Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Time to End One-Size-Fits-All Virus Response

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Trump’s plan calls for protecting vulnerable age cohorts while letting the less vulnerable get back to work. The two charts below demonstrate why opposition to this proposal borders on the insane.

The first chart is from CDC’s website showing COVID-19 deaths by age cohort as of April 17. The total is only 13,130, because CDC is behind in sorting this data. According to Worldmeter, total US deaths as of April 17 are 37,230. The second chart assumes the rates stay the same as the data is compiled (and I see no reason we should not assume that). Then I calculate total deaths as of today by age cohort.

One number should jump out at you. 3,315. That is the total number of deaths in the three months since the beginning of the pandemic among people under 55. In a country with a population of 327,167,434, that is .001%. That is 1 one thousandth of a percent.

Fact: The overwhelming majority of deaths are among the elderly.
Fact: The overwhelming majority of deaths are among those with serious preexisting conditions.
Fact: The government response is to treat young healthy people with practically zero risk of death the same as sick, elderly people.

The third fact needs to end, and that is the administration’s plan. You don’t shut the county down over a 1 one thousandth of a percent risk.

Comments
Shouldn't the elderly be allowed to return too if they know the risks. They are no more likely to be infectious and pass the virus along. But isolating them is isolating tens of millions of people. I know some extremely healthy 65+ people. Some run marathons and compete in triathlons. Who gets out and who doesn't? Seems a little totalitarian? This is one voting block I would not want to piss off.jerry
April 18, 2020
April
04
Apr
18
18
2020
11:30 AM
11
11
30
AM
PDT
1 2 3 4

Leave a Reply