Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Shallit’s Deposition Now Available Online

William Dembski
November 12, 2005
Evolution, Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Jeffrey Shallit’s deposition in the Dover case is now available online (go here). The deposition itself was attached to the Plaintiff’s argument against the Defense’s motion for summary judgment (go here). I solicit your reactions to Shallit’s deposition.

Comments
Is this who we are talking about > http://www.angelfire.com/amiga2/horizon/Gene-Shalit-web.jpgBombadill
November 12, 2005
November
11
Nov
12
12
2005
10:40 AM
10
10
40
AM
PDT
"What’s happened to your previous blogs on Shallit’s deposition?" You mean the request to have it released? I thought the same thing, but then just figured it makes sense to remove a request when it is fulfilled. Anyway, reading from Shallit's desposition that you don't respond to your [Dembski] critics--and looking at the many responses to your critics on designinference.com, had me confused too. Is he correct that you don't respond to many criticisms? It seems to me you respond to many.Ben Z
November 12, 2005
November
11
Nov
12
12
2005
10:02 AM
10
10
02
AM
PDT
What's happened to your previous blogs on Shallit's deposition?harvey
November 12, 2005
November
11
Nov
12
12
2005
09:55 AM
9
09
55
AM
PDT
The above question might be confusing. It's two questions actually. The first one is: Is his explanation for e-mailing Ruse behind your back valid at all? The second is: Did Ruse forward his request to you on accident, or out of a concern that what Shallit was asking was unethical?Ben Z
November 12, 2005
November
11
Nov
12
12
2005
09:31 AM
9
09
31
AM
PDT
What do you make of his explanation (on pages 164-167 of his desposition) for e-mailing Ruse about the book you co-authored with him? Is it true that he just didn't want you to keep it out for some reason? He says Ruse did it on accident and was mortified; on your page, https://uncommondescent.com/index.php/archives/155, it sounds like Ruse did it out of ethical concern and because he thought what Shallit was asking was unethical.Ben Z
November 12, 2005
November
11
Nov
12
12
2005
09:28 AM
9
09
28
AM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply