Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Retraction call for fetal pain paper

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

From Retraction Watch:

Pro-life activists have asked JAMA to retract a 2005 paper that suggested fetuses can’t feel pain before the third trimester.

Critics are arguing that newer findings have shown pain sensation appears earlier in gestation, yet the 2005 data continue to be cited in the discussion around abortion. What’s more, they note, some of the authors failed to mention their ties to the abortion industry.

The 2005 paper has been cited 191 times, according to Thomson Reuters Web of Science. We spoke with Howard Bauchner, Editor in Chief at JAMA and The JAMA Network, who told us something similar to what he said last week, when PETA asked to retract a paper they claim could be harmful to elephants:

…all requests for retraction are carefully evaluated. At this time we are reviewing the request as well as the references that were cited.

Reporting of Conflict of Interest has changed over the past 10 years, but nevertheless are evaluating that issue.

In a statement to the National Catholic Register, the president of “Just Facts” James Agresti asked JAMA to retract the paper, which he dubbed “the media’s go-to source for fetal pain.” More.

It must have taken some guts for Retraction Watch to even publish this. Deception is a common and widely, santimoniously supported feature of the abortion industry. I learned that as a much younger hack many years ago.

The internet has made many deceptions harder to sustain. Watch for some industry spokespeople to call for efforts to step up the persecution/prosecution of those who expose facts.

See also: The fetus is a parasite, abortion is like plucking out a hair: how much does Jerry Coyne really know about biology? (Vincent Torley)

Keep up to date with Retraction Watch

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Comments
News.... Remember this? Correlation not Causation: The Relationship between Personality Traits and Political Ideologies http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3809096/ It was a study in 2012 that concluded that conservatives are psychopaths..... Turns out the mixed up the results and its actually liberals that that are the psychopaths.... http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ajps.12216/epdf hahahahahahahahahahahahaha!Andre
June 9, 2016
June
06
Jun
9
09
2016
10:05 PM
10
10
05
PM
PST
vjtorley @ 6
clown fish Plants have everything necessary for them to survive, yet they’re not sentient. Newborn babies can’t survive unless they’re fed by their mothers, and yet they are sentient. I’m sorry, but you’ll have to do better than that.
Clown fish seems to have fallen silent. Has it occurred to you that he might like to try and do better but is no longer able to reply?Seversky
June 9, 2016
June
06
Jun
9
09
2016
09:00 PM
9
09
00
PM
PST
clown fish Plants have everything necessary for them to survive, yet they're not sentient. Newborn babies can't survive unless they're fed by their mothers, and yet they are sentient. I'm sorry, but you'll have to do better than that.vjtorley
June 9, 2016
June
06
Jun
9
09
2016
04:09 PM
4
04
09
PM
PST
VJ, a fully developed insect brain has everything necessary for an insect to survive. A 20 week undeveloped human brain doesn'tclown fish
June 8, 2016
June
06
Jun
8
08
2016
09:22 PM
9
09
22
PM
PST
clown fish: Kindly tell me which characteristic you think an insect's brain has (and which the brain of a 22-week-old fetus lacks), that enables it to experience consciousness.vjtorley
June 8, 2016
June
06
Jun
8
08
2016
03:36 PM
3
03
36
PM
PST
"One thing I do know: journalists who keep quoting from this 2005 paper to support their contention that 22-week-old fetuses don’t feel pain are being downright hypocritical when they turn around and argue that insects and crustaceans (whose brains are far more primitive) are nonetheless capable of feeling pain." Primitive, and undeveloped are not the same thing.clown fish
June 8, 2016
June
06
Jun
8
08
2016
08:24 AM
8
08
24
AM
PST
One thing I do know: journalists who keep quoting from this 2005 paper to support their contention that 22-week-old fetuses don't feel pain are being downright hypocritical when they turn around and argue that insects and crustaceans (whose brains are far more primitive) are nonetheless capable of feeling pain.vjtorley
June 8, 2016
June
06
Jun
8
08
2016
07:23 AM
7
07
23
AM
PST
This reads like pro-lifers are trying to censor a study because they don't like it.Bob O'H
June 8, 2016
June
06
Jun
8
08
2016
06:50 AM
6
06
50
AM
PST

Leave a Reply