Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

The Primordial Goo

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

In light of the challenge proposed to ID in the previous post (i.e., “The Intelligent Design Zoo”), here is a parallel challenge directed at materialistic evolutionists: Take the goo depicted in the photo below, autoclave it until none of the organic material here belongs to living cells (i.e., till all the cells are dead), and then try to reconstitute life without teleological guidance. Origin-of-life researchers typically focus on trying to obtain more complicated biomolecules from simpler ones. Here you’ve got all the complicated biomolecules you could ever want. Go to it — show us how, out of the material here once autoclaved, to get a living being that has all the characteristics we ordinarily attribute to life (i.e., reproduction, growth, metabolism, homeostasis, stimulus-response repetoire, adaptability to changing environments, maintenance of organizational boundaries).

Comments
Then again. Nothing is totally random.a5b01zerobone
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
05:06 PM
5
05
06
PM
PDT
This is totally random, but I was wondering, how do most Design Theorists view the relationship between Neanderthal and modern Homo sapiens?a5b01zerobone
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
04:45 PM
4
04
45
PM
PDT
We should establish a 24/7 Materialist-only Goo-Watch.Michaels7
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
04:06 PM
4
04
06
PM
PDT
These people insist that the most complex biological processes and finely-tuned cosmological constants have a naturalistic origin and are always quick to throw out the tired old designer/God red herring. Why stop there? Why not carry their line of argumentation to its rational end? Why not just say that no design can be rationally inferred anywhere--even from human sources? You could try to elucidate the epistemic consequences of their argumentation to them (and, indeed, I've tried more times than I should), but in the end you just discover that they're so completely blinded by their materialist ideology that their critical thinking skills appear to be permanently impared.crandaddy
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
03:41 PM
3
03
41
PM
PDT
If a person believes that chemicals have the hocus-pocus wherewithal to organize into living systems, then they will believe in anything.apollo230
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
02:52 PM
2
02
52
PM
PDT
Ya, where did they get the goo? What's more, where did they get the energy that comprises the atoms and physical laws that governs the atoms that allow the goo to exist? Maybe a better challenge would be to get something, anything, out of nothing as the materialists propose somehow happened.Jehu
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
02:49 PM
2
02
49
PM
PDT
er..where did they get the goo?M.Olson
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
02:38 PM
2
02
38
PM
PDT
Or just take any recently dead body and make it, well, alive. Should be no problem. Forming DNA is the hard part of abiogenesis, right?tribune7
January 15, 2007
January
01
Jan
15
15
2007
02:17 PM
2
02
17
PM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply