Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Convergent evolution? Crown of Thorns starfish shows “surprising” chordate-like gene organization

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email
Crown of Thorns starfish/Yuna Zayasu

An intact Hox cluster. From ScienceDaily:

New research published in the journal genesis, by Kenneth Baughman, Dr. Eiichi Shoguchi, Professor Noriyuki Satoh of the Marine Genomics Unit at the Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University, and collaborators from Australia, reports an intact Hox cluster in the Crown of Thorns starfish, Acanthaster planci. This surprising result contrasts with the relatively disorganized Hox cluster found in sea urchins, which are also echinoderms, classification of animals including starfish, sea lilies, and sea cucumbers. Stanford University Professor Christopher Lowe, who studies developmental biology in echinoderms, summarizes the paper: “The translocation of the Hox cluster in echinoderms has been a major red herring for understanding their evolution. It’s really good to have some hard data showing that some echinoderms exhibit some oddities that are not representative of all echinoderms.”

Generally, the Hox cluster shows “colinearity,” in which gene order correlates with the location of expression, or the developmental stage of expression. “For example, anterior Hox genes are expressed in regions that are closer to the head of an embryo, and are expressed sooner during development, versus the posterior Hox genes,” explained Baughman. “Thus, we were surprised to see chordate-like Hox cluster organization in starfish, which have a radial body plan.” Echinoderms are classical model organisms for embryology, and more recently evo-devo. Baughman added, “Interacting with the speakers and students of theOIST Winter Course ‘Evolution of Complex Systems’ (OWECS) allowed me to appreciate the importance of finding an intact Hox cluster in starfish.”

Follow UD News at Twitter!

By the way, it is a pretty remarkable life form anyway.

Comments
Did the study "surprise" you?PaV
December 18, 2014
December
12
Dec
18
18
2014
08:17 AM
8
08
17
AM
PST
Thanks for answering the question, wd400. So this one is common ancestry rather than convergent evolution? Shows how things have changed, that one must now ask (convergence is everywhere). One day, the News desker will be wondering if it is HGT instead (with some reason). And then next, “Thus, we were surprised to see chordate-like Hox cluster organization in starfish, which have a radial body plan.” So WHY were they surprised?News
December 18, 2014
December
12
Dec
18
18
2014
03:14 AM
3
03
14
AM
PST
Is convergent evolution welcome to evolutionary biology? I say its not and is a excuse to explain away unlikely common designs in unrelated creatures with mutations being selected on. They mind a few. Yet convergence everywhere is not desired by evolutionists. It is by ideas of common design. The better the investigation of nature the more nature looks designed. Like answers for like needs in a biology that seeks the simple path.Robert Byers
December 17, 2014
December
12
Dec
17
17
2014
11:49 PM
11
11
49
PM
PST
I don't know anything about development in echinoderms, but I do know what "convergent" means...wd400
December 17, 2014
December
12
Dec
17
17
2014
05:46 PM
5
05
46
PM
PST
wd400: Here's what they say:
“For example, anterior Hox genes are expressed in regions that are closer to the head of an embryo, and are expressed sooner during development, versus the posterior Hox genes,” explained Baughman. “Thus, we were surprised to see chordate-like Hox cluster organization in starfish, which have a radial body plan.
They're surprised. Why aren't you?PaV
December 17, 2014
December
12
Dec
17
17
2014
04:50 PM
4
04
50
PM
PST
You misspelled Chordettes. Chordette Sister GroupMung
December 17, 2014
December
12
Dec
17
17
2014
04:30 PM
4
04
30
PM
PST
Why convergent? Echinoderms are part of the sister group to chordates.wd400
December 17, 2014
December
12
Dec
17
17
2014
12:32 PM
12
12
32
PM
PST
1 2 3

Leave a Reply