Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Origin of life: Wheeling out God as a default explanation? Aw come on, New Statesman!

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

In”Science, God, and the ultimate evolutionary question” (New Statesman, November 30, 2011), Andrew Zak Williams tells us,

Until science proves the origin of the very first cells, many will wheel out God as the default explanation.

Actually, those of us who have noticed the origin of life clown car trailing real science for the better part of a century could just as easily wheel out space aliens. (God tends to win on points, and logic.) The funny thing is, Williams knows he’s bought a losing ticket, in buying into a material-only origin of life:

And so the hydrothermal vents theory provides a plausible account of how the first life could have formed on earth along with the DNA which was necessary to replicate it. But the theory certainly has difficulties. In fact, a similar theory based on a different type of vents, black smokers, is now generally given short shrift by the scientific community. Perhaps the hydrothermal vents theory will likewise come unstuck.

Perhaps? They all have come unstuck. Ain’t no “perhaps” about it.

The problem cannot be addressed without factoring in information, which is not a material entity, but is evidently present in life forms.

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Comments
ps : I would like to post a new post, how do I do that?MrDunsapy
December 2, 2011
December
12
Dec
2
02
2011
09:30 AM
9
09
30
AM
PDT
In reality you we don't have to bring out God, because some scientists do not know how life started, or that 'evolution' is real. The science stands for itself. So do you expect that the science will support a wrong view, don't you think that after 150 years of trying to prove something that is not supported by the science, you would still not know? The science is telling you, but will you listen?MrDunsapy
December 2, 2011
December
12
Dec
2
02
2011
09:28 AM
9
09
28
AM
PDT
OT: Frank Turek is in top form in this following video which was recently made at Rick Warren's Saddleback church at a apologetics conference:
Top Ten Reasons We Know the New Testament is True - Frank Turek - video http://saddleback.com/mc/m/5e22f/
Here is another video from the same conference that is very informative as well:
Why Historians Take The Gospel Seriously - video http://saddleback.com/mc/m/28a42/
bornagain77
December 2, 2011
December
12
Dec
2
02
2011
07:06 AM
7
07
06
AM
PDT
Rats! Hit the wrong "reply" button again. Sorry!dmullenix
December 2, 2011
December
12
Dec
2
02
2011
04:16 AM
4
04
16
AM
PDT
I get the distinct impression that you haven't actually read Steven Pinker's "The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined" despite the frequent exhortations on this blog not to review a book you haven't read. Have you? If not, I'll tell you what. Christmas is coming. I will buy you a copy of the book, either hard back or e-reader format, as a gift if you promise to read it. I guarantee you that you will find it informative and good reading. And you'll also find that Pinker is talking about a reduction in violence that started thousands of years ago and which continues to this day. The Twentieth Century is only a tiny portion of the book. (And the second half of the Twentieth Century was the most peaceful period in human history.) Just email me an address (P.O. Box is fine) or e-reader instructions. The blog has my email address.dmullenix
December 2, 2011
December
12
Dec
2
02
2011
04:16 AM
4
04
16
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply