Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

At Rational Religion, Umar Nasser critiques atheist Ricky Gervais on the laws of nature

arroba Email

Ricky Gervais takes on Stephen Colbert – we review bit by bit!

The video we’re reviewing:

Umar Nasser and his brother are Ahmadiyya Muslims. If you liked Michael Egnor vs. Matt Dillahunty (here), you’ll probably like this one too.

You may also wish to read: A thoughtful critique of Philip Goff’s panpsychism Umar Nasser: I was quite disappointed at his treatment of dualism. I felt like he listed some objections against it but didn’t really seek to give counter-objections, as it might hold up too well as compared to his preferred option of panpsychism [everything is conscious to some degree].

As to Ricky Gervais repeating that old atheist slogan "I believe in one less God than you', well, John DeRosa recently (2020) wrote a book by that very name. A book that answers the most common Slogans, Clichès, and Fallacies that Atheists use,
One Less God Than You: How to Answer the Slogans, Clichès, and Fallacies That Atheists Use to Challenge Your Faith – June 1, 2020 by John DeRosa Have you heard these ones before? The God of the Bible is a bloodthirsty dictator. Religion is the cause of war, suffering, and intolerance. Whether on Twitter, in a college quad, or at the dinner table with a freshman philosophy major, you're probably familiar with the litany of slogans that religious skeptics employ in an attempt to rescue you from the foolish belief that God exists. Even our public schools and mainstream media often can't help but parrot the memes that seem to leave thinking people with no alternative but to embrace atheism. How can a Christian respond? In One Less God Than You, John DeRosa breaks down twenty of the most common atheist challenges, exposes their logical weaknesses, and shows you how to craft effective answers. Atheism is more aggressive and widespread than ever before, so believers have a crucial task. Read One Less God Than You and respond with the joyful truth that God is real. https://www.amazon.com/One-Less-God-Than-You/dp/1683571657 John DeRosa - audio interview https://www.catholic.com/audio/cal/one-less-god-than-you
Of related note:
Answering Atheism: I believe in one less God than you. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHlnEQPSWFM GOD, GODS, AND FAIRIES by David Bentley Hart - June 2013 One of the strangest claims often made by purveyors and consumers of today’s popular atheism is that disbelief in God involves no particular positive philosophy of reality,,,, it is absurd to think that one can profess atheism in any meaningful way without thereby assenting to an entire philosophy of being, however inchoate one’s sense of it may be. The philosophical naturalist’s view of reality is not one that merely fails to find some particular object within the world that the theist imagines can be described there; it is a very particular representation of the nature of things, entailing a vast range of purely metaphysical commitments. Principally, it requires that one believe that the physical order, which both experience and reason say is an ensemble of ontological contingencies, can exist entirely of itself, without any absolute source of actuality. It requires also that one resign oneself to an ultimate irrationalism: For the one reality that naturalism can never logically encompass is the very existence of nature (nature being, by definition, that which already exists); it is a philosophy, therefore, surrounded, permeated, and exceeded by a truth that is always already super naturam, and yet a philosophy that one cannot seriously entertain except by scrupulously refusing to recognize this. It is the embrace of an infinite paradox: the universe understood as an “absolute contingency.” It may not amount to a metaphysics in the fullest sense, since strictly speaking it possesses no rational content—it is, after all, a belief that all things rest upon something like an original moment of magic—but it is certainly far more than the mere absence of faith. https://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/06/god-gods-and-fairies
I may have missed this in the conversation, but if Ricky Gervais believes that "nature" can explain everything, how does he explain "stuff" before nature existed? OldArmy94

Leave a Reply