Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Every vegan’s nightmare: Those lovely, peacable plants, they don’t really trap and eat worms, do they?

arroba Email

Uuuhhh …

In ‘Hungry plant traps worms underground’ (Nature, January 9, 2012), Katherine Rowland reports, “Hidden feeding strategy suggests carnivory is more common than was thought.”

A study published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences not only offers evidence that Philcoxia species are indeed carnivorous, but also explains why this trait had gone undocumented. P. minensis, researchers found, uses a unique nutrient-acquisition mechanism: its sticky leaves are hidden below the sand.

“This leads to the question of whether there are other carnivorous plants out there in families not known for carnivory,” says Peter Fritsch, a botanist at the California Academy of Sciences in San Francisco, and co-author of both the latest study and the 2007 investigation.

Plant carnivory is known to occur in only 0.2% of flowering plant species. However, Fritsch and his colleagues suggest that this count may be an underestimate. In the words of Mark Chase, a botanist at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, UK, and his colleagues, writing in a 2009 paper on carnivorous lineages, “We may be surrounded by many more murderous plants than we think.”


That awful monstrous space weed that your mother-in-law insists cleans the air probably does it by surreptitiously removing the meatballs from the slow cooker all day long … .

See also: A serious discussion of the evolution puzzle of carnivorous plants.

Also Geneticist W.-E. Loennig replies to Darwinist Nick Matzke: Which is more important: Darwin or facts?

Joe, we're glad to hear that. We've nothing against vegans in particular. But it may be harder getting away from carnivory than some have supposed. The plant world seems to be ethically divided in the matter ... News
OK, I am one tiny step away from being a vegan, I eat some dairy products. Yet I don't see carnivorous plants as any type of nightmare nor any type of ethical problem. Perhaps if vegans ate the plants that ate animals you would have a point. With that they would be eating meat via the plant and that would be an issue, IMHO. Joe
Yes, it would create an ethical problem for a vegan, I suppose. Does the mere fact that the plant has thoughtfully replaced worm substance with its own remove the stain of murder? News
LoL! Do vegans eat these plants? Murderous? Do the plants know that they are killing animals? Too funny... Joe

Leave a Reply