Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Neuroscience: Walking back “Perception a controlled hallucination”

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

From Ari N. Shulman at Big Questions Online:

Is human perception a controlled hallucination? That was the claim advanced in a pair of talks at the Human Mind Conference in Cambridge, England in June, one by Anil Seth, a neuroscientist at the University of Sussex, the other by Andy Clark, a philosopher at the University of Edinburgh. They were not advancing the radical thesis, made by some overeager neuro-philosophers, that all experience is an illusion. Rather, Seth and Clark made the case that there is no bright dividing line between hallucination and ordinary perception.

The terms “controlled hallucination,” and related ones like “inferred fantasy” and “virtual reality,” are useful rhetorical devices for illustrating what is distinctive about the theory of predictive processing. But Clark is resistant to adopting these terms in full. For none of them quite describes what the theory says about the nature of our perceptual contact with the world. Perception, on Clark’s view, “doesn’t cut us off from the world…instead, it opens us up to the world as it matters to a creature like us.” More.

There was a reason that scientists used to be more modest in their claims.

See also: Researcher: Never mind the “hard problem of consciousness”: The real one is… “Our experiences of being and having a body are ‘controlled hallucinations’ of a very distinctive kind”

and

Post-modern science: The illusion of consciousness sees through itself

Comments
Waking perception is an internally generated fiction that gets CHECKED often against external sensory input.
What if 'checking' is part of the hallucination?Origenes
October 17, 2017
October
10
Oct
17
17
2017
03:18 AM
3
03
18
AM
PDT
I don't see why the concept needs to be 'walked back'. Dreams and hallucinations and our perceived fiction are INTERNALLY indistinguishable. Waking perception is an internally generated fiction that gets CHECKED often against external sensory input. Sometimes we have to conduct an experiment to tell the difference. "Pinch me so I know I'm not dreaming" is a familiar description of the experiment.polistra
October 17, 2017
October
10
Oct
17
17
2017
12:58 AM
12
12
58
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply