Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

New archaeopteryx fossil said to strengthen claim that feathers did not evolve for flight

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email
The new (11th) specimen of Archaeopteryx/H. Tischlinger

From ScienceDaily:

Predatory dinosaurs (theropods) with body plumage are now known to predate Archaeopteryx, and their feathers probably provided thermal insulation. Advanced species of predatory dinosaurs and primitive birds with feathered forelimbs may have used them as balance organs when running, like ostriches do today. Moreover, feathers could have served useful functions in brooding, camouflage and display. Indeed, the feathers on the tail, wings and hind-limbs most probably fulfilled functions in display, although it is very likely that Archaeopteryx was also capable of flight. “Interestingly, the lateral feathers in the tail of Archaeopteryx had an aerodynamic form, and most probably played an important role in its aerial abilities,” says Foth.

On the basis of their investigation of the plumage of the new fossil, the researchers have been able to clarify the taxonomical relationship between Archaeopteryx and other species of feathered dinosaur. Here, the diversity in form and distribution of the feather tracts is particularly striking. For instance, among dinosaurs that had feathers on their legs, many had long feathers extending to the toes, while others had shorter down-like plumage. “If feathers had evolved originally for flight, functional constraints should have restricted their range of variation. And in primitive birds we do see less variation in wing feathers than in those on the hind-limbs or the tail,” explains Foth.

These observations imply that feathers acquired their aerodynamic functions secondarily: Once feathers had been invented, they could be co-opted for flight. “It is even possible that the ability to fly evolved more than once within the theropods,” says Rauhut. “Since the feathers were already present, different groups of predatory dinosaurs and their descendants, the birds, could have exploited these structures in different ways.” The new results also contradict the theory that powered avian flight evolved from earlier four-winged species that were able to glide.

Something about this does not sound quite right. Feathers can be used for a number of purposes that other structures can also fulfil. But feathers are essential for bird flight. And the researchers believe that Archaeopteryx could in fact fly.

It seems a stretch to insist that feathers were “invented” (the authors’ term) for a purpose other than flight.

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Comments
leenibus, yes, but sheepskin is just as good, as is a fat layer under the skin (a resort of rodents), or digging below the frost line (a resort of reptiles and amphibians). It seems an odd thesis that feathers, which - like sub-frost mud - are "superb thermal insulation" - would accidentally be the way they are and so happen to turn out to be adapted for flight. Strange things happen, but in Darwin's follower's world, such strange things seem to happen every day. Which suggests that something isn't quite right.News
July 4, 2014
July
07
Jul
4
04
2014
04:15 AM
4
04
15
AM
PDT
rhampton7, were pterosaurs flying or gliding?News
July 4, 2014
July
07
Jul
4
04
2014
04:10 AM
4
04
10
AM
PDT
Hello News, Have you ever owned a down jacket, down vest or down sleeping bag? Feathers are superb thermal insulation. The ability to maintain an optimal body temperature would rank fairly high up the list of advantageous survival techniques for many animals.leenibus
July 4, 2014
July
07
Jul
4
04
2014
12:08 AM
12
12
08
AM
PDT
Pterosaurs predate Birds by tens of millions of years, so we do know that feathers were not necessary flight.rhampton7
July 3, 2014
July
07
Jul
3
03
2014
08:16 PM
8
08
16
PM
PDT
This is just silly. Nothing evolves for anything. EVO 101Mung
July 3, 2014
July
07
Jul
3
03
2014
07:36 PM
7
07
36
PM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply