Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Evolution Was the Key in Joseph Campbell’s Loss of Faith

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Joseph Campbell died in 1987 but remains influential. In this revealing video, Campbell clarifies why he left the Roman Catholic faith of his youth — EVOLUTION:

While many try to reconcile their faith with evolution, many find in evolution reason to leave the faith. Just because there’s no strict contradiction between the two doesn’t mean that the two aren’t in tension. Campbell felt the tension and left the faith.

SOURCE: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJmNBxbExuA

Postscript [added 06.14.09, 7:40AM CST]: It’s interesting to see Campbell disparage the biblical cosmology for being several millennia old and thus out of touch with current cosmologies — myths that impact our lives being myths that are compatible with contemporary cosmologies, according to Campbell. But when I studied ancient near eastern cosmologies at Princeton Theological Seminary, I found an interesting thing: they divided into cosmologies in which creation occurs through a spoken word by a supreme deity (the biblical cosmology was not unique in this regard) and cosmologies in which natural forces evolve and do all the creating, producing better and more powerful deities as time flows along (e.g., the Babylonian creation, in which Marduk is born several generations down and finally becomes the chief god). Given that this is an information age and that the Bible teaches that God created the world through a spoken word, would it not follow that the biblical cosmology is actually back in the saddle and ready again to engage culture? It would seem then that the provenance and length of time that a cosmology has been with us need not sap it of its cultural relevance or impact.

Comments
riddick: The theological point you raise is irrelevant. Yes, from God's perspective, God knows from eternity who are His and who are not His. But from a human vantage, we find people confessing the faith and then leaving the faith and giving reasons why they left the faith. Evolution is one of the prime reasons given. I regard this as significant. It raises the counterfactual question, Where would Joseph Campbell's faith be if a cogent refutation of evolution had been available when he was first exposed to it? If you have a problem with this question, then ask yourself if you have a problem with the following question: Where would Riddick's faith be if someone hadn't present him with the Gospel? William Dembski
June 13, 2009
June
06
Jun
13
13
2009
07:35 PM
7
07
35
PM
PDT
Campbell can say whatever he wants, and Dembski is free to believe him. But the scriptures make it clear that no one "leaves the faith." One either rejects Christ and remains lost, or one is saved at some time and remains saved forever. There is no middle ground, and no going back and forth. Otherwise, Jesus, who promised "to never leave us nor forsake us" is a liar. Based on his own testimony, it appears that Campbell was never a believer in the first place (1John 2:19).riddick
June 13, 2009
June
06
Jun
13
13
2009
07:28 PM
7
07
28
PM
PDT
1 3 4 5

Leave a Reply