See also: J. P. Moreland on why minds could not simply evolve somehow
Comments
"I could grant the truth of evolutionary theory, and still believe in the Christian God."
No, you couldn't.
A god, perhaps.
But the truth of evolutionary theory makes the Christian God a liar rather than merely unnecessary, and the atheists know this even if Christians do not.
And being a liar makes the Christian God disappear a lot faster than merely being unnecessary.ScuzzaMan