Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Eggbound baby gulls warn nestmates of threats

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

When they hear the warning cries of adult gulls:

Yellow-legged gull embryos exposed to the warnings of adults and neighboring embryos that had not been exposed to the sounds both displayed a series of behavioral and physiological changes when newly hatched, according to a study published Monday in Nature Ecology & Evolution. By vibrating, the embryos exposed to the call appeared to transfer knowledge of the threat to the others in their nest—the first time such a behavior has resulted in observed changes to clutchmates.

Just as human babies register sounds they hear from the womb, embryos within bird, reptile, amphibian and insect eggs use sensory clues to glean information about their environment. …

“Sounds can give a lot of information to embryos, and they seem to be using it to shape their development to their particular conditions,” says behavioral ecologist Mylene Mariette of Deakin University in Australia, who was not involved in the study.

Jennifer Leman, “Bird embryos vibrate to warn one another of danger before they hatch” at Scientific American

Well, if the embryos are shaping their development in response to warning cries, that puts a whole new spin on “evolution.”

This was the first time we had heard the expression “embryo-to-embryo communication”:

“These results suggest a degree of developmental plasticity based on prenatal social cues, which had hitherto been thought impossible,” Mariette and Buchanan report.

Although chicks tuned in to siblings’ vibrations found themselves better-equipped to respond to danger, Science Alert’s Michelle Starr notes that this advantage came at the cost of reduced energy production and growth. Still, Sheikh writes for the New York Times, the informational advantage represented by nestmates’ warnings “could mean the difference between being eaten or not.”

Meilan Solly, “Unhatched Bird Embryos Communicate With Siblings by Vibrating Their Shells” at Smithsonian Magazine

It would be hard to quantify the advantages of being eaten.

No wonder there are so many gulls in the world.

See also: Does intelligence depend on a specific type of brain?

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Comments
mimus:
It’s a pretty cool finding, but gene-environment interaction is standard evolutionary biology going right back to Fisher.
Show us where in the theory of evolution that says that warning cries will effect development.ET
July 25, 2019
July
07
Jul
25
25
2019
04:53 AM
4
04
53
AM
PDT
Mimus
How? It’s a pretty cool finding, but gene-environment interaction is standard evolutionary biology going right back to Fisher.
Don’t confuse me with facts.Brother Brian
July 24, 2019
July
07
Jul
24
24
2019
05:33 PM
5
05
33
PM
PDT
Well, if the embryos are shaping their development in response to warning cries, that puts a whole new spin on “evolution.”
How? It's a pretty cool finding, but gene-environment interaction is standard evolutionary biology going right back to Fisher.Mimus
July 24, 2019
July
07
Jul
24
24
2019
03:06 PM
3
03
06
PM
PDT
"Just as human babies register sounds they hear from the womb"... Heretic! Scientists aren't supposed to call fetuses babies, and scientists know as an absolute fact that life begins well after birth. Aside from the sarcasm, communication by vibrating shells doesn't seem like a good assumption. Birds don't normally communicate by bumping each other. I'd be inclined to look for mutual inductive coupling among brain waves. Birds do have a refined magnetic sense. The wiggling may be a response to the arousal by parental calls, but that doesn't mean it's a mode of communication.polistra
July 24, 2019
July
07
Jul
24
24
2019
02:16 PM
2
02
16
PM
PDT
OK, but even though these pre-born creatures are clearly communicating, they're not ALIVE, right? I mean, if pre-born animals were ALIVE, then terminating them would be MURDER, no?vmahuna
July 24, 2019
July
07
Jul
24
24
2019
02:04 PM
2
02
04
PM
PDT
I expect they'll end up calling it something a bit briefer and more fancy, such as 'anticipatory evolution'.Axel
July 24, 2019
July
07
Jul
24
24
2019
10:26 AM
10
10
26
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply