Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Yonath on “ingeniously designed” ribosome? Everyone tells us she didn’t mean it …

arroba Email

At Evolution News & Views Casey Luskin notes that “Nobel Prize Winner Cites the ‘Ingeniously Designed’ Architecture of the Ribosome” (February 20, 2012). Everyone hastens to assure us that she doesn’t mean it … .

The available three dimensional structures of the bacterial ribosome and their subunits show that in each of the two subunits the ribosomal proteins are entangled within the complex rRNA conformation, thus maintaining a striking dynamic architecture that is ingeniously designed for their functions: precise decoding; substrate mediated peptide-bond formation and efficient polymerase activity.

(See Ada Yonath, “Supervisor’s Foreword,” in Chen Davidovich, Targeting Functional Centers of the Ribosome, p. vii (Springer-Verlag, 2011) (emphasis added).)

But they couldn’t take the 2009 Prize away from her anyway, could they? The most they could do is edit the phrase out or gloss it in the next edition of the book. When a lot of people already know.

Well hopefully this does help in health or just in knowledge. Yes everything is wonderfully made and looks like what it would if it was made. A prediction. Israel eh. ? This is because 3 billion dollars and more help goes to such a small country. the money should stay in america because it would go further in research and the credit should go to those paying the bill. Without American peoples money they couldn't afford reserach and Americans could have more. It takes away the fun of Nobel prizes. Why not finance China/ lots of them and they like science stuff. Off thread but it sticks in the ribosome's. Robert Byers
There was a very simple, completely straightforward way around that unfortunate 'mot pas' for Yonath. They are verbs that cry out to be coined: '... most intricately randomed/haphazarded' Axel
SCheesman You'll have to get rid of the architecture, I'm afraid. Dictionary definition: "science of building". Etymology: "that which is panned and made by an arch builder." Sorry - you don't get to turn down the Nobel. Jon Garvey
Jon Garvey:
Here’s a challenge: can someone be helpful by rewording it in totally non-teleological language? A Nobel Prize for the best…
Actually, the rules to do this are well-know and relatively simple, for instance: "... a striking dynamic architecture that evolved over millions of years" "... has evolved a striking dynamic architecture." I must decline the Nobel... one has to be original, I think. SCheesman
Correction, the video/animation is 'based on' work from Yonath's group; bornagain77
Here is a video that was put out by Yonath's group;
Ribosome animation - video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9vIOYlZXjE
Honors to Researchers Who Probed Atomic Structure of Ribosomes - Robert F. Service Excerpt: "The ribosome’s dance, however, is more like a grand ballet, with dozens of ribosomal proteins and subunits pirouetting with every step while other key biomolecules leap in, carrying other dancers needed to complete the act.” http://www.creationsafaris.com/crev200910.htm#20091015a Nobel Prize In Chemistry: What Ribosomes Look Like And How They Function At Atomic Level - 2009 http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/10/091007081536.htm
A few more videos and a note on the ‘Ingeniously Designed’ ribosome:
The Ribosome: Perfectionist Protein-maker Trashes Errors Excerpt: The enzyme machine that translates a cell's DNA code into the proteins of life is nothing if not an editorial perfectionist...the ribosome exerts far tighter quality control than anyone ever suspected over its precious protein products... To their further surprise, the ribosome lets go of error-laden proteins 10,000 times faster than it would normally release error-free proteins, a rate of destruction that Green says is "shocking" and reveals just how much of a stickler the ribosome is about high-fidelity protein synthesis. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/01 /090107134529.htm Molecular Machine - Ribosome - video http://pubs.acs.org/cen/multimedia/85/ribosome/translation_bacterial.html Protein Synthesis - Vuk Nikolic 3-D artist - Protein Translation - video http://vimeo.com/31830891 Programming of Life - Protein Synthesis - video http://www.youtube.com/user/Programmingoflife#p/c/AFDF33F11E2FB840/4/m5Z3afBdxB0 Journey Inside The Cell - Stephen Meyer - video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fiJupfbSpg
Verse and music:
Psalm 139:13 ,,,you knit me together in my mother's womb. Ribosome Song http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ti6MygOCLvI
Here's a challenge: can someone be helpful by rewording it in totally non-teleological language? A Nobel Prize for the best... Jon Garvey

Leave a Reply