Intelligent Design Psychology

Study: Only 15% of psych papers rooted in theory

Spread the love

A study of over 2000 papers highlights the need for more theory in psychology research, especially in view of the current replication crisis:

This means that even a prominent psychology journal dedicated to theory-based science only rarely tests theory. The finding may explain the lack of reliability in psychology, and signals a potential failing in the fundamental scientific enterprise of psychology. Can psychology develop a sound theoretical framework? Perhaps this new focus on the matter will push the field toward that goal.

Eagle Gamma, “Just 15 percent of psychology studies are strongly rooted in theory” at Massive Science

Reform, you say? But wait! What will we do without all the Sokal hoaxes. The righteous defenses of the current state of the discipline were always the best part of the hoaxes, of course.

On the other hand, findings that really shed light on something we need to hear about might be interesting in their own right…

The paper is open access.

2 Replies to “Study: Only 15% of psych papers rooted in theory

  1. 1
    polistra says:

    Separated twins are the only way to get a controlled experiment in psychology. The studies on separated twins have already been done, showing what wise people always knew. All human traits and tendencies are part genetic and part learned. Some traits are more one way and some are more the other way. The details don’t matter.

    So there’s really nothing more to do. The only real science in psychology was finished 60 years ago. Close up shop and turn off the lights.

  2. 2
    polistra says:

    OT: The new Paradigm Project video is WONDERFUL. The first truly persuasive video or podcast on ID. Lots of ‘production’, and the host cutely admits right up front that there’s lots of ‘production’. The whole thing is simply perfect.

Leave a Reply