Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

A new look at an old idea – Geocentrism


In another thread a new sock puppet contributor on Uncommon Descent named TheYellowShark with an as yet undetermined appendage writes:

Geocentricsm was accepted beyond all reasonable doubt the scientific community circa 1610. Being in an echo chamber isn’t good for anybody.


And intelligent design was accepted by the scientific community prior to 1859. Both ideas were replaced, and rightfully so.

Rightfully so? Think again my cartilaginous fishy friend. Nothing in science is beyond refute.

Is Earth at the heart of a giant cosmic void?

New Scientist issue 2682
12 November 2008
by Marcus Chown

IT WAS the evolutionary theory of its age. A revolutionary hypothesis that undermined the cherished notion that we humans are somehow special, driving a deep wedge between science and religion. The philosopher Giordano Bruno was burned at the stake for espousing it; Galileo Galilei, the most brilliant scientist of his age, was silenced. But Nicolaus Copernicus’s idea that Earth was just one of many planets orbiting the sun – and so occupied no exceptional position in the cosmos – has endured and become a foundation stone of our understanding of the universe.

Could it actually be wrong, though? At first glance, that question might seem heretical, or downright silly. But as our cosmic horizons have expanded over the centuries so too has the scope of Copernicus’s idea. It has morphed into the Copernican, or cosmological, principle: that nothing distinguishes the position of Earth’s galaxy from any other place in the entire universe. And that idea, some cosmologists point out, has not been tested beyond all doubt – yet.

Copernicus’s principle has not been tested beyond doubt — yet
That could be about to change. A new generation of experiments might shore up the cosmic orthodoxy – or blow it out of the water. That unexpected alternative, some people go so far as to say, might be no bad thing at all.

Read the entire New Scientist article at the link above.

Cool link, Dave. Thanks. tribune7
I think this is on-topic: Irish environment minister charges climate change alarmists with ignorance of the science they claim supports their view: http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/environment/environment-minister-sammy-wilson-i-still-think-manmade-climate-change-is-a-con-14123972.html russ

Leave a Reply