Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Bob Argues With a Saudi About Whether it is Good to Execute Homosexuals

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

While Saudi Arabia is in the news, I have a question for our subjectivist friends.  In the United States it is considered morally wrong to execute a person for being a homosexual.  In Saudi Arabia it is considered morally right to execute a person for being a homosexual.

As I understand subjectivist reasoning, morality is subjective and culturally determined.  If you were in Saudi Arabia I assume you would attempt to get them to change their mind about executing homosexuals.  I am curious.  How would you argue for that?  I can imagine a subjectivist (let’s call him “Bob”) making a number of arguments, and a probable response from a Saudi:

  1. Bob: Executing people because they are homosexual is morally reprehensible.

Saudi:  That’s just your opinion Bob.  In my opinion executing people because they are homosexual is morally correct and laudable.  And you yourself tell me that your personal subjective view on the matter is no “better,” in any meaningful sense of that word, than mine.  So why should I care what you think?

  1. Bob: It is not just my opinion.  The people of the United States believe it is immoral to execute a person for being homosexual.  The Saudi people should be more like the American people.

Saudi:  Why?  The analysis does not change when you compare your group to mine.  Your own principles as a subjectivist tell me that the American view on the matter is no better, in any meaningful sense of that word, than the Saudi view.

  1. Bob: Don’t you believe in moral progress?  Every progressive nation believes that executing homosexuals is wrong.  Don’t you want to be progressive?

Saudi:  “Progressive”?  By what standard are you progressive?  Again, it is merely your opinion whether you are progressive.  Your own first principles say there is no objective standard by which progress toward “progressive” goals can be measured.  And I disagree.  We consider your coddling of homosexuals not to be progressive but decadent.

  1. Bob: Do you not care that the Western world rejects your views on this matter.

Saudi:  First, you are wrong.  Some progressive Westerners – the ones that understand their own premises forbid them from judging us – say “who am I to judge the Saudis.”  Second, no, I don’t care what you and your friends think Bob.  What is more, you yourself cannot give me a reason why I should care about what you and your friends think.  Besides, I will turn it back on you:  Don’t you care that the whole Islamic world rejects your views on the matter?

What am I missing?  The one argument that Bob can never logically make is that it is actually objectively wrong (as opposed to wrong in his humble opinion) to execute homosexuals.

Comments
Bob O'H
One thing I’ve never seen . . .
Truer words were never spoken. There is none so blind as he who refuses to see. They have been shown to you many times Bob.Barry Arrington
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
01:45 PM
1
01
45
PM
PST
jdk
So I accept that you, and everyone, have your own personally chosen moral codes, but that doesn’t mean I have to accept every action that flows from beliefs that are in conflcit with my own.
You have to accept that the other subjective moral code has the same value of goodness or correctness as your own. You have no basis for saying that your opposing view is more correct than theirs. You have to believe that their moral code is good and correct for them. But that's the contradiction. You may not like the effects that their subjective morality has on your life. So, you have to affirm that their moral code is good for them, but at the same time it is a moral code that you oppose. That doesn't make sense. If their moral code is good for them, they have subjective reasons for it just like you - then the affects of that code are good also. You refer frequently to a "clash". Yes, that clash is this contradiction. It's the clash caused by an irrational worldview. It is not possible to affirm the rightness of contradictory moral codes - which actually oppose each other. Killing homosexuals. "It's your subjective code, so it is good and valid for you. But I have my own subjective code which is good for me and which opposes yours. So, I affirm the goodness and validity of both codes." To merely say that this is a "clash" that is normal in society is not enough. Subjectivism itself causes this clash which is actually the attempt to embrace contradictory and opposed viewpoints.Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
01:42 PM
1
01
42
PM
PST
An argument must be based on objective referents, as Stephen points out in 14.
One thing I've never seen is a statement of these objective moral referents, and a demonstration that they are objective. It seems to me that without that this whole discussion is pointless: if we don't know what these objective referents are, then don't we have to operate subjectively?Bob O'H
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
01:34 PM
1
01
34
PM
PST
"For a man to lie down with another man is an abomination before God." Leviticus 20:13 I'm guessing a lot of the "Christian" responders are pretty selective in which parts of the Bible they actually consider to form the basis of Morality. I would also note that in his "Germania", Tacitus describes the German custom of taking any homosexual they discovered and wrapping him in a wicker basket. The basket was then placed on the edge of a stream, and the WHOLE VILLAGE walked across the basket, pressing it down into the mud, where it was left to rot. Tacitus considered this a CLEAR example of the admirable culture of the otherwise barbaric Germans. I think a Scotch judge finally refused to condemn a "witch" to death in the late 1600s. Several witches had been executed in the preceding generation or so. (Suffer ye not a witch to live). And of course for several centuries after Cromwell's invasion, a man could be executed for simply BEING a Catholic priest, regardless of whether he preached or celebrated the mass. Today Moslems regularly execute Christians (hundreds have been executed in Africa in the last month) for Blasphemy because Christians declare that Jesus is God. Christians clearly don't accept the Moslems' Morality, and Moslems clearly don't accept the Christian's Morality. So there ain't much point in arguing about any CLEAR or PERMANENT point of Morality. Morality is specific to a time and a community, and liable to change in less than a generation.vmahuna
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
12:44 PM
12
12
44
PM
PST
Stephen writes at 24,
The crux of your argument is that *everyone* (including the Saudi) is entitled to construct his or her own moral code and, for that reason, everyone’s personal moral code should be accepted on that basis.
Interesting: there are two statements here, written as if the first necessarily implies the second, but that is false. I accept that you, Stephen (to make this less abstract) have moral codes that you have constructed for yourself, and you are "entitled" to do so. I have moral codes that are different then yours. I support your right to have your moral codes, but I still can, and will, when the opportunity arises, resist your acting on your moral codes if it impacts situations that I am involved in. Among other things, the difference is between beliefs and actions (although of course the two are related). I support your right to have moral beliefs different from mine, but I am not obligated to just take a laissez faire attitude towards your actions. Your actions impact the world of which I am a part: I will act in ways that reflect my beliefs, and you in ways that reflect your beliefs, and we may therefore clash in some way or another. The extend to which I respond to such situations depends on both opportunity (there are many situations that are completely out of my sphere of influence), the importance I attach to the issue, and the extent to which your actions may influence the larger communities which I care about. For instance, to be more abstract, if one has moral objections to dancing, and that affects how they live their life around others, I really don't care. If someone is working to make same-sex marriage illegal, for instance, than I will be active in opposing that. The world is full of these type of competing interactions, every day. We are all trying to live according to our principles, and we have to struggle sometimes when we run into competing beliefs. So I accept that you, and everyone, have your own personally chosen moral codes, but that doesn't mean I have to accept every action that flows from beliefs that are in conflcit with my own. We have to engage with this world, and our principles and values are a major part of what informs that engagement.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
12:36 PM
12
12
36
PM
PST
JDK Stephen was correct. Right use of reason is connected with the objective vs the subjective. Right use of reason requires an objective foundation of fact outside of the person using the reasoning techniques. Any result derived from a reasoning process is only as strong as its foundation. Having your own opinion is always OK as long as you recognize and admit that it is only an opinion. However, your opinion is no better than another's opinion, even when you get him to change his mind. I can see two situations where your opinion is dominant to another's opinions: 1 - You have power over the person and the person is trying to please you or could be harmed by you. 2 - You are objectively superior to the person and the person is objectively required to accept that superiority. Subjectivity comes from its source - the subject. The question is whether the subjects are equal. If equal, then there is nothing to rate one opinion better than another. If not equal, it seems like we are getting into an hierarchy issue. Seems like it may lead to God!GCS
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
12:30 PM
12
12
30
PM
PST
"Tell me GUN and JDK, why should the Saudi care about your personal preferences on the matter." Why don't you tell us why they should care about your personal preference for an objective basis to morality?Mimus
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:56 AM
11
11
56
AM
PST
jdk: The “subjectivist” doesn’t deny reason. Oh, but he does. Reason and the natural moral law are inextricably tied together. To deny one is to deny the other.
Why did you parenthetically throw that in there?
Good question. The investigation begins with self-evident truths (it is wrong to torture babies for fun) and develops develops through the use of reason (if it is wrong to torture babies for fun, then it is also wrong to torture adults for fun - and so on). Or again, if individuals have a moral right to defend themselves against aggressors, then so do nations, which are collections of individuals.StephenB
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:52 AM
11
11
52
AM
PST
jdk
However, if there were a Saudi here in my town that I knew and had these beliefs and yet also had a personal relationship with me, then I might be able to have some influence in their changing their beliefs.
Once again, you miss the point of your own contradiction. The crux of your argument is that *everyone* (including the Saudi) is entitled to construct his or her own moral code and, for that reason, everyone's personal moral code should be accepted on that basis. You are not accepting his moral code if you are also trying to change it.StephenB
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:39 AM
11
11
39
AM
PST
Stephen writes,
The subjectivist, on the other hand, who denies objective morality (and reason) ...
The "subjectivist" doesn't deny reason. Why did you parenthetically throw that in there?jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:31 AM
11
11
31
AM
PST
Barry writes,
JDK: “There is no reason why the Saudi’s should care about my beliefs” JDK goes to the head of the class. It is rare and refreshing (if nevertheless tragic) when a subjectivist admits the glaring truth that everyone else sees.
What? How about quoting the rest of what I said:
However, if there were a Saudi here in my town that I knew and had these beliefs and yet also had a personal relationship with me, then I might be able to have some influence in their changing their beliefs.
We influence other's beliefs through human interaction. The Saudi's know nothing about me our my beliefs, so obviously they don't care about them. They don't care about your beliefs, either. I think you made something out of my statement that is not there.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:28 AM
11
11
28
AM
PST
goodusername:
More likely the Saudi would respond that it’s objectively morally correct to execute homosexuals.
Most likely.
I don’t know how someone who believes that it’s objective morally wrong to execute homosexuals would respond to the Saudi.
He would explain that the Saudi was following the Islamists skewed and incomplete interpretation of objective morality, which recognizes the evil of sodomy but fails to recognize the inherent dignity of all humans. The objective natural moral law, based on reason, recognizes both. The subjectivist, on the other hand, who denies objective morality (and reason), must acknowledge that the Saudi's rationale for arriving at a *personal* morality is no better or worse than his own, both of which are based on the same amoral principle: "It is my decision based on my reasons and is justified on that basis alone." It follows, therefore, that the subjectivist has no grounds for disagreeing with the Saudi's skewed perception of morality.StephenB
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:16 AM
11
11
16
AM
PST
I choose to have convictions, and to live by my convictions. That’s all I can do: that’s all anybody can do.
Hold on there, jdk. It's not all anybody can do. You should be able to, and especially as a science-minded person, be able to give me a compelling reason why I should pay attention at all to anything you think and say, based on your stated position. Your position screams that it's admittedly no better than anyone else's. The problem is compounded by the fact that you won't tell people you don't really believe your own position is and could never be any better than anyone else's. Andrewasauber
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:14 AM
11
11
14
AM
PST
JDK: "There is no reason why the Saudi’s should care about my beliefs" JDK goes to the head of the class. It is rare and refreshing (if nevertheless tragic) when a subjectivist admits the glaring truth that everyone else sees.Barry Arrington
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:13 AM
11
11
13
AM
PST
Barry writes,
An argument must be based on objective referents.
Same mistake as Stephen. If there are no objective referents, then that is a meaningless claim. Barry writes,
The point of the OP, which the A-Mats have, unsurprisingly, ignored, is there is no reason in the world that I can think of why the Saudi should care what your personal preferences are. Tell me GUN and JDK, why should the Saudi care about your personal preferences on the matter?
I am not ignoring that. There is no reason why the Saudi's should care about my beliefs, and I am in no position to have any influence over them. However, if there were a Saudi here in my town that I knew and had these beliefs and yet also had a personal relationship with me, then I might be able to have some influence in their changing their beliefs. P.S. I am not an "A-Mat"jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:07 AM
11
11
07
AM
PST
re 14: Let me complete Stephen' sentence
If objective referents don’t exist, then no moral argument can be justified [ by reference to objective referents.]
That is a tautology. If objective referents don't exist, then what? That is the question I am addressing I agree that I can't prove that you are wrong to be against same-sex marriage, for instance, but I can live my life according to the belief that allowing same-sex marriage is right, not wrong, and do what I can to convince others to adopt that belief also. I choose to have convictions, and to live by my convictions. That's all I can do: that's all anybody can do.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
11:01 AM
11
11
01
AM
PST
It is amusing to watch subjectivists squirm when the incoherence of their moral views is put in their face. They say I would argue thus and so, all the while sticking their head in the sand and avoiding the question raised in the OP. An argument must be based on objective referents, as Stephen points out in 14. To argue means that one points to inter-subjective premises that lead to a logically compelled conclusion. "In my opinion you should not execute homosexuals" is not an argument. It is an expression of a personal preference. The point of the OP, which the A-Mats have, unsurprisingly, ignored, is there is no reason in the world that I can think of why the Saudi should care what your personal preferences are. Tell me GUN and JDK, why should the Saudi care about your personal preferences on the matter? RJ Sawyer has been shown the exist for attempting to derail the discussion with lies (which I have deleted) about me.Barry Arrington
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:54 AM
10
10
54
AM
PST
I don’t know how someone who believes that it’s objective morally wrong to execute homosexuals would respond to the Saudi.
It's a theological problem and has to be argued within the context of Islam which has its roots in Catholicism. Islamic moral norms are based on divine fiat and therefore the understanding of Allah, Mohammed and the Koran is necessary. To argue against moral norms of Islamic countries is to argue against the religion itself, or at least to show that a parallel and better interpretation is available within Islam (that's what liberal Muslims try to do).Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:47 AM
10
10
47
AM
PST
jdk:
Saying, “well, you can’t really justify your choices because they are nothing but your choices – they don’t have an objective referent”, is, in my opinion, empty rhetoric that, among things, is wrong because it assumes, without proof, that such objective referents can even exist.
It doesn't assume that objective referents exist. It assumes only that they are necessary to make the argument (to justify the choice(s)). If objective referents don't exist, then no moral argument can be justified.StephenB
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:34 AM
10
10
34
AM
PST
Saudi: That’s just your opinion Bob. In my opinion executing people because they are homosexual is morally correct and laudable.
More likely the Saudi would respond that it's objectively morally correct to execute homosexuals. I don't know how someone who believes that it's objective morally wrong to execute homosexuals would respond to the Saudi.goodusername
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:13 AM
10
10
13
AM
PST
jdk
I am saying that, taking into account everything I know, both from within and without me, I have chosen to live by certain values, and it’s a matter of my own integrity to put my beliefs and actions before the world. That’s my freely chosen choice.
Yes, exactly. The other subjectivist does the same thing you do. So, on that basis - you have to fully accept that the moral norms of the other person are completely correct and good, for that person. You have no grounds to say that person's moral norms are incorrect or wrong.Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:09 AM
10
10
09
AM
PST
RJS
True. But I can give a damn good reason, backed up by logic and rational reason, why in is subjectively wrong. Shouldn’t that be enough?
I don't think logic or rationality are required to show that something is subjectively right or wrong. Subjectively means that the person has their own reason and moral norm - so, it is right for them. They think one thing is good another bad. Whether that is illogical or not is irrelevant. Otherwise, we would have to say "all moral norms much be logical". But that's an objective norm itself. We might say that "it's illogical to follow the moral norms of a mythical god". Yes, but in the subjectivist view, it doesn't matter how one created the morality or what it is based on. Ultimately, it is whatever the person decides. Then, once a person say "I subjectively believe this is good or bad" - then there is no way to say the person is wrong.Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:05 AM
10
10
05
AM
PST
You’re saying that your moral norms are better, more correct, than theirs.
No, that is not what I am saying. I am saying that, taking into account everything I know, both from within and without me, I have chosen to live by certain values, and it's a matter of my own integrity to put my beliefs and actions before the world. That's my freely chosen choice. This is not, as I said to Barry, a matter of what I consider somewhat sophomoric armchair philosophy, it is a matter about how a full-fledged human being chooses to live in the world, and interact with other human beings. Saying, "well, you can't really justify your choices because they are nothing but your choices - they don't have an objective referent", is, in my opinion, empty rhetoric that, among things, is wrong because it assumes, without proof, that such objective referents can even exist. They don't. Therefore, the responsibility lies with each one of us to make choices about our values. This is true for all of us: Barry, you, everyone. Can I prove that this is the right way to look at things? No. But I can tell you that it is the way I look at things, and you can decide for yourself what to make of it. That's the way it works.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
10:00 AM
10
10
00
AM
PST
SA
In a subjectivist view that is true. It cannot logically assert that executing any class of people is objectively wrong.
True. But I can give a damn good reason, backed up by logic and rational reason, why in is subjectively wrong. Shouldn’t that be enough?R J Sawyer
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:34 AM
9
09
34
AM
PST
jdk I don't think you addressed it. When you disagree with the other morality, you're rejecting the validity (goodness, rightness) of their moral choice. You're saying that your moral norms are better, more correct, than theirs. But that is not possible since your moral norms are just your subjective views - you are not superior to them. They have their own views. Why do you not respect the rightness of the morality that they have?Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:32 AM
9
09
32
AM
PST
RJS
The one argument that Bob can never logically make is that it is actually objectively wrong (as opposed to wrong in his humble opinion) to execute homosexuals.
In a subjectivist view that is true. It cannot logically assert that executing any class of people is objectively wrong. I have heard abortion-advocates use this approach in pointing to the benefits of executing poor people, or handicapped. Some take it farther - Peter Singer, for example - and state that infanticide has a moral benefit and should be permitted. I think that's basically what atheism gives us. Killing homosexuals is good for somebody, it fit someone's subjective moral norms, so it is morally permissible. Simply disagreeing with someone's subjective morality is not enough to claim that your morals are better than the others'.Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:29 AM
9
09
29
AM
PST
re 6. That question I addressed in 2, if you'd like to comment on what I said.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:27 AM
9
09
27
AM
PST
jdk Ok, I didn't read it that way but I see your point. It still remains a contradiction. If one's subjective view is enough to validate the rightness of a moral position, then on what basis would you argue against someone's morality? They have their subjective reasons, so it must be right for them. True?Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:20 AM
9
09
20
AM
PST
re 3: SA, those are two sets of questions. The OP is not about why one shouldn't execute a homosexual (your first two questions), but about how we deal with people who have different views than we do, and feel just as strongly about them as we do about ours. That was the question I addressed in 2.jdk
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
09:11 AM
9
09
11
AM
PST
jdk
Simple. I would explain all the reasons why I think it is wrong.
I think that's the question. What is your argument? What are all your reasons? Why should someone accept your viewpoint on this?Silver Asiatic
October 22, 2018
October
10
Oct
22
22
2018
08:58 AM
8
08
58
AM
PST
1 … 7 8 9 10