Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Is Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) gaining respectability again?

arroba Email

Sarah Scoles, author of the forthcoming They Are Already Here: UFO Culture and Why We See Saucers makes the case:

In their recent paper, the SETI scientists present a case for closing the gap between their work and that of people like Seager, putting SETI back on the astrobiology continuum. And that’s looking pretty possible: The House Appropriations Bill that Congress passed in April 2018 directed NASA to start including searches for “technosignatures” in its broader search for life beyond Earth. In September of that year, interested parties gathered to discuss what that would look like. Information from the SETI luminaries’ paper, arguing that their search belongs back within the sanctioned fold, will soon be considered by a committee that determines astronomy’s priorities for the coming decade. If things go well, “little green men” will be a warm joke, not a harsh slur, in the 2020s…

Perhaps the alien hunters offer a way for scientific insiders and outsiders to get along. Proper science is now more willing to embrace SETI: Astronomer Jill Tarter, one of the search’s pioneers, received radio astronomy’s highest honor—the Janksy Lectureship—in 2014. The chair of the Harvard astronomy department has repeatedly and very publicly suggested that an interstellar object called Oumuamua, cruising through the solar system, could be a visiting spaceship. A scientist at NASA’s Ames Research Center recently proposed new SETI strategies—and included a radical idea: Astronomers shouldn’t cover their eyes to UFO reports. “I think the approach the scientific community could take … is very similar to what SETI has done so far: find the signal in the noise,” he wrote. “In the very large amount of ‘noise’ in UFO reporting there may be ‘signals’ however small, that indicate some phenomena that cannot be explained or denied.”

Don’t just ignore all the outliers as outliers, in other words: Important truth, if not whole truth, can lurk inside of them too.

Sarah Scoles, “What Scientists Can Learn From Alien Hunters” at Wired

But then the consensus boffins will have fewer groups to reject, in order to hang onto their status without really doing anything…

See also: The scientific revolution depended in part on disproven theories Many true tales of science are not the subjects of lectern oratory. Here’s one: brain localization. How did the idea develop? Originally via phrenology.


BioLogos is marketing theistic evolution and “consensus science” to Christian schools In the real world, this is not the time to be buying into “consensus” but to be advocating reform.

Hey guys spooky 16 day cycle signal. What do you think https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/mysterious-signal-from-deep-space-is-repeating-in-16-day-cycle?fbclid=IwAR1erSXqlFyX0CEaZrfDcuTRvi_e8Gr-XJYT_ViJVOSI5q8rSpYHEtc_sUY AaronS1978
UFO reports from expert sources are hardly unreliable. And there are plenty of such reports. However most people won't accept that just cuz they weren't there. Imagine if every observation had to be proved to every individual on the planet... ET
When NASA encourages UFO observations, it usually means they're developing a Flying Object that they hope is Unidentifiable, and they're recruiting extra eyes to double-check its stealthiness. polistra
EDTA, I see your valid point. Thanks pw
The title asks if SETI is gaining respect again. Then the quote mentions the possibility of new funding for the search. It ends with the suggestion that we pay more attention to less information (the "outliers"), including UFO reports, which are notoriously unreliable. That's not the way to gain intellectual respect. But it might get funding, thus showing the disconnect between those two things. EDTA
EDTA, What does that mean? pw
Gaining funding and gaining respectability are not the same thing these days. EDTA
Craig Venter seems like a strong candidate for the Evo2.0 $10M prize for explaining OOL in a coherent way. https://youtu.be/WXUk6FLJPpw PavelU

Leave a Reply