Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

3X+1 is an unexpectedly weird math problem

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The Collatz Conjecture is the simplest math problem no one can solve — it is easy enough for almost anyone to understand but notoriously difficult to solve.

Toward the end: “If anything it shows that all the things we can solve are miracles.”

More on the Collatz Conjecture.

Hat tip: Heather Zeiger

See also: Things exist that are unknowable: A tutorial on Chaitin’s number

and

Yes, you can manipulate infinity in math. The hyperreals are bigger (and smaller) than your average number — and better! (Jonathan Bartlett)

Comments
Thanks. I'll check their site also for sale pricing.Silver Asiatic
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
01:21 PM
1
01
21
PM
PDT
The Amazon audible version was $35. I think I have the VHS version someplace. If I see the audio one on sale, I will post it but you have to be around that day. Another good one by same author is Science and Religion.jerry
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
01:18 PM
1
01
18
PM
PDT
I wish they would notify me when those go on sale. I'm digging into the roots and origins of science. That course shows that science emerged from theism and Christianity specifically. I saw it listed for around $99, which seems too much for just audio. I look on EBay for Great Courses also and there are hundreds. But a used copy of that one is still $60 which is probably a very good deal but it seems a lot for audio and no book. A few people have old VHS versions for around $30 and that just seems crazy. Especially because as you say they offer brand new DVD sets for $20 to 30. The one on Quantum Theory you posted looks good also.Silver Asiatic
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
12:57 PM
12
12
57
PM
PDT
I am waiting for the price to drop on the History of Science, ancient to 1700
All the history of science courses are good. I like the more modern era ones better since more has happened since 1700. They go on sale every 4-6 weeks. Some times at very low prices. They also have a program where you can stream hundreds of video courses for a yearly fee. I have that but will get those courses that show up at about $20/$30 per 24/36 lectures when they are on sale. Normal prices are 70% off list but have seen them occasionally at 90% off list. The History Science prior to 1700 is only on audio so not on their yearly streaming. It is probably available on Audible. But doesn’t come with a course book. They recently on The Great Courses, last week, had all audio courses on sale.jerry
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
11:35 AM
11
11
35
AM
PDT
But another way is The Great Courses. I recently purchased a course for less than a dollar a lecture
I am waiting for the price to drop on the History of Science, ancient to 1700. That one was highly recommended to me. A very excellent Great Courses I completed was Daniel Robinson on the nature of Consciousness. I was shocked to discover he is a Thomist-realist with tremendous knowledge of contemporary ideas on consciousness. Dr. Robinson recently passed away - R.I.P.Silver Asiatic
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
09:36 AM
9
09
36
AM
PDT
Fell apart at the end by promoting Brilliant. We can all waste time in various ways and maybe Brilliant is one. But another way is The Great Courses. I recently purchased a course for less than a dollar a lecture, called Great Thinkers, Great Theorems. If you are interested in mathematics, this is the best one I’ve seen. Three lectures just on Euclid. He did not use any numbers. Question- how does one define a right angle with no numbers. https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/great-thinkers-great-theoremsjerry
August 13, 2021
August
08
Aug
13
13
2021
09:16 AM
9
09
16
AM
PDT
H, there are as yet no generally accepted proofs. KFkairosfocus
August 12, 2021
August
08
Aug
12
12
2021
11:54 AM
11
11
54
AM
PDT
At collatz.com, Franz Ziegler offers a proof of the Collatz Conjecture (3n+1). Is this proof valid? Why or why not?hoosfoos
August 12, 2021
August
08
Aug
12
12
2021
07:51 AM
7
07
51
AM
PDT
Fascinating!Barry Arrington
August 12, 2021
August
08
Aug
12
12
2021
06:00 AM
6
06
00
AM
PDT
Yes, indeed, this is an interesting problem, as was noted here earlier. Your linked case, for 3 illustrates how the process looks for the ladder of powers of 2 and once this hits, goes to the 421 loop: 3, 10, 5, 16, 8, 4, 2, 1,… KFkairosfocus
August 12, 2021
August
08
Aug
12
12
2021
12:11 AM
12
12
11
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply