Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Oakes: Nietzsche, the Only Honest Atheist

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Ed Oakes has a fabulous essay over at FT.  A taste:

Today, one can hardly find more puffed-up braggarts than those noisy New Atheists currently mounting their soapboxes in Hyde Park, and who seem to labor under the assumption that they are doing the human race a favor by attacking belief in God. In fact, as Nietzsche saw, in his own inimitably ironic way, these atheist frat boys are really attacking science. This is because for Nietzsche—who was perhaps the only truly honest atheist in the history of philosophy—science was ultimately a moral, not an epistemological problem, a point he drove home with special force in The Gay Science (all italics are his):

The question “Why science?” leads back to the moral problem: Why have morality at all when life, nature, and history are “not moral”? . . . [I]t is still a metaphysical faith upon which our faith in science rests—even we seekers after knowledge today, we godless anti-metaphysicians still take our fire, too, from the flame lit by a faith that is thousands of years old, that Christian faith which was also the faith of Plato, that God is the truth, that truth is divine. —But what if this should become more and more incredible, if nothing should prove to be divine any more unless it were error, blindness, the lie—if God himself should prove to be our most enduring lie?

 

In other words, atheist “scientists” are eating away at the very foundation that makes science possible in the first place. If God is “our most enduring lie,” science is inevitably founded on that same lie. After all, science teaches that all stars eventually die out, and with them the planets that orbit them, and once those planets are consumed by the suns that gave them birth, so too will vanish the pathetic creatures that emerged from their respective planetary slimes. Sure, soon after their emergence, they began to invent such high-blown Platonic words like knowledge and truth during their brief strut upon the otherwise empty stage of the cosmos. But so what?

I am not trying to argue here against such a scenario, it being an option impervious to argument anyway, at least among those who have already adopted it as their primary framework for addressing all other questions. (I speak from experience.) But it is a scenario that can hardly be regarded as consequence-free. The battle is still between nihilism and theism. There is no third option.

Comments
Paulbaird, Thanks for the response. I just don't believe ID's merits are going to be decided by a court. If we allow them to, then we have no right to call ID science. What has to happen is a paradigm shift. The old school dies out, and a new generation that is more ID friendly comes to the reigns. It's not really our fight. Our fight is in presenting ID, and that's all. Forget Kitzmiller. If ID advocates have the better argument, then it will catch on among the young, and they will earn degrees, and get teaching positions, and soon enough the science academy will no longer be populated by an atheistic majority. I think the whole Wedge strategy, if you want my honest opinion, was wrongheaded. All ID advocates really need to do is present ID in the best light and with the most rigor. The legislation and the politics will take care of itself.CannuckianYankee
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
11:11 AM
11
11
11
AM
PST
Perhaps my comment #25 wasn't clear enough: In the title, at least the missing "s" in Nietzsche's name should be inserted...DiEb
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
10:19 AM
10
10
19
AM
PST
I think much confusion arises from the equivocal use of the word "faith." In New Testament times, the word meant, basically, either an act of the will, i.e. a choice (based upon sufficient reason) or a body of doctrine that is believed (again, having sufficient reason). However, if I go to the M-W online dictionary, I find this phrase as one of the definitions of faith: "firm belief in something for which there is no proof". This is decidedly NOT what the New Testament writers had in mind when they used the word pistis or pisteuo. However, it seems to me that is often the meaning ascribed to the word in many of these conversations. So in 21st century vernacular, as a Christian, I am not a person of faith, I am a person of REASON. It is the atheists who are people of faith in the 21st century meaning of the word. Exodus 3:14 "I AM WHO I AM" God reveals Himself as the foundation for all rational thought - the Personalization of the First Principles of Reason. He reveals Himself to us, as, among other things, a God of REASON. He IS Being and Identity. Small wonder then, that reason is the universal method of acquiring truth. And small wonder that the "new" atheists, or more properly perhaps, the anti-theists, commit the error warned against (violating the Law of Identity) in Isaiah 5:20 "woe to you who call evil good and good evil". Only they say it like this: I am a person of reason and you are a person of "faith" when it is exactly the opposite that is true. They call their "faith" reason and our reason "faith."tgpeeler
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
07:52 AM
7
07
52
AM
PST
Countering The New Atheism Of Richard Dawkins - Dan Petersen - 20 minute video http://www.tangle.com/view_video?viewkey=e2c9a21a5403f439f879 ----------------- Nickelback - Savin' Me - song http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPc-o-4Nsbkbornagain77
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
02:49 AM
2
02
49
AM
PST
Zeroseven, your entire post is saturated with arrogance. In fact, it's spoken like the typical "holier than thou" atheist.Berceuse
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
01:17 AM
1
01
17
AM
PST
11.CannuckianYankee PaulBaird, “Given the excellent evidence that ID appears to have in it’s favour when can we expect Kitzmiller v Dover II (aka Scopes III) ?” I’m not certain if you’re being serious or facetious. If you want a court to decide what is true for you, then science isn’t a quest for truth. Truth simply becomes the resolve of legislation – a system, which at one time legalized slavery. If you want that as your final authority, I wish you good will with it. But you spelled it ‘favour,’ so I would assume your life is not even legislated by the us courts. ================================= Yes I was being serious. US and UK law are inter-linked, if only persuasively. If you are serious about advancing ID then you are going to have to deal with this issue, otherwise the whole ID debate belongs in the ivory tower world of academia. Certainly any UK government considering allowing the teaching of ID in schools will quickly come up against the objection founded on the US Kitzmiller judgement. This objection is already codified in the guidance issued by the Department for Education, but it could be altered, based on the Michael Gove's (the new Secretary of State for Education) views on the independence of schools and the role of faith organisations in setting up new schools. If the Kitzmiller judgement stands uncontested then that battle is lost before it begins.paulbaird
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
12:51 AM
12
12
51
AM
PST
Oakes: Nietzsche - perhaps the only truly honest atheist in the history of philosophy.DiEb
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
12:48 AM
12
12
48
AM
PST
zeroseven You're missing the point. What is "meaning?" If you believe that all of the things you and I think or feel or do in our lives ends in a few short years with our eternal death; if all of the thoughts and things done by mankind end up in the destruction of Earth and all we have done in a relatively short time; if everything that gives meaning to our lives vanishes without a trace in the not too distant future (relatively speaking in the face of eternity) why would anyone want to propagate and defend such a meaningless end to our existence? Why is anything you do important if it all ends in a short while with nothingness? Sure, you could say that even though our lives and humanity is a temporary blip on the face of eternity that still we are here and let's make the best of it. But that is exactly what you oppose. Preaching atheism to try to convince everyone that everything and everyone is existentially doomed is not a sign of someone who has found true meaning in life. Rather it shows someone who sees no meaning in life other than what can be experienced in the moment. You say that belief in a "divine creator" who made the "world just for you" is arrogant, and that you don't need such a belief. No one is saying God made the universe "just for you." God made the universe because God needed something to do and other people to be with. And if you want to be happy, truly happy, you do need to believe that because it is your only hope for life beyond the end of your body. As for the rest of you -- faith is not something someone can intellectually decide to have. Atheists generally cannot be changed intellectually. Even if it seems that someone gained faith due to an intellectual argument, you need to understand that the ability to see the truth of God is due to God himself revealing that truth -- or hiding it -- according to a person's destiny. No amount of scientific exposition will force someone to see the light if God sees fit to keep them in darkness. I see so much frustration by theists because they cannot understand that what is glaringly obvious to them -- is not seen by so many very intelligent people. The truth is obvious, there is no doubt about that, but everyone has their destiny, or karma, to go through. Realize that God is in control of that.mentok
May 27, 2010
May
05
May
27
27
2010
12:27 AM
12
12
27
AM
PST
Pelagius: “ You seem to be saying that science is impossible if our existence is transient. I don’t see how the latter implies the former. …” Oakes didn't say that our “transience” or the “meaninglessness” of our lives makes ‘science’ impossible. What Oaks said (rightly) is that "This atheist scenario [which seeks to explain how 'science' fits into the world] undermines science itself;" for, once we, as persons, understand/grasp the “atheist scenario,” then we understand/grasp the utter pointlessness of ‘science,’ or of anything else. Continuing on to deeper understanding, it isn't that we die, that everything dies, that "the universe" will die that explains why the "atheist scenario undermines science itself." It isn’t the meaninglessness (if atheism is the truth about the nature of reality) of all existence that explains why the "atheist scenario undermines science itself." It is that, IF atheism is the truth about the nature of reality, THEN materialism/naturalism the truth about the nature of reality … and, IF materialism/naturalism the truth about the nature of reality, THEN all things, including the “thoughts” of scientists, are reducible to, and wholly explicable in terms of, matter-in-motion. If atheism is the truth about the nature of reality, then there are no thoughts: atheism destroys science because atheism destroys thought and reason and knowledge. Thank God that atheism is *not* the truth about the nature of reality, and that we *can* think real and true thoughts and can possess/know real and true knowledge.Ilion
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
08:58 PM
8
08
58
PM
PST
B.Arington: "He displays an unreflective fideism (to atheism) that would have made a medieval churchman blush." I'd have thought that a "medieval churchman" has even less use for fideism than we so-rational moderns do.Ilion
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
08:52 PM
8
08
52
PM
PST
Thanks, Phaedros Really, if you think about it, all the tiresome philosophical quests for meaning over the last several hundred years culminate with the wisdom of Solomon. Yet Solomon didn't simply conclude that all is meaningless. I think he was keenly aware of what naturalism is, and what it leads to. His words are profoundly prophetic to our current circumstance.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
04:55 PM
4
04
55
PM
PST
Thanks cannuckianyankee.Phaedros
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
04:38 PM
4
04
38
PM
PST
CannuckianYankee @15, yes I guess that is all I'm saying. Or, to be more specific, I don't need a "celestial dictator" to give my life meaning. My sense of self and relationships with my fellow humans (and for that matter, non-human animals) are what give my life meaning. Barry, yes, I believe those questions are trivial in the sense of not having any meaningful responses. I don't think my assertion is absurd, I think the questions are. I am not afraid of my lack of consequence in the universe. I don't need to believe that a divine creator made it just for me. I'm not that arrogant.zeroseven
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
04:27 PM
4
04
27
PM
PST
Sorry, The Ecclesiastes quote is from The New English Translation (NETbible)CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
03:27 PM
3
03
27
PM
PST
Zeroseven, I should have pointed out also that you're attempting to find meaning out of what you concede is meaningless. Read Ecclesiastes if you want a lesson in the futility of human secular endeavor. “Futile! Futile!” laments the Teacher, “Absolutely futile! Everything is futile!” What benefit do people get from all the effort which they expend on earth? A generation comes and a generation goes, but the earth remains the same through the ages. The sun rises and the sun sets; it hurries away to a place from which it rises again. The wind goes to the south and circles around to the north; round and round the wind goes and on its rounds it returns...... .....All this monotony is tiresome; no one can bear to describe it: The eye is never satisfied with seeing, nor is the ear ever content with hearing. What exists now is what will be, and what has been done is what will be done; there is nothing truly new on earth....... .......No one remembers the former events, nor will anyone remember the events that are yet to happen; they will not be remembered by the future generations. I, the Teacher, have been king over Israel in Jerusalem. I decided to carefully and thoroughly examine all that has been accomplished on earth. I concluded: God has given people a burdensome task that keeps them occupied. I reflected on everything that is accomplished by man on earth, and I concluded: Everything he has accomplished is futile – like chasing the wind!....... ......I decided to discern the benefit of wisdom and knowledge over foolish behavior and ideas; however, I concluded that even this endeavor is like trying to chase the wind! For with great wisdom comes great frustration; whoever increases his knowledge merely increases his heartache.(1:1-18) His conclusion? There is nothing better for people than to eat and drink, and to find enjoyment in their work. I also perceived that this ability to find enjoyment comes from God. For no one can eat and drink or experience joy apart from him. For to the one who pleases him, God gives wisdom, knowledge, and joy, but to the sinner, he gives the task of amassing wealth only to give it to the one who pleases God. This task of the wicked is futile – like chasing the wind! (2:24-26) So God is the basis for meaningful life and enjoyment. Chasing the wind is circular, as the author describes it. The wind simply returns eventually to where it was before. This is the author's assessment of secular wisdom and toil. It is circular. It has no grounding. The grounding of theism is not circular, because it is not naturalistic. It's grounded in He who transcends nature.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
03:24 PM
3
03
24
PM
PST
zeroseven writes: “I don’t see why the transience and meaninglessness of our existence makes science pointless. . . . And our existence is only meaningless in respect of the trivial and pointless questions like “why are we here” or “what is our purpose”. Fascinating comment. The very next sentence in Oakes’ essay after the ones I quoted is: “I am not trying to argue here against such a scenario, it being an option impervious to argument anyway, at least among those who have already adopted it as their primary framework for addressing all other questions.” zeroseven proves Oakes’ statement. For whatever reason, he has already adopted the atheistic narrative, and he is impervious to any rational argument that does not fit within his belief system. He displays an unreflective fideism (to atheism) that would have made a medieval churchman blush. Let us examine the two assertions in his comment: 1. “I don’t see why the transience and meaninglessness of our existence makes science pointless.” If you cannot see why the meaninglessness of everything means that everything is meaningless, I cannot help you. You are, as Oakes says, impervious to argument. 2. “And our existence is only meaningless in respect of the trivial and pointless questions like “why are we here” or “what is our purpose”. Yes, it is true, that our existence is meaningless only with respect to questions about meaning. You’ve got me there. But your assertion that these questions are “trivial” and “pointless” is absurd on its face. If you were correct, a corollary to your assertion would be that the greatest minds in the history of humanity devoted themselves almost exclusively to “trivial and pointless” questions. You don’t really believe that, no matter how much you continue to whistle in the dark.Barry Arrington
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
02:58 PM
2
02
58
PM
PST
Zeroseven, "I don’t see why the transience and meaninglessness of our existence makes science pointless. In fact, I think that makes it all the more worthwhile. And our existence is only meaningless in respect of the trivial and pointless questions like 'why are we here' or 'what is our purpose'. I know that personally I find a lot of meaning in my existence and discovering the wonders of the cosmos and our planet is one of those activities that does provide meaning for me during my brief experience of life." The problem is that your rendering finding purpose and meaning as 'trivial' is subjective. You have no basis for that assessment outside of your own prejudice. The same goes for the meaning that you find in your life. There's no basis for the meaning, so it's meaningless. It's a circular argument - quite tautological: "I find meaning in life because my life is meaningful." That's all you're saying.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
02:49 PM
2
02
49
PM
PST
But then with me the horrid doubt always arises whether the convictions of man's mind, which has been developed from the mind of the lower animals, are of any value or at all trustworthy. Would any one trust in the convictions of a monkey's mind, if there are any convictions in such a mind? ~ Charles Darwin If my mental processes are determined wholly by the motions of atoms in my brain, I have no reason to suppose that my beliefs are true. They may be sound chemically, but that does not make them sound logically. ~ J.B.S. Haldane The ultimate irony is that this philosophy implies that Darwinism itself is just another meme, competing in the infectivity sweepstakes by attaching itself to that seductive word "science." Dawkins ceaselessly urges us to be rational, but be does so in the name of a philosophy that implies that no such thing as rationality exists because our thoughts are at the mercy of our genes and memes. The proper conclusion is that the Dawkins poor brain has been infected by the Darwin meme, a virus of the mind if ever there was one, and we wonder if he will ever be able to find the cure. ~ Phillip Johnson The very notion of physical law is a theological one in the first place, a fact that makes many scientists squirm. Isaac Newton first got the idea of absolute, universal, perfect, immutable laws from the Christian doctrine that God created the world and ordered it in a rational way. ~ Paul Davies Modern science was conceived, and born, and flourished in the matrix of Christian theism. Only liberal doses of self-deception and double-think, I believe, will permit it to flourish in the context of Darwinian naturalism. ~ Alvin Plantingabevets
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
02:11 PM
2
02
11
PM
PST
Barry, I assume you agree with Oakes, having described his essay as "fabulous". I must say, it's a point I don't get. I don't see why the transience and meaninglessness of our existence makes science pointless. In fact, I think that makes it all the more worthwhile. And our existence is only meaningless in respect of the trivial and pointless questions like "why are we here" or "what is our purpose". I know that personally I find a lot of meaning in my existence and discovering the wonders of the cosmos and our planet is one of those activities that does provide meaning for me during my brief experience of life.zeroseven
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
02:08 PM
2
02
08
PM
PST
Barry, Did you forget to create a title for this thread?CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
02:00 PM
2
02
00
PM
PST
PaulBaird, "Given the excellent evidence that ID appears to have in it’s favour when can we expect Kitzmiller v Dover II (aka Scopes III) ?" I'm not certain if you're being serious or facetious. If you want a court to decide what is true for you, then science isn't a quest for truth. Truth simply becomes the resolve of legislation - a system, which at one time legalized slavery. If you want that as your final authority, I wish you good will with it. But you spelled it 'favour,' so I would assume your life is not even legislated by the us courts.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
01:58 PM
1
01
58
PM
PST
I should have added at the end of 9: With absolutely no basis for the rationality.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
01:46 PM
1
01
46
PM
PST
Barry, The next charge from the atheists is going to be: Well if atheism renders science pointless, then how come there are so many atheists involved in science? I would answer that by saying it is because atheists in general have few other options within which to search for meaning. Even though science is really a dead end for such meaning, at least they can pretend that it does. Also, much of the meaning that atheists affirm in their lives is spun off the coattails of theism. Think about it; baseless morality is gathered from the dregs of theists, but they cannot with those dregs produce their own morality. All they do is pick out the parts they like from theistic morality, and leave out the parts they don't. Then they champion those parts as their own. They've done the same thing with science. Science would not be where it is today without a prior theistic rationality and worldview. Now atheists are championing science and rationality as their own.CannuckianYankee
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
01:41 PM
1
01
41
PM
PST
pelagius regarding your comment at [1]. I am not saying anything. This is all a quote from Oakes' essay. To your point, I don't think Oakes is saying science is impossible if our existence is transient and meaninless. He is saying that if our existence is transient and meaningless, science is pointless. If a society becomes convinced that an activity is pointless, then the cultural foundation upon which that activity rests will cease to exist.Barry Arrington
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
01:20 PM
1
01
20
PM
PST
Given the excellent evidence that ID appears to have in it's favour when can we expect Kitzmiller v Dover II (aka Scopes III) ?paulbaird
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
11:19 AM
11
11
19
AM
PST
Innerbling- You're right it's not funny, it is sad. Ultimately it degrades the value of the human intellect, spirit, and worth.Phaedros
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
11:18 AM
11
11
18
AM
PST
Phaedros in 3: "I find it funny that the atheists commenting on that essay keep repeating the mantra of “raligious faith is unwarranted and uncritical belief” and “faith is antithetical to reason”." I find it to be extremely sad as in materialistic atheism there cannot be any reason because when that worldview is taken to it's final conclusion we don't in fact exists at all only matter and physical laws exist and even those can cease to exist at any moment.Innerbling
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
10:59 AM
10
10
59
AM
PST
oops hit submit too soon- As Rodney Stark put it, there is a faith in reason and atheists must have a much stronger faith in their reason if atheism is true than a Christian does.Phaedros
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
09:49 AM
9
09
49
AM
PST
I find it funny that the atheists commenting on that essay keep repeating the mantra of "raligious faith is unwarranted and uncritical belief" and "faith is antithetical to reason".Phaedros
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
09:48 AM
9
09
48
AM
PST
"... The battle is still between nihilism and theism. There is no third option." Exactly. And, since nihilism inevitably leads us to all sorts of absurdity (including that we ourselves cannot reason), we must, reasonably and logically, reject it ... and, rejecting nihilism, reject God-denial.Ilion
May 26, 2010
May
05
May
26
26
2010
09:09 AM
9
09
09
AM
PST
1 2 3 4