Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Does Atheism Poison Everything? Debate Between David Berlinski and Christopher Hitchens

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The debate is happening today, Sept. 7th, at the Fixed Point Foundation.

Our next debate features famed atheist Christopher Hitchens, author of God is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, and Dr. David Berlinski, author of The Devil’s Delusion: Atheism and Its Scientific Pretensions.  The question being debated: What are the implications of a purely secular society?  It promises to be a formidable clash of titans.  In addition to being highly entertaining and witty, these two men have a serious message they want to communicate.

The Does Religion Poison Everything? Debate begins at 7 p.m., September 7.

The luncheon, reception, and debate all take place at the Sheraton Birmingham Hotel:

For those of us who cannot make the debate, the DVD can be ordered here.

Dr. Berliski is a Senior Fellow of the Discovery Institute.

David Berlinski describes himself as “a secular Jew and an agnostic.”  He has written a number of books on mathematics, but he is best known for his appearance in the Ben Stein film “Expelled” as well as for his irreverent assault upon the New Atheists in his book, The Devil’s Delusion: Atheism and Its Scientific Pretensions.  Mr. Berlinski, whose immediate family was saved during the Holocaust by the “American Schindler” Varian Fry, resides in Paris.  He possesses a Ph.D. from Princeton University and formerly taught philosophy and mathematics at Stanford University and the University of Paris.

Christopher Hitchens, an atheist and polemicist, is best known for his controversial book, God is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, and, most recently, for his memoir, Hitch 22, which has been on The New York Times Best Seller List since its release last month.  Hitchens has been a columnist for The Atlantic, Slate, and Vanity Fair, and has debated his views around the English-speaking world.  Hitchens is one of the so-called “New Atheists”, along with other notables like Richard Dawkins.

Comments
Gil: If you needed a bible to tell you to love your neighbour, then I worry for you. Im sure you and others have been uplifted by the bible, but its not the only book capable of arousing such feelings. I have been similarly stirred by various works, I dont think I need to quote any particular text.Graham
September 7, 2010
September
09
Sep
7
07
2010
09:21 PM
9
09
21
PM
PDT
Awesome testimony Gil! God loves you and so do I. From one "Fundy" to another lol:)IRQ Conflict
September 7, 2010
September
09
Sep
7
07
2010
08:41 PM
8
08
41
PM
PDT
At risk of being labeled a religious fanatic who has abandoned all powers of reason, I present the following, written in 1994 at the behest my friend David Pounds, who is mentioned. It was David who recommended that I read Michael Denton's Evolution: A Theory in Crisis. In answer to the question, Does Atheism Poison Everything? -- I can attest to the fact that it does. It poisoned my life, soul, and intellect for 43 years. Readers can take the following as they will. I present it as my experience, which transformed my life, intellect, and soul much for the better. My former atheism was universally and consistently destructive in all three categories. A Christian Testimony March 12, 1994 at age 43 Gil Dodgen All my life I was an atheist, and believed that I was just a complex piece of biochemistry that came about by chance. When my chemical processes shut down at death I would cease to exist and enter eternal oblivion. I had (and have) everything the world has to offer -- a wonderful wife, two beautiful children, a nice home and a job I enjoy -- but somehow, as I grew older, I increasingly sensed that something was missing. I started asking myself, "What is all this for in the end? Is there some purpose behind all this? Are my children nothing more than a bunch of chemistry as well?" Deep inside I knew there had to be more. One day, while shopping in a book store, I ran across a cartoon video entitled "The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe." The blurb on the back of the package made it look like a nice story for my five-year-old daughter, and it was only $9.95, so I bought it. One evening my daughter and I lounged on the living room floor and watched the cartoon. At one point the lion gave up his life to an evil witch to spare a child, on whom the witch had a claim. The story of his courage, compassion and unjust death moved me deeply, and his return to life and struggle against evil inspired me. Suddenly I realized that the lion was Jesus Christ. There had been no mention of the allegory on the package, but I knew enough about the life of Jesus from my secular studies to recognize it. In retrospect I realize that Someone had gone to work on my heart as well. I had a friend, Dave Pounds, and I knew that he was a devout Christian. (In fact, he was the only Christian I knew.) We had not seen each other in a long time and I thought the video might make a nice excuse for our families to get together for dinner, so I gave his wife a call. The evening came and we all watched the video. When it came to the death of the lion I started asking Dave questions about how certain parts of the cartoon related to the story of Jesus, and decided that it might be interesting to read about it in the Bible. He went out to his car and gave me one. For the next few weeks I read the New Testament, and began to feel a transformation taking place. I had no idea how much wisdom there was in this book, and how beautiful and inspiring the life of Christ was. I was particularly moved by the story of His death, and His total devotion to God, righteousness and love of His fellow man. How could He forgive His murderers from the cross? His final words were burned into my mind: "Father, into your hands I commit my spirit." A battle had begun -- an intense mental conflict that lasted a few weeks. I would argue with myself, "This is just a bunch of mythology; you're too smart to believe this. No, this is good, this is true, this is beautiful. There is a God, and He loves you. Jesus died a hideous death for you on the cross." I noticed, however, that once I started reading the Bible the arguing ceased. I would call up Dave to ask questions about what I had read in the Bible, and one evening he prayed for me over the phone, and suggested that I try it myself. Although prayer was a totally foreign concept to me, I felt that somehow I had to give it a try. So, with the greatest sincerity I could muster I knelt in prayer. In Jesus' name I asked God to reveal Himself to me, to bring Christ into my life, to lead me where He wanted me to go. I knew at this point that there was no going back; I just couldn't return to the darkness of my former atheism. But I still lacked the courage of total commitment. I was still in conflict. Then one night I went to a concert at Calvary Chapel, Costa Mesa, California. The master of ceremonies was Warren Duffy, a Christian radio talk show host from whom I had heard about the concert. He asked everyone to do something that they used to do in his church when he was a pastor. He asked us to turn to someone we didn't know, give them a big hug and say, "God loves you and I do too." I turned to the guy standing to my right, and hugged him. He said, "God loves you and I do too." I hesitated just a moment and then said it back to him. The strange thing was, I meant it. At that moment I was overwhelmed with joy and a complete sense of peace, as I felt what I knew was Christ's perfect love overtaking me. It was as though a pair of spiritual eyes, that I didn't even know I had, were opened. Suddenly I understood -- in an indescribable and profoundly spiritual way -- what Christ had done on the cross. As He hung there He was putting His arms around a stranger, saying, "I love you Gil, and my Father who sent me does too." He meant it, and proved it by suffering and dying for me. There was no mistaking it, I had become a Christian, and in silent prayer I accepted Jesus Christ as my Lord and Savior. The battle was over. I have left the dark, cold, depressing, nihilistic depths of atheism, and have been brought into the light, warmth, joy, peace and love of Jesus Christ. The missing piece in my life has been found. I think about my Savior almost always, whether consciously or in the back of my mind. I know that He is with me, even when it might not seem like it. I have new, Christian standards for my life, and although I haven't lived up to all of them, I have Someone on my side to help me work toward these goals.GilDodgen
September 7, 2010
September
09
Sep
7
07
2010
07:52 PM
7
07
52
PM
PDT
Oh! I am definitely pre-ordering this! Thanks for the heads up.IRQ Conflict
September 7, 2010
September
09
Sep
7
07
2010
07:20 PM
7
07
20
PM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply