have some intriguing avenues out of addiction. And here is one where the participants invariably don't come out of it as committed materialists at all, quite the contrary as this report from Russia can show: http://whale.to/b/kungurtsev.htmlgroovamos
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
01:18 PM
1
01
18
PM
PST
Quantum criticality in a wide range of important biomolecules – Mar. 6, 2015 Excerpt: “Most of the molecules taking part actively in biochemical processes are tuned exactly to the transition point and are critical conductors,” they say. That’s a discovery that is as important as it is unexpected. “These findings suggest an entirely new and universal mechanism of conductance in biology very different from the one used in electrical circuits.” The permutations of possible energy levels of biomolecules is huge so the possibility of finding even one (biomolecule) that is in the quantum critical state by accident is mind-bogglingly small and, to all intents and purposes, impossible.,, of the order of 10^-50 of possible small biomolecules and even less for proteins,”,,, “what exactly is the advantage that criticality confers?” https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/the-origin-of-life-and-the-hidden-role-of-quantum-criticality-ca4707924552
Thus, take from it what you will, but the plain fact of the matter is that quantum entanglement/information, which has no possible materialistic explanation, and which indeed requires a beyond space and time cause to explain its existence, is now found to be pervasive within life. Moreover, to repeat, this quantum information is conserved in that it cannot be created nor destroyed. Thus, the question now becomes, 'where does this 'conserved' quantum information go when the material body dies?' ,,, Well, physics also provides some fairly compelling answers to that question as well: Whereas, atheists have no compelling evidence for the various parallel universe and/or multiverse scenarios that they have put forth,,
Multiverse Mania vs Reality – video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQJV4fH6kMo
,, Christians, on the other hand, can appeal directly to the higher dimensional mathematics behind Quantum Mechanics, Special Relativity and General Relativity to support their belief that God upholds this universe in its continual existence, as well as to support their belief in a heavenly dimension and in a hellish dimension.
Quantum Mechanics, Special Relativity, General Relativity and Christianity – video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKggH8jO0pk
Some people in the preceding comments on this thread continue to question just how important the ‘soul’ really is. ,,, Jesus held that your soul is worth more than the entire world.
Matthew 16:25-26 For whoever wants to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for My sake will find it. What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul? Jewel – Who will save your soul – Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LukEq643Mk
Myself, since He died to save us from the penalty of our sins, I take Jesus's assessment about the soul's worth very seriously:
Turin Shroud Hologram Reveals The Words "The Lamb" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Tmka1l8GAQ
bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
12:04 PM
12
12
04
PM
PST
J-Mac,
Wouldn’t that mean that quantum consciousness/soul is “emergent” in the sense that quantum information would have to be “generated” in microtubules of neurons in the brain in order create qualia, experiences and memories?
I sure do wish people would stick to empirical evidence,,, First off, the material brain, whilst it can host quantum entanglement, does not 'generate' quantum entanglement. i.e. quantum entanglement is a 'non-local' effect that demands a beyond space and time cause in order to explain the effect.
Looking beyond space and time to cope with quantum theory – 29 October 2012 Excerpt: “Our result gives weight to the idea that quantum correlations somehow arise from outside spacetime, in the sense that no story in space and time can describe them,” http://www.quantumlah.org/highlight/121029_hidden_influences.php
Despite all the il-founded hope of materialists that hidden variables between particles might someday explain away quantum non-locality,,
"When Bohm expressed "hope" that violations of QM (Quantum Mechanics) would be found later and hidden variables supported, Bohr responded that the strange sentence is almost isomorphic to "I hope that 2×2=5 will be proven at some point which will have a good effect on our finances." https://motls.blogspot.com/2015/12/how-term-copenhagen-interpretation-got.html
,,, The fact of the matter is that multiple mathematical theorems have all but proven that hidden variables between particles cannot explain away all of the bizarre behaviors seen in quantum mechanics.
The One Theory of Quantum Mechanics That Actually Kind of Makes Sense - But most physicists don't buy it. - Dec 1, 2016 Excerpt: pilot-wave theory requires that "hidden variables" exist,,, But despite Einstein's reservations, multiple mathematical theorems have all but proven that hidden variables cannot explain away all of the bizarre behaviors seen in quantum mechanics. The most recent and famous being John Stewart Bell's theorem, which concludes that, "No physical theory of local hidden variables can ever reproduce all of the predictions of quantum mechanics." http://www.popularmechanics.com/space/a24114/pilot-wave-quantum-mechanics-theory/
These multiple mathematical theorems that have all but falsified hidden variables between particles have now been experimentally confirmed in that it is now experimentally shown that "entangled objects do not cause each other to behave the way they do."
Quantum correlations do not imply instant causation – August 12, 2016 Excerpt: A research team led by a Heriot-Watt scientist has shown that the universe is even weirder than had previously been thought. In 2015 the universe was officially proven to be weird. After many decades of research, a series of experiments showed that distant, entangled objects can seemingly interact with each other through what Albert Einstein famously dismissed as “Spooky action at a distance”. A new experiment by an international team led by Heriot-Watt’s Dr Alessandro Fedrizzi has now found that the universe is even weirder than that: entangled objects do not cause each other to behave the way they do. http://phys.org/news/2016-08-quantum-imply-instant-causation.html
Whereas materialists have been thwarted in their efforts to explain away quantum entanglement, as a Christian, I have a beyond space and time cause to appeal to in order to explain quantum entanglement:
Colossians 1:17 He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together.
Moreover, the quantum information associated with quantum entanglement,,,
Quantum Entanglement and Information Quantum entanglement is a physical resource, like energy, associated with the peculiar nonclassical correlations that are possible between separated quantum systems. Entanglement can be measured, transformed, and purified. A pair of quantum systems in an entangled state can be used as a quantum information channel to perform computational and cryptographic tasks that are impossible for classical systems. The general study of the information-processing capabilities of quantum systems is the subject of quantum information theory. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qt-entangle/
,,, this quantum information is conserved in that it cannot be created nor destroyed,,,
Quantum no-hiding theorem experimentally confirmed for first time - 2011 Excerpt: In the classical world, information can be copied and deleted at will. In the quantum world, however, the conservation of quantum information means that information cannot be created nor destroyed. This concept stems from two fundamental theorems of quantum mechanics: the no-cloning theorem and the no-deleting theorem. A third and related theorem, called the no-hiding theorem, addresses information loss in the quantum world. According to the no-hiding theorem, if information is missing from one system (which may happen when the system interacts with the environment), then the information is simply residing somewhere else in the Universe; in other words, the missing information cannot be hidden in the correlations between a system and its environment. http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-03-quantum-no-hiding-theorem-experimentally.html Quantum no-deleting theorem Excerpt: A stronger version of the no-cloning theorem and the no-deleting theorem provide permanence to quantum information. To create a copy one must import the information from some part of the universe and to delete a state one needs to export it to another part of the universe where it will continue to exist. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_no-deleting_theorem#Consequence
The preceding facts are why Stuart Hameroff stated this obvious inference to the 'soul',,
“Let’s say the heart stops beating. The blood stops flowing. The microtubules lose their quantum state. But the quantum information, which is in the microtubules, isn’t destroyed. It can’t be destroyed. It just distributes and dissipates to the universe at large. If a patient is resuscitated, revived, this quantum information can go back into the microtubules and the patient says, “I had a near death experience. I saw a white light. I saw a tunnel. I saw my dead relatives.,,” Now if they’re not revived and the patient dies, then it's possible that this quantum information can exist outside the body. Perhaps indefinitely as a soul.” - Stuart Hameroff - Quantum Entangled Consciousness - Life After Death - video (5:00 minute mark) https://youtu.be/jjpEc98o_Oo?t=300
To add weight to Haneroff's inference, microtubles are far from the only biological molecules to exhibit quantum entanglement. Quantum entanglement is now found to be pervasive within biological molecules.
Darwinian Materialism vs Quantum Biology - video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHdD2Am1g5Y
bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
12:03 PM
12
12
03
PM
PST
Why doesn't he stop anything being less than perfect? Why doesn't he stop people from murdering? Why doesn't he stop manslaughter? Why doesn't he stop theft? Why doesn't he stop people not using their turn signals? Why doesn't he stop people from overeating? Why doesn't he stop people from being lazy? ... Why doesn't he stop every person in the universe from not being perfect in every way? But if he did that then there would be no decisions for us to make. The fact that we are even having this discussion illustrates that we do. On the other hand, if you are free to choose (one way or the other), then You are free to be lazy You are free to overeat You are free to not use your turn signal ... You are basically free to be as dastardly as you choose, including to other people. If you believe in free will, then you believe that evil is a very real, albeit undesirable, potential. So if you believe God gave man a free will, then a possibility for some measure of evil must exist, otherwise he would not be truly free. BUT, if you don't believe in free will, then everything we do is just an illusion of choice, and all bad choices are just the product of such an illusion. Our interpretations (thoughts) of what constitutes evil itself would likewise be part of the same illusion. But if all the things that we think are evil, and all that we construe the concept of evil as being - If these are merely the product of an illusion, how can they be actually be evil? The fact that we can even accept that evil is, in fact, evil, is predicated on the fact that our decisions and thoughts are more than just an illusion. And if our decisions are not just an illusion, then we do, at least in part, have a free will, and therefore the potential for evil, both conceptually and in actuality, must exist.outside_observer
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:48 AM
11
11
48
AM
PST
Then I was not talking to you…
Then there goes another Modern Sir Robin, unwilling to face a difficult question. Andrewasauber
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:18 AM
11
11
18
AM
PST
@88 WHY GOD DIDN'T STOP EVIL?J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:17 AM
11
11
17
AM
PST
@86 Depends on what the question is.outside_observer
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:15 AM
11
11
15
AM
PST
@85 Then I was not talking to you...J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:12 AM
11
11
12
AM
PST
O_O@83 Good question in the video...Any thoughts?J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:10 AM
11
11
10
AM
PST
It wasn’t meant to be scientific…
Then why would it it mean anything to me? Andrewasauber
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:10 AM
11
11
10
AM
PST
asauber @82 "I find your admonishment very unscientific. Or almost theological, if I may use the phrase." It was't meant to be scientific... I was a human admonishment... I always try to think what Jesus would say... Or "Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect.”-Mark TwainJ-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
11:07 AM
11
11
07
AM
PST
@81 J-Mac I agree that judging people individually is not the best way to go. In the case of ID, from a scientific standpoint it is about empirically evaluating the evidence for/against Intelligent Design. The question of "Why?" is more religious/philosophical than scientific in nature. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WV7OQV5eU2Ioutside_observer
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
10:21 AM
10
10
21
AM
PST
I would be very careful with judging people, including atheists/materialists…
J-Mac From one bag of judgemental ground beef to another, I find your admonishment very unscientific. Or almost theological, if I may use the phrase. Andrewasauber
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
10:19 AM
10
10
19
AM
PST
I would be very careful with judging people, including atheists/materialists... Many of them are at/mats because they are confused about the many religious teachings, including the immortality of the soul, eternal hellfire, limbo, purgatory and the prevalence of evil, but especially omnipotence and omniscience of God that implies that God knew that Adam and Eve would sin... I found that quite a few of them are searching for truth and not to support preconceived ideas, like many overconfident religious do...J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
09:52 AM
9
09
52
AM
PST
BA77 @75, Aren't you the big supporter of quantum consciousness that survives death as quantum soul? Wouldn't that mean that quantum consciousness/soul is "emergent" in the sense that quantum information would have to be "generated" in microtubules of neurons in the brain in order create qualia, experiences and memories?J-Mac
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
09:43 AM
9
09
43
AM
PST
Neither the soul nor the mind can be accounted for via purely materialistic processes. I don't know if they were intelligently designed, will into being or part of the whole.ET
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
09:02 AM
9
09
02
AM
PST
"Mind and soul are not the same." I realize that. But I presume that you believe that we have both. And if we were designed, does that not imply that both the soul and the mind are also designed? Or do you consider one or both to be emergent properties of the physical brain?Molson Bleu
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
08:59 AM
8
08
59
AM
PST
TWSYF @ 76 Ditto that. They whip out their canards with lightning swiftness, and just like that, you might as well be talking to a bag of ground beef... which they will assert they are anyway. Andrewasauber
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
08:46 AM
8
08
46
AM
PST
BA77 @ 75: "very few dogmatic atheists ever are honest..." Indeed.Truth Will Set You Free
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
08:30 AM
8
08
30
AM
PST
CR, as to your appeal to 'emergent magic', and not that you will ever be honest to the empirical evidence, (very few dogmatic atheists ever are honest), but for the sake of others who are reasonable, and contrary to claims from Darwinists who say immaterial information is merely 'emergent' from a material basis, immaterial information is now experimentally shown to be its own distinct physical entity that is separate from matter and energy.
Information is physical (but not how Rolf Landauer meant) - video https://youtu.be/H35I83y5Uro Demonic device converts information to energy – 2010 Excerpt: “This is a beautiful experimental demonstration that information has a thermodynamic content,” says Christopher Jarzynski, a statistical chemist at the University of Maryland in College Park. In 1997, Jarzynski formulated an equation to define the amount of energy that could theoretically be converted from a unit of information2; the work by Sano and his team has now confirmed this equation. “This tells us something new about how the laws of thermodynamics work on the microscopic scale,” says Jarzynski. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=demonic-device-converts-inform Maxwell’s demon demonstration (knowledge of a particle’s position) turns information into energy – November 2010 Excerpt: Scientists in Japan are the first to have succeeded in converting information into free energy in an experiment that verifies the “Maxwell demon” thought experiment devised in 1867.,,, In Maxwell’s thought experiment the demon creates a temperature difference simply from information about the gas molecule temperatures and without transferring any energy directly to them.,,, Until now, demonstrating the conversion of information to energy has been elusive, but University of Tokyo physicist Masaki Sano and colleagues have succeeded in demonstrating it in a nano-scale experiment. In a paper published in Nature Physics they describe how they coaxed a Brownian particle to travel upwards on a “spiral-staircase-like” potential energy created by an electric field solely on the basis of information on its location. As the particle traveled up the staircase it gained energy from moving to an area of higher potential, and the team was able to measure precisely how much energy had been converted from information. - per physorg Scientists show how to erase information without using energy – January 2011 Excerpt: Until now, scientists have thought that the process of erasing information requires energy. But a new study shows that, theoretically, information can be erased without using any energy at all.,,, “Landauer said that information is physical because it takes energy to erase it. We are saying that the reason it (information) is physical has a broader context than that.”, Vaccaro explained. - per physorg Matter, energy… knowledge: - May 11, 2016 Running a brain-twisting thought experiment for real shows that information is a physical thing – so can we now harness the most elusive entity in the cosmos? https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg23030730-200-demon-no-more-physics-most-elusive-entity-gives-up-its-secret/ New Scientist astounds: Information is physical – May 13, 2016 Excerpt: Recently came the most startling demonstration yet: a tiny machine powered purely by information, which chilled metal through the power of its knowledge. This seemingly magical device could put us on the road to new, more efficient nanoscale machines, a better understanding of the workings of life, and a more complete picture of perhaps our most fundamental theory of the physical world. https://uncommondescent.com/news/new-scientist-astounds-information-is-physical/ Information engine operates with nearly perfect efficiency - Lisa Zyga - January 19, 2018 Excerpt: Physicists have experimentally demonstrated an information engine—a device that converts information into work—with an efficiency that exceeds the conventional second law of thermodynamics. Instead, the engine's efficiency is bounded by a recently proposed generalized second law of thermodynamics, and it is the first information engine to approach this new bound.,,, The generalized second law of thermodynamics states that the work extracted from an information engine is limited by the sum of two components: the first is the free energy difference between the final and initial states (this is the sole limit placed on conventional engines by the conventional second law), and the other is the amount of available information (this part sets an upper bound on the extra work that can be extracted from information). To achieve the maximum efficiency set by the generalized second law, the researchers in the new study designed and implemented an information engine made of a particle trapped by light at room temperature. Random thermal fluctuations cause the tiny particle to move slightly due to Brownian motion, and a photodiode tracks the particle's changing position with a spatial accuracy of 1 nanometer. If the particle moves more than a certain distance away from its starting point in a certain direction, the light trap quickly shifts in the direction of the particle. This process repeats, so that over time the engine transports the particle in a desired direction simply by extracting work from the information it obtains from the system's random thermal fluctuations (the free energy component here is zero, so it does not contribute to the work extracted). One of the most important features of this system is its nearly instantaneous feedback response: the trap shifts in just a fraction of a millisecond, giving the particle no time to move further and dissipate energy. As a result, almost none of the energy gained by the shift is lost to heat, but rather nearly all of it is converted into work. By avoiding practically any information loss, the information-to-energy conversion of this process reaches approximately 98.5% of the bound set by the generalized second law. The results lend support for this bound, and illustrate the possibility of extracting the maximum amount of work possible from information. https://phys.org/news/2018-01-efficiency.html What is information? - animated video (May 2016) Quote: “If information is not (physically) real then neither are we” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AvIOzVJMCM
Although the preceding is certainly very strong evidence for the physical reality of immaterial information, the coup de grace for demonstrating that immaterial information is its own distinct physical entity, separate from matter and energy, is Quantum Teleportation:
Quantum Teleportation Enters the Real World – September 19, 2016 Excerpt: Two separate teams of scientists have taken quantum teleportation from the lab into the real world. Researchers working in Calgary, Canada and Hefei, China, used existing fiber optics networks to transmit small units of information across cities via quantum entanglement — Einstein’s “spooky action at a distance.”,,, This isn’t teleportation in the “Star Trek” sense — the photons aren’t disappearing from one place and appearing in another. Instead, it’s the information that’s being teleported through quantum entanglement.,,, ,,, it is only the information that gets teleported from one place to another. http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/d-brief/2016/09/19/quantum-teleportation-enters-real-world/#.V-HqWNEoDtR
If Darwinian evolution were treated as a falsifiable science by Darwinists, instead of being jealously protected from empirical falsification, then these empirical findings showing that immaterial information is its own distinct physical entity separate from matter and energy should have been the experimental death blow against the foundational claims of Darwinists who claim that immaterial information is merely 'emergent' from a material basis. But alas, the empirical evidence never really mattered to Darwinists in the first place. Which is yet more proof that Darwinism is, in reality, a religion instead of a science.
Talking Evolution With Evolutionists - Cornelius Hunter - December 2011 Excerpt: "Like the cultist I spoke with, evolutionists are certain even though the facts do not support such certainty.,,," "You can present the facts, you can walk through the logic, you can review the experiments, and you can tally up the findings. It doesn’t matter. It never did matter because, ultimately, evolution never was about the science." http://darwins-god.blogspot.com/2011/12/talking-evolution-with-evolutionists.html "Evolution is promoted by its practitioners as more than mere science. Evolution is promulgated as an ideology, a secular religion—a full-fledged alternative to Christianity, with meaning and morality,,, Evolution is a religion. This was true of evolution in the beginning, and it is true of evolution still today." Darwinian atheist Michael Ruse - Prominent Atheistic Philosopher
bornagain77
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
08:20 AM
8
08
20
AM
PST
Michael Egnor writes:
Thoughts may be divided into thoughts about particulars and thoughts about universals. Thoughts about particulars are thoughts, including perceptions, imagination, memory, etc., about particular objects in our environments. Thoughts about my coffee, or my car, or my family would be thoughts about particulars. Thoughts about universals are abstract thoughts, and are thoughts about concepts. Justice, mercy, logic, mathematics, etc., are abstract thoughts.
Truth is also a universal concept. For example, naturalism/materialism makes a universal truth claim when it claims that mind and consciousness are the result of some kind of mindless and purposeless “natural” process. But, how do we know that is true? So far, at least as far as I can see, none of our nat/mat interlocutors have provided any proof that their universal truth claims about mind and consciousness are true. All they have are beliefs and opinions which they believe are true. But believing something to be true doesn’t make it true. For example, at one time virtually everyone believed that the earth was the center of the universe, however, the truth was that it wasn’t. So, just having strong opinions and beliefs doesn’t establish the truth about anything.john_a_designer
February 6, 2018
February
02
Feb
6
06
2018
08:12 AM
8
08
12
AM
PST
1 2 3 4 5 6