Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Should atheism be included in religious education?

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

File:Atheism.svg That’s being suggested in Britain:

Humanists UK welcomed the recommendation that humanist beliefs and values be taught. In general, the commission’s conclusions were a “once-in-a-generation opportunity to save the academically serious teaching of religious and non-religious worldviews in our schools”, said Andrew Copson.

But the Catholic Education Service said the report was “not so much an attempt to improve RE as to fundamentally change its character … The quality of religious education is not improved by teaching less religion.”Harriet Sherwood, “Call for atheism to be included in religious education” at The Guardian

Surely the Catholic Education Service is missing the point. Atheism is a religious stance and an important one, given that many prominent people are atheists. Teaching beliefs other than atheists’ beliefs as “religion” means that the worldview on which atheists’ choices are based is going to be represented in a confusing way.

For example, many atheists don’t believe in free will. That doubtless influences what they advocate or think reasonable but if we can’t unpack it, we can’t talk about what it means.

See also: Sam Harris, atheists, and charitable giving

and

Which side will atheists choose in the war on science? They need to re-evaluate their alliance with progressivism, which is doing science no favours.

Comments
Comparative religion courses do discuss atheism, agnosticism, etc, along with the other major groups. I don't know what they're complaining about. Do they want religion courses to be SOLELY about atheism?polistra
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
03:08 PM
3
03
08
PM
PDT
ET:
That doesn’t make any sense at all
Does it need to make sense?Mung
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
10:11 AM
10
10
11
AM
PDT
@Bob O'H one problem with claiming theism is a religion is that it covers a wide variety of beliefs: western Christianity is only one form. Hinduism, for example, is theistic.EricMH
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
08:33 AM
8
08
33
AM
PDT
claiming that atheism is a religion
Until an atheist can prove there's no God, Atheists have a religious belief there is no God. In fact, all the posturing, pretense, and mental frameworks of Atheists rival and often surpass in intensity the same things in people of other beliefs. Andrewasauber
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
07:47 AM
7
07
47
AM
PDT
aarceng - one problem with claiming that atheism is a religion is that it covers a wide variety of beliefs: western Humanism is only one form. Taoism, for example, is atheistic (at least as far as I understand it, although there are spirits within Taoism that are viewed as supernatural, and perhaps even god-like).Bob O'H
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
07:35 AM
7
07
35
AM
PDT
Well Atheism does match **some** definitions of a religion. Religion : a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith : a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universeaarceng
September 17, 2018
September
09
Sep
17
17
2018
03:13 AM
3
03
13
AM
PDT
So Intelligent Design in sex education classes, eh? That doesn't make any sense at allET
September 16, 2018
September
09
Sep
16
16
2018
04:12 PM
4
04
12
PM
PDT
I have no problem with students being taught about atheism or agnosticism in religious education classes just as I have no problem with students being taught about Intelligent Design or taught about the variations of human sexuality in sex education classes. The distinction, which teachers and students should clearly understand, is that there is a difference between teaching about the world's faiths - or lack thereof - and promoting or proselytizing one particular religion.Seversky
September 16, 2018
September
09
Sep
16
16
2018
01:35 PM
1
01
35
PM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply