Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

We Is Junk

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The quote below is taken from this week’s Nature magazine.

Since joining the blogosphere over two years ago, when challenged, I’ve invoked a scenario pretty much like the one the paper summary is making. I suspect Dave Scot has been making this argument for a longer period than that.

While still preliminary, I have to say that when Nature magazine starts running articles saying that “gene regulation — not the creation of new genes — has moulded the traits that make us unique”, then all that can be said is (a la Allen MacNeil): “Darwinism is dead. Long live evo-devo.” Is the war over?

Anyone who has ever put together self-assembly
furniture knows that having the right parts
is important, but what you do with them can
make or break the project. The same seems
to be true of the vast amounts of DNA in an
organism’s genome that used to be labelled as
junk. Studies now indicate that this DNA may
be responsible for the signals that were crucial
for human evolution, directing the various
components of our genome to work differently
from the way they do in other organisms.

The findings seem to bolster a 30-year-old
hypothesis that gene regulation — not the creation
of new genes — has moulded the traits that
make us unique.

While there’s not many particulars in what I’ve quoted, it strikes me as provocative enough to invite comments. Any takers?

Comments
Allen. Are you kidding? You said: Allen MacNeill (49): “Indeed, Darwin did not propose any mechanism for the origin of life, nor did he speculate about it (beyond a single sentence fragment in the Origin of Species ).” J provides a full paragraph. You argue that it wasn't published in his lifetime. So, if you make a speculation in WRITING, but it's not "published" does that mean you never spoke on the issue? This is getting old fast. You never said "Darwin never spoke of OOL in PUBLISHED work. You said he never proposed any mechanism for the origin of life (period)." Add cavaets all you want. You were wrong. Be the gentleman you constantly claim to be....make a reference to how you're an avid fencer and move along.JasonTheGreek
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:37 PM
6
06
37
PM
PST
Is anyone else tired of every comment from Al containing something to this effect: "ID isn't real science" "_____INSERT IDer NAME isn't a real scientist" "IDers refuse to do lab work, aka real science" "That is how real science works" Maybe I'm alone, but it's like listening to a broken record.JasonTheGreek
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:33 PM
6
06
33
PM
PST
j asserts that Darwin speculated on the origin of life with his "warm little pond" quote. However, that quote is taken from a letter that Darwin wrote to another naturalist and was never published in book form, either during his lifetime or thereafter. It is, of course, collected in his correspondence. Try this: find a quote in Darwin's published works (i.e. those he published during his lifetime) in which he speculates as to the origin of life. And please note that I have already mentioned the sentence fragment from the last paragraph of the Origin, so that one is already off the table.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:32 PM
6
06
32
PM
PST
Don't worry J- one could always argue that random in science sonehow doesn't mean the same thing in everyday language...and that words like 'accidental' and 'purposeless' mean something different in science as well. Darwinist: "They don't really mean a lack of purpose or intent or that the event was accidental- science can't answer questions like these! That's philosophy."JasonTheGreek
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:31 PM
6
06
31
PM
PST
Backing away from true eusociality, Hamilton's Law has been used to find less extreme versions of kin selection in animals as diverse as ground squirrels, scrub jays, and (surprise!) primates. Indeed, as biologists look for additional applications of Hamilton's Law, we find them in multiple locations, often right out there where we could have seen them all along, but didn't until we had Hamilton's Law to point the way. That is how real science works: an hypothesis is proposed, used to make predictions, which are tested in the field and in the lab, and the results compared with the original hypothesis. In the case of Hamilton's brilliant insight, his hypothesis has been so thoroughly tested and its applications so fruitful in our understanding of animal social behavior that it deserves at least the appellation of "theory" and, in time, will almost certainly be acclaimed as a scientific "law."Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:28 PM
6
06
28
PM
PST
An accidental mechanism evolved (without plan or purpose) to provide a purposeful method of ADJUSTING sex ratio? Sounds quite teleological to me.JasonTheGreek
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:27 PM
6
06
27
PM
PST
Allen MacNeill (49): "Indeed, Darwin did not propose any mechanism for the origin of life, nor did he speculate about it (beyond a single sentence fragment in the Origin of Species )." Charles Darwin (1871, in Life and Letters of Charles Darwin):
It is often said that all the conditions for the first production of a living organism are now present, which could ever have been present. But if (and oh! what a big if!) we could conceive in some warm little pond, with all sorts of ammonia and phosphoric salts, lights, heat, electricity, etc. present, that a protein compound was chemically formed ready to undergo still more complex changes, at the present day such matter would be instantly devoured or absorbed, which would not have been the case before living creatures were formed.
Making false claims about what Darwin wrote is getting to be a habit of yours, Dr. MacNeill. (Cf. https://uncommondescent.com/archives/1714 comments #38 and #45.) Per DaveScot (44): "You need to do less writing and more reading professor."j
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:27 PM
6
06
27
PM
PST
No, actually you missed the point of my post. Not all ants, bees, and wasps are eusocial. However, eusociality has evolved independently almost a dozen times in the order Hymenoptera, but only once in any other order of insects (the Isoptera) and only once in the entire subphylum Vertebrata (naked mole rats). In other words, Hamilton's Law brilliantly predicts the evolution of eusociality as the result of a seemingly unrelated phenomenon: the mechanism of sex determination in Hymenoptera, which almost certainly evolved as a method for females to adjust the sex ratio of their offspring to respond to changes in their environment.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:22 PM
6
06
22
PM
PST
Dr. MacNeill, DaveScot wrote; “Altruism is a good example. Evolution explains both the lack of it and the manifestation of it. It never predicts where it will be found it only explains how it happened after it is found (or not found).” And then Dr. MacNeill said; "Actually, W. D. Hamilton's theory of kin selection predicts exactly where altruism resulting from kin selection should be found: in the order Hypmenoptera (ants, bees, and wasps). And, sure enough, almost all of the cases of intense eusociality have evolved within that order. " So since you are answering DaveScot's assertion that evolution explains but never predicts. Then Mr. Hamilton did not know the type of society that bee's, wasps and ants had before he made this prediction in his theory. I find that hard to believe but maybe I missed DaveScot's point.JFD
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:30 PM
5
05
30
PM
PST
An interesting thought experiment also suggests itself, vis-a-vis the previous post. If haplodiploidy does NOT predispose the Hymenoptera to the evolution of eusociality, then why exactly are so many eusocial species found in that order? And why should unambiguous cases of relatively intense sociality be correlated with genetic relatedness in other orders, classes, and even phyla of animals?Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:15 PM
5
05
15
PM
PST
DaveScot wrote: "Altruism is a good example. Evolution explains both the lack of it and the manifestation of it. It never predicts where it will be found it only explains how it happened after it is found (or not found)." Actually, W. D. Hamilton's theory of kin selection predicts exactly where altruism resulting from kin selection should be found: in the order Hypmenoptera (ants, bees, and wasps). And, sure enough, almost all of the cases of intense eusociality have evolved within that order. Hamilton based his prediction on the sex determination mechanism in Hymenoptera: females are normal diploids, but males are haploid. This means that sisters (i.e. the workers and the queen in a hive) are related to each other by more than they would be to their own offspring (three-fourths versus one-half), and therefore those females who assist one of their number (the queen) in reproducing actually cause more copies of their genes to be replicated in the next generation than they would if they themselves passed them on. Since Hamilton made his prediction, it has been exhaustively tested, not only in insects but also in birds, mammals, fish, reptiles, and a myriad of other animals. In virtually every case, his prediction has turned out to be accurate: the closer the genetic relationships between a group of animals, the more likely they are to act altruistically toward each other. Indeed, such correlations are so common and so predictable, Hamilton's hypothesis is now often refered to as "Hamilton's Law." What is interesting is that extreme cases of eusociality have also been observed in animals that do not use haplodiploidy for sex determination the way the Hymenoptera do. And, some of the Hymenoptera are not eusocial (the Ichneumonidae are a classic example). So, what Hamilton's Law predicts is not an absolute rule, but rather a strong correlation (based on ecology and life history, as well as genetic relatedness).Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:12 PM
5
05
12
PM
PST
Allen MacNeil: Here are two quotes taken from two different posts on this thread:
According to Darwin, natural selection is the inevitable result of three pre-conditions: variation, inheritance, and fecundity. Given these three pre-conditions, some individuals survive and reproduce more often than others. As a result, their heritable variations become relatively more common over time in the populations of which they are members.
In other words, the rearrangement of the genetic program of a particular organism is not the result of natural selection, it is the result of one of the “engines of variation” to which I referred in one of my earlier comments.
There's a tremendous ambiguity produced by these two statements. In the first, you postulate NS acting on the end-product of variation, inheritance and fecundity (by which, I'll presume, you mean that the "mutant" can reproduce), while in the second you attribute tremendous change to the "engines of variation", leaving NS completely out of the picture. The only way to reconcile these two statements is to say that nature produces "hopeful monsters", and some of them live, which, then, makes NS completely moot. This almost has the appearance of saying that when it is convenient to talk about NS doing something, then we'll talk about it. But if it isn't convenient, then we'll just leave it out and talk about "variation". In this case, the "rearrangement of the genetic program" occurs through the "engines of variation", and NS has nothing to do with it. But, of course, this sounds exactly like what Goldschmidt was saying in 1940, only, not knowing about DNA as we do, he talked about chromsomal rearrangments bringing about "systemic mutations"--an alteration in how the program of development takes place. Now the wonder of all of this is that we are always told that evolution is not a "chance process", because NS in some way "confines", let us say, these chance events. But here you are saying we have "chance events" which modify a genetic program, so it's a completely "stochastic' event. If Darwin insists--as he did--that "natura non facit saltum", then he's proven wrong. Why should his theory stand?
The ID strawman of “RM” (i.e. random mutation) is a pale shadow of these “engines,” about which we know surprisingly little, but about which we are learning an immense amount at present.
I don't think it entirely fair that RM is ID's "strawman". This blog has countless posters who invoke RM +NS as the cause of evolution. But, in the second quote above, in answering the question about the "reprogramming of genetic programs", you're intimating that some "random mutation", whether it be an insertion, deletion, crossover, or even point mutation, has affected a Hox gene with a resultant "change" in how the developmental program unfurls. I was pointing that out above. So, I don't really see it as a "strawman". I suspect it's just simply something you don't want to spend time defending, which I well understand.PaV
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
10:42 AM
10
10
42
AM
PST
Allen re religion conferring survival advantage Chance & necessity is able to explain an awful lot of things after the fact but has very little predictive power. It's tough predicting what random variation will produce. I'd be really impressed if evolution predicted religion before religion was there or if it could predict what path religion was going to take in the future or when & where religion will arise in another animal species. Of what practical use is a theory which only explains things after the thing is actually observed and is so flexible that practically any observation can be explained by it? Altruism is a good example. Evolution explains both the lack of it and the manifestation of it. It never predicts where it will be found it only explains how it happened after it is found (or not found). Then for the few things it can't explain we get a Darwin of the Gaps defense in that evolution must have done it we just don't know how yet (queue the flagellum). Either that or the theory is modified ad hoc to accomodate observations that don't fit (queue up punc eek). Or bits of it are discarded with no widely publicized admission of how badly wrong it was (queue up gene-centric theory). I know you stand out from the herd in that you're willing to say the modern synthesis is dead or dying but you might want to consider that its death was a prediction of ID going back at least to Paley. I'll further predict that you'll never find a theory of everything in biology (which must include the origin of life as well as its diversification) that survives for the long haul if it excludes intelligent agency as a mechanism. In other words, you can search for a blind watchmaker until the cows come home and you won't find one. The reason is simple - you can't find that which does not exist. There's no such thing as a blind watchmaker. DaveScot
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
08:02 AM
8
08
02
AM
PST
Allen Patents became a lot more common in my field in the 90's although part of that with me was working for small companies where trade secrets were the rule and patents were the exception. I really only patented a few things at Dell because it was a requirement in my performance plan to generate patents. And even then the only reason we did it as a company was because IBM and Texas Instruments was taking us to the cleaners in broad patent license fees. It's a racket. Big companies with big patent portfolios threaten small companies with expensive litigation then settle for annual license fees that grant immunity from infringement. IBM alone was clocking us for over $100 million annually. That was a huge chunk of our profits. Around 1998 we developed a big enough portfolio of our own (and enough money to pay lawyers to sue IBM for infringement) so that we could broker a cross-license deal (we don't sue you, you don't sue us) and get out from under that annual extor... er, I mean, license fee. Many of us down in the trenches doing the inventing feel the same way as many idealistic academics - discoveries should be made public for everyone to use freely. That's why there's so much public domain software nowadays. In my field there's a lot of crap patents that should never have been granted too (as I suppose in yours there's a lot of crap papers that should never have been published). The reason I suspect is the same - poor peer review. Patent examiners (our equivalent to peer review) have little knowledge of prior art unless the prior art was patented. Things that are commonly done by experts in the field or were poorly kept trade secrets receive patents all the time because the examiners don't know they aren't novel. And once a patent is issued the burden of proof is on the accused infringer in court to defend himself as the assumption is that the patent examiners did their job well. Like I said, it's a racket, but what can you do? "Publish or perish" has an analog in my field: "Patent or perish". DaveScot
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
07:32 AM
7
07
32
AM
PST
Allen I read the 1973 Physiology Nobel acceptance speech and aside from a passing reference to natural selection in the first paragraph, which appears completely gratuitous (as most such references are when the actual discovery was accomplished through the study of living tissue), I could find no other mention of evolution. Moreover, even if you argue the mention wasn't gratuitous it makes no mention of chance mutation being the source of variation which natural selection acts upon. I really only have a problem with the exclusion of telic mechanisms not with natural selection acting to filter the good from the not good in direct response to the environment. In other words, my problem isn't in survival of fitness but arrival of fitness. http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine/laureates/1973/presentation-speech.html As an aside, in reading Lorenz' biography he talked about the importance of birds in his studies. I've raised a lot of different birds from nestlings and found they instinctively do a lot of birdlike things without ever being around another bird. Like flying. It seems rather farfetched to imagine a protein cascade of some sort that accounts for a bird instinctively knowing how to fly or how to build a nest characteristic of its species (location, building materials, and construction details) yet they do. Obviously the nest building instructions are contained in the egg. How? My first guess would be it's somehow encoded in the "junk" DNA.DaveScot
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:43 AM
6
06
43
AM
PST
Joseph asked: “…why don't we know what mutations afforded what changes? ” Allen MacNeil: Actually, we do. As just one example, we know that a fusion of two chromosomes in a primate ancestor in the hominid line is correlated with the divergence between the line that led to humans and the line that led to chimps and other great apes. We know this because human chromosome #2 is the product of this fusion, a conclusion that is based on pure empirical genetic testing. Umm, you didn't say what changes the alleged fusion afforded. And I have had discussions with a Scott Page of Norwich U who tells me that no one thinks the event you mention had any significance at all- and his specialty is primates. We still don't know what mutations allowed for upright, bipedal motion. Joseph also asked: “Why don't we even know whether or not ANY mutation/ selection process can account for the range of change required for Common Descent to be indicative of reality?” Allem MacNeil: We don't yet know whether or not variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and resulting in differential survival and reproduction has done this because we are still investigating such possibilities. That's what science is all about: doing the hard work in the field and in the lab that either falsifies one's hypotheses or not. If we don't know then that is what should be presented to students. To keep pushing that we do know or that we will know in time is just plain hypricritical. Everything in the field and lab points to wobbling stability. Allen MacNeil: Referring to CSI, IC, and other ID ideas isn't doing science at all. It does not involve doing actual experiments or field observations, it simply relies upon conceptual arguements, arguments that so far have no empirical support. Actually CSI, IC and counterflow all have been observed in the lab and in nature. All can be tested against their respective definitions. And it should also be noted that there are some anti-IDists who have (falsely) claimed to have refuted the concept of IC via experimentation. That fact alone contradicts your response. Allen MacNeil: Until IDers start performing actual experiments or gathering field data that clearly and unambiguously distinguish between EB and ID hypotheses, evolutionary biologists will continue to assert (with a century and a half of empirical evidence to back them up) that ID “theories” (which to date are no more than hypotheses) have no empirical support, and are therefore not science. And again by YOUR criterion EB isn't science either. There aren't any experiments which demonstrtae a population of ape-like organisms can "evolve" into a population of humans. Only a handful of wishful speculations based on the assumption such a thing did occur. --------------------------------------------------------- Allen MacNeil: Personally, I pay very little attention to the “origin of life” problem, as I believe that it is almost impossible to obtain evidence either way. Answering that question also should have little or no effect on answering the question, “once life exists and has a reliable mechanism for information coding and transfer, what happens?” The answer is, it evolves into what we see around us today. Try this Allen: If living organisms did NOT arise from non-living matter via stochastic mechansims there would be no reason to infer the subsequent diversity arose solely via those types of processes. IOW the origins of living organisms directly impacts any subsequent evolution.Joseph
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:31 AM
6
06
31
AM
PST
P.S. DaveScot: Congratulations on all your patents. I don't work in a field in which patents are either likely or possible (most research scientists don't). However, you might be interested in reading my most recent publication: chapter 10 ("The Capacity for Religious Experience is an Evolutionary Adaptation to Warfare") in Fitduff, M. & Stout, C. eds. (2005) The Psychology of Resolving Global Conflicts, vol. 1, Praeger International Series, Westport, CT. This is a slight revision of a paper that appeared in vol. 10 #1 (July 2004) of Evolution & Cognition, published by the Max Plank Institute in Vienna. I would be happy to email you a pdf of either document, or you can read about them at my blog: http://evolutionlist.blogspot.com/2006/04/capacity-for-religious-experience-is.htmlAllen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:11 AM
6
06
11
AM
PST
I sense some confusion about the term "stochastic" in some of the previous comments. the term is usually used to refer to any process that includes a random component (see http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?va=stochastic ). It does not mean "happening in a discontinuous manner," as some commentators seem to imply. This distinction is extremely important, as evolution is indeed a stochastic process; it includes both a random component (i.e. many of the "engines of variation" generate apparently random variations) and a non-random component (i.e. differential survival and reproduction, as specified by the environment). Nothing in Darwin's original theory of evolution required that "descent with modification" be absolutely continuous. True, Darwin used the latin phrase "natura non facit saltum" several times, but the diagram that he included in the Origin (the only illustration in the book) shows a branching process of cladogenesis not substantially different from that proposed by Eldredge and Gould in 1972. In other words, there is nothing about the concept of naturalistic evolution that requires that it be a continuous, gradualistic process. The fossil record as we now understand tends to support the idea that macroevolution is relatively discontinuous, with relatively long periods of "stasis" punctuated by relatively brief periods of cladogenesis, usually correlated with either mass extinction/adaptive radiation events, founder effects/bottlenecks, and/or genetic innovations such as the fusion of prokaryotes into the eukaryotic endosymbiont. In other words, microevolution (i.e. natural selection, genetic drift, and other processes that happen anagenetically at the population level) and macroevolution (i.e. extinction/adaptive radiation, genetic innovation, and symbiosis that happen cladogenetically at the species level and above) are in many ways fundamentally different processes with fundamentally different mechanisms. Furthermore, for reasons beyond the scope of this thread, macroevolution is probably not mathematically modelable in the way that microevolution has historically been. I am just beginning work on a book on macroevolution in which I intend to develop these ideas much more fully. However, as I am already working on an introductory evolution textbook for non-scientists and a lecture series on evolutionary psychology for the Teaching Company, not to mention an ongoing research project on the evolutionary dynamics of vertical polygamy in America and a book on the evolution of the capacity for religious experience for a major university press, it will probably not be finished for several years.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
06:02 AM
6
06
02
AM
PST
Mike 1962 wrote: "I accept that there are many “mechanisms of variability”, but logically Darwinian evolution (i.e., variability, inheritance, fecundity) seems completely impotent in “stochastically” arriving at a new “program mode” for DNA/RNA information systems.”" Actually, that's exactly what homeotic gene regulatory mechanisms are eminently capable of. And as to "stochastically" arriving at a new "program mode", that is precisely what differential survival and reproduction is: a stochastic mechanism by which new variations are sorted and tested against the environment, which ultimately "chooses" the most efficient variation out of those produced by the "engines of variation." Not to put too fine a point on it, but this is just Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection, restated in terms of "information theory."Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:40 AM
5
05
40
AM
PST
Mike 1962 asked: "So the engines of variation you speak of are sufficient for novel cell types, tissues, and body plans? Where has this been demonstrated empirically" Yes; you can read all about it in Sean Carroll's new book Endless Forms Most Beautiful and in Lynn Margulis's classic Symbiosis in Cell Evolution and her more recent Acquiring Genomes, coauthored with her son, Dorion Sagan (yes, that Sagan; Lynn was Carl's first wife).Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:36 AM
5
05
36
AM
PST
PaV also asked: "...can NS, acting alone, bring about a “rearrangement” of the “genetic program” of a particular organism?" As John Endler, Will Provine, and myself have repeatedly pointed out, natural selection can't "bring about" anything. Natural selection isn't a mechanism, it's an outcome. The mechanisms that bring about natural selection are variation, inheritance, fecundity, and differential survival and reproduction. In other words, the rearrangement of the genetic program of a particular organism is not the result of natural selection, it is the result of one of the "engines of variation" to which I referred in one of my earlier comments. The ID strawman of "RM" (i.e. random mutation) is a pale shadow of these "engines," about which we know surprisingly little, but about which we are learning an immense amount at present. And yes, it nows seems that something like what Richard Goldschmidt proposed as the basis for cladogenesis might not be so far-fetched at all. The idea of a single-step "hopeful monster" was not rejected by the founders of the "modern evolutionary synthesis" on empirical grounds, it was rejected because it could not be explained using the "one gene: one trait" model of genetics that was in vogue at the time. With the rise of evolutionary developmental biology (i.e. "evo-devo"), we are beginning to realize that large-scale, relatively rapid changes in overall phenotype are possible, and that they can be explained by changes in the regulation of "master control genes" (i.e. homeotic genes). Furthermore, these insights are now beginning to be applied to the patterns of cladistic change visible in the fossil record, as first forcefully pointed out by Eldredge and Gould in 1972. What is now happening, in other words, is that a new "evolutionary synthesis" is being formulated, based on a flood of new information from genetics, developmental biology, paleontology, and historical geology/planetology. This new synthesis takes into account new information that has been obtained since the heyday of the "modern synthesis" and provides a much more powerful and comprehensive explanation of Darwin's "descent with modification." No, it doesn't rely completely on Darwin's proposed "mechanism" of natural selection, at least not as formulated by Fisher/Haldane/Wright/Dobzhansky/Mayr, but yes it does conform to the overall outlines of Darwin's original theory. So, as I said before, "the modern synthesis is dead; long live evolutionary biology!"Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:32 AM
5
05
32
AM
PST
PaV asked: "Do the “engines of variation” provide sufficient variation to move beyond microevolution to macroevolution." This is indeed the central question. One of the central tenets of the "modern synthesis of evolutionary biology" as celebrated in 1959 was the idea that macroevolution and microevolution were essentially the same process. That is, macroevolution was simply microevolution extrapolated over deep evolutionary time, using the same mechanisms and with essentially the same effects. A half century of research into macroevolution has shown that this is probably not the case. In particular, macroevolutionary events (such as the splitting of a single species into two or more, a process known as cladogenesis) do not necessarily take a long time at all. Indeed, in plants it can take as little as a single generation. We have observed the origin of new species of rose, primroses, trees, and all sorts of plants by genetic processes, such as allopolyploidy and autopolyploidy. Indeed, most of the cultivated roses so beloved of gardeners are new species of roses that originated spontaneously as the result of chromosomal rearrangements, which rose fanciers then exploited. The real problem, therefore, is explaining cladogenesis in animals. As Lynn Margulis has repeatedly pointed out, animals have a unique mechanism of sexual reproduction and development, one that apparently makes the kinds of chromosomal events that are common in plants very difficult in animals. However, she has proposed an alternative mechanism for cladogenesis in animals, based on the acquisition and fusion of genomes. Research into such mechanisms has only just begun, but has already been shown to explain the origin of eukaryotes via the fusion of disparate lines of prokaryotes, plus the origin of several species of animals and plants as the result of genome acquisition. As Lynn has been extraordinarily successful in the past in proposing testable mechanisms for macroevolutionary changes, I look forward to many more discoveries in this field.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:19 AM
5
05
19
AM
PST
Personally, I pay very little attention to the "origin of life" problem, as I believe that it is almost impossible to obtain evidence either way. Answering that question also should have little or no effect on answering the question, "once life exists and has a reliable mechanism for information coding and transfer, what happens?" The answer is, it evolves into what we see around us today.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:09 AM
5
05
09
AM
PST
Kairos wrote: "...no engines of that sort are a plausible explication of life." That's true: the mechanism that Darwin proposed in 1859 (i.e. natural selection) was not proposed as an explanation of the origin of life. Indeed, Darwin did not propose any mechanism for the origin of life, nor did he speculate about it (beyond a single sentence fragment in the Origin of Species). As Daniel Dennett has shown, Darwin "started in the middle" by proposing a testable mechanism for descent with modification among organisms that already existed, and abjured speculation on the origin of life.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:07 AM
5
05
07
AM
PST
DaveScot wrote: "I couldn't find a single noble prize award for any discoveries in evolutionary biology." The Nobel prize for physiology or medicine for 1973 was awarded to Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen, and Karl von Frisch for their work in founding the science of ethology, which is the science of animal behavior from an explicitly evolutionary perspective. My own field - evolutionary psychology - is a direct subdiscipline of ethology; that is, it is the ethology of humans.Allen_MacNeill
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
05:03 AM
5
05
03
AM
PST
#39 Agree PaV
While you're mulling that over (as I stated when I posted this summary article) I “predicted” that junk-DNA would be found to be highly significant, and that it would be involved in the regulation of the coding (and the non-coding/binding ) portions of DNA, which is no more than what would be clearly expectated if one starts from a design perspective.
But instead it's very bad news for NDE. One of the reason NDEers have been able up to now to sell a minimal plausibility for RM+NS is by claiming that only a SMALL part of DNA is actually active. If this is not the case, mere statistics is sufficient to get NDE buried. And this without taking into account hierarchy and other complex features that could show DNA even more "designed".kairos
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
03:18 AM
3
03
18
AM
PST
#44
For instance, check out all the prizes awarded for inventions in physics:
May I cite a name for all? Guglielmo Marconi
It appears you evolutionary biologists are just leeching off the discoveries and inventions made by chemists, physicists, and physiologists. When are you going to go out and do some real research that leads to the betterment of the human condition? :lol:
Perhaps are we waiting Godot?kairos
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
03:07 AM
3
03
07
AM
PST
Michaels7 Here is the definitive way of identifying inventors who've been issued patents. http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-bool.html&r=0&f=S&l=50&TERM1=MacNeill%3B+Allen&FIELD1=INNM&co1=AND&TERM2=&FIELD2=INNM&d=PTXT No hits on "MacNeill; Allen". Conversely if we check my name http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-bool.html&r=0&f=S&l=50&TERM1=Springer%3B+David&FIELD1=INNM&co1=AND&TERM2=&FIELD2=INNM&d=PTXT Four of the eleven hits on "Springer; David" are mine. So unless I spelled Allen's name incorrectly or he goes by some other name he's not a named inventor on any granted U.S. patent. As an aside, this invention of mine http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5936608.PN.&OS=PN/5936608&RS=PN/5936608 was inspired by my knowledge of human anatomy and physiology. It's basically a method of conserving power in a certain type of flat panel display by figuring out what element(s) on the display screen are being focused upon by the eyes and gradually lowering the brightness (which reduces the power consumption) of all elements not in focus. The visual system in humans (and other higher animals) works the same way. Things in the central focus are processed in high resolution and those on the periphery in low resolution. That way the brain doesn't get overloaded by applying an equal amount of processing power to the entire field of vision. The way color was added to black and white TV was similarly inspired. The color content in an NTSC video image is only about a fifth of the resolution of the black and white (brightness) content. That's because the human eye is much more sensitive to brightness of light than it is to the frequency of the light. Knowing that, color content could be added onto the 14 megahertz amplitude modulated black/white carrier by the addition of a 3.5 megahertz phase modulated sub-carrier. In other words brightness is painted with a very fine brush and then color is slopped over the top with a much wider brush.DaveScot
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
02:55 AM
2
02
55
AM
PST
Allen MacNeil Your notion that nobel prizes are awarded for discoveries-only is all wet. (my emphasis) In physics:
Awarded by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences to "the person who shall have made the most important discovery or invention within the field of physics".
In chemistry
Awarded by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences to "the person who shall have made the most important chemical discovery or improvement".
You need to do less writing and more reading professor. For instance, check out all the prizes awarded for inventions in physics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize_in_Physics One more thing of note, I couldn't find a single noble prize award for any discoveries in evolutionary biology. Check out all these physiology/medicine awards. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize_in_Physiology_or_Medicine All of them are directly or indirectly driven by the study of living tissue. Modern biology is the study of living tissue and is not dependent on how it got that way. How it got that way is historic biology. Historic biology appears to me to be about useful as teats on a tomcat. It appears you evolutionary biologists are just leeching off the discoveries and inventions made by chemists, physicists, and physiologists. When are you going to go out and do some real research that leads to the betterment of the human condition? :lol: DaveScot
November 12, 2006
November
11
Nov
12
12
2006
02:01 AM
2
02
01
AM
PST
Chris, Zachriel, Ty for response. I'll respond to you both after Dr. MacNeill responds to my serious line of questions as you both did.Michaels7
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:05 PM
10
10
05
PM
PST
1 2 3 4