Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

“Evolution” says: We are alone


Guess the odds cited below—of seven key innovations—mean we’ll have to be our own ET:

So maybe each of these seven key innovations evolve just 1% of the time. If so, intelligence will evolve on just 1 in 100 trillion habitable worlds. If habitable worlds are rare, then we might be the only intelligent life in the galaxy, or even the visible universe.

And yet, we’re here. That must count for something, right? If evolution gets lucky one in 100 trillion times, what are the odds we happen to be on a planet where it happened? Actually, the odds of being on that improbable world are 100%, because we couldn’t have this conversation on a world where photosynthesis, complex cells, or animals didn’t evolve. That’s the anthropic principle: Earth’s history must have allowed intelligent life to evolve, or we wouldn’t be here to ponder it.

Intelligence seems to depend on a chain of improbable events. But given the vast number of planets, then like an infinite number of monkeys pounding on an infinite number of typewriters to write Hamlet, it’s bound to evolve somewhere. The improbable result was us.

Nick Longrich, “Evolution tells us we might be the only intelligent life in the universe” at The Conversation

Why do we keep running into arguments for intelligent design that don’t seem to realize that they are arguments for intelligent design?

See also: Tales of an invented god

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Q. Is there intelligent life on Earth? A, Yes, but I'm just visiting Seversky
Revenge of the Fermi Paradox. Somerschool
Amazing how quickly he slid from 100 trillion to infinite... EDTA

Leave a Reply