Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Were 32 cave symbols a 30 kya communication system?

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

32 symbols von petzinger From Digventures:

Among the elaborate horses, bulls, bears and hunters, there are some other rather less captivating designs – small geometric motifs, etched onto the walls. Until now, they’ve not received much attention. But as it turns out, these humble designs conceal a much more intriguing mystery.

Von Petzinger and her photographer-husband visited 52 caves across Europe recording every instance of these symbols that they could see. They found new, undocumented examples at 75% of the caves they visited, and found the symbols far outnumbered the human and animal images. But the amazing thing was that however many caves they visited, they found the same 32 shapes being used again and again and again.

The fact that the same 32 symbols are repeated across sites that span 30,000 years and an entire content is nothing less than mindblowing. But what do they actually mean? More.

Well, whatever they mean, if this find holds up, they suggest something: If language precedes writing, language has been around for longer than that.

inukshuk at Great Whale River/Nicolas M. Perrault

Note: When there are only a few people and they live far apart, they may develop interlingual symbol systems, to be read by people they may never meet, maybe a decade later. Consider, for example, the inuksuit of the Arctic.

Note 2: Photographer Perrault is clearly a man of the North. With respect to permission to copy his work, he helpfully writes, “You hereby have the permission to use, copy, modify the image and/or pretend to be it’s legitimate author: I couldn’t possibly give any less of a damn.” One suspects that’s how most ancient artists viewed their work too. – O’Leary for News

See also: Can we talk? Language as the business end of consciousness

and

Human evolution, the skinny

Note: Posting light until late this evening, due to O’Leary for News’ alternate day job.

Comments
We still blend text and images today.kairosfocus
December 29, 2015
December
12
Dec
29
29
2015
12:42 AM
12
12
42
AM
PDT
Probably gang symbols etched there while the owners were asleep. Or hobo marks, signifying where to get a good meal. 8-) But on a more serious note, it would be interesting to know what spatial relationship they had, which followed which how often, and so on. (No such data was in the transcript of the TED talk...)EDTA
December 28, 2015
December
12
Dec
28
28
2015
05:36 PM
5
05
36
PM
PDT
These "symboloids" could be the tracks of ancient burrowing worms. The inference that these were left by purposeful intelligent and language capable agents is simply unwarranted. Or so I've heard.leodp
December 28, 2015
December
12
Dec
28
28
2015
04:10 PM
4
04
10
PM
PDT
32 eh. Took us years to get to 32-bit processors.Mung
December 28, 2015
December
12
Dec
28
28
2015
03:29 PM
3
03
29
PM
PDT
Wow. I hope this holds up. This would, among other things, help prove that there was a single Atlantean culture(people dwelling along the Atlantic Ocean, not people living in the fictional City of Atlantis) prior to intrusion of the MUCH later Aryans/Indo-Europeans. And again on the silly suggestion that humans spent 900,000 years not being able to talk. Human babies form thoughts before they're born. I'm guessing these include concepts like "hug" and "mom" and "knock off the Tabasco Sauce". And once they arrive in the outside world, they are INTENSELY interested in the faces of other humans and learning how to repeat sounds that their pack-mates make. How could humans have AVOIDED composing a spoken language?mahuna
December 28, 2015
December
12
Dec
28
28
2015
01:54 PM
1
01
54
PM
PDT

Leave a Reply