Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Bob Argues With a Saudi About Whether it is Good to Execute Homosexuals

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

While Saudi Arabia is in the news, I have a question for our subjectivist friends.  In the United States it is considered morally wrong to execute a person for being a homosexual.  In Saudi Arabia it is considered morally right to execute a person for being a homosexual.

As I understand subjectivist reasoning, morality is subjective and culturally determined.  If you were in Saudi Arabia I assume you would attempt to get them to change their mind about executing homosexuals.  I am curious.  How would you argue for that?  I can imagine a subjectivist (let’s call him “Bob”) making a number of arguments, and a probable response from a Saudi:

  1. Bob: Executing people because they are homosexual is morally reprehensible.

Saudi:  That’s just your opinion Bob.  In my opinion executing people because they are homosexual is morally correct and laudable.  And you yourself tell me that your personal subjective view on the matter is no “better,” in any meaningful sense of that word, than mine.  So why should I care what you think?

  1. Bob: It is not just my opinion.  The people of the United States believe it is immoral to execute a person for being homosexual.  The Saudi people should be more like the American people.

Saudi:  Why?  The analysis does not change when you compare your group to mine.  Your own principles as a subjectivist tell me that the American view on the matter is no better, in any meaningful sense of that word, than the Saudi view.

  1. Bob: Don’t you believe in moral progress?  Every progressive nation believes that executing homosexuals is wrong.  Don’t you want to be progressive?

Saudi:  “Progressive”?  By what standard are you progressive?  Again, it is merely your opinion whether you are progressive.  Your own first principles say there is no objective standard by which progress toward “progressive” goals can be measured.  And I disagree.  We consider your coddling of homosexuals not to be progressive but decadent.

  1. Bob: Do you not care that the Western world rejects your views on this matter.

Saudi:  First, you are wrong.  Some progressive Westerners – the ones that understand their own premises forbid them from judging us – say “who am I to judge the Saudis.”  Second, no, I don’t care what you and your friends think Bob.  What is more, you yourself cannot give me a reason why I should care about what you and your friends think.  Besides, I will turn it back on you:  Don’t you care that the whole Islamic world rejects your views on the matter?

What am I missing?  The one argument that Bob can never logically make is that it is actually objectively wrong (as opposed to wrong in his humble opinion) to execute homosexuals.

Comments
When SA wrote, "It [belief in Jesus] is a logical or intellectual development of the natural moral law", Stephen replied,
How is belief in Jesus a logical development of the natural moral law? God yes, but Jesus?
, which I think is a good question. Rather than pursue that (which SA has done), I'd like to ask another question, for Stephen. Back at 228, Stephen wrote,
However, once one accepts the natural law as an objective fact, it prompts the next logical question: If such a law exists, doesn’t that require a lawgiver? If so, who might that lawmaker be? The obvious candidate would be God (but not necessarily the God/Man Jesus).
So my question is given the natural moral law NML, what is the extent of the logical conclusions one can draw, beyond the conclusion that there must be a lawgiver, God? What attributes of this God (who is not logically necessarily the Christian God) can be considered logically necessary attributes? P.S. I am also still interested in the questions I asked in 238.jdk
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
04:27 PM
4
04
27
PM
PST
Sorry - historical evidence is needed for #4. Life of Jesus.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
12:22 PM
12
12
22
PM
PST
StephenB
How is belief in Jesus a logical development of the natural moral law? God yes, but Jesus? I can understand how you can use reason and other kinds of information to get there, but not from NML alone.
Well, if the NML proves that God exists, then all additional arguments about God follow from that. So, the NML provides the first premise in all additional arguments. 1. Objective morality exists, therefore God exists (proof from NML alone). 2. Since God exists, then there is one all-powerful being 3. Only an all-powerful being can raise himself from the dead 4. Jesus raised himself from the dead 5. Therefore Jesus is God. Yes, historical, testimonial evidence is needed for #3, but that's true for many derivations of the Moral Law. We will often need additional information to determine moral ideas based on the NML. Is an atom bomb moral justified in all cases? We need to know what an atom bomb is, and what it does. Was Aristotle's (and St. Thomas') view on abortion correct? Science informs us more to give a better understanding of what the NML indicates. Is homosexuality genetically determined? The NML can only give general principles - in that case, about the purpose of marriage and procreation. But derivations of the NML require additional information in order to reason about it.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
12:21 PM
12
12
21
PM
PST
Silver Asiatic
The NML is generalized principles. “To respect and care for the lives of other humans is good. To murder people is bad”. “To give help to those in need is morally good. To steal from people in need is morally evil”. Things like that.
Yes.
From those principles, others are derived. But belief that Jesus is true God to be worshipped is not a self-evident principle of the NML. It is derived, rationally from the NML.
I don't think you can get to Jesus from the NML or principles derived from it without adding new information from an outside source, such as history, scripture, or other religious sources? (Or is belief in Jesus an addition to following the natural moral law).
It’s a logical or intellectual development of the natural moral law.
Can you take me through that process? How is belief in Jesus a logical development of the natural moral law? God yes, but Jesus? I can understand how you can use reason and other kinds of information to get there, but not from NML alone.StephenB
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
10:51 AM
10
10
51
AM
PST
re 228: Thanks for all the explanation of your beliefs, Stephen. You write,
The reason people lose their souls is because they refuse to love. (God and their neighbor).
So if I love my neighbor (but don't believe in the Christian God), and live a life that all would agree is in accordance with the natural moral law, I will still go to hell: that I gather is the correct conclusion. This seems to me to be an unreasonable and unlikely characteristic of a divine entity who has created this whole universe, and one that I would not be willing to accept. A corallary question: Suppose I do believe in the Christian God, and do in general believe in and try to live in accordance with the natural moral law, but disagree about some specific common conclusion: for instance, I support same -sex marriage. Will I still go to hell? Or is belief in Jesus etc. the deciding fator in whether I do or don't go to hell? Or do my actions matter, and to what extent?jdk
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
07:15 AM
7
07
15
AM
PST
StephenB (w/attention for jdk's question)
So, the empirical evidence suggests that if anyone who claims to speak for God should be believed, that person would be Jesus Christ.
Here's a good example of why some (not all) derivations from the natural moral law lead to "probably correct" but not 100% certain conclusions. It would not be correct to say that "belief that Jesus Christ is God is a conclusion that can be proven with certainty by reason alone". That conclusion can be seen as "the most reasonable one", given alternatives. But the belief requires faith. There is evidence given, but a leap of faith is still required. Otherwise, there would be no faith involved. The Christian religion would be merely a logical construct - like a mathematical formula. There would be no merit in believing in Christ. In the same way there is no merit in accepting the result of a math problem. Instead, the natural moral law gives absolute, objective principles - and from those, belief in Christ can be seen as reasonable.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
05:44 AM
5
05
44
AM
PST
StephenB
It is clear enough to provide reliable guidance in situations that could include hundreds of possible combinations and permutations. What else could one want?
Following up and adding to this - I'm just pointing to a difference in two things: 1. Principles of the Natural Moral Law 2. Moral concepts derived from those principles. In the first case, those principles are not merely "clear enough". They are absolute, universal and objective. Those principles are self-evident. They are not the product of reasoning. "Murder is evil" - that has clarity in itself. However, applying that princple requires reasoning, and in the end as you say it's "clear enough" to provide reliable guidance. Ok, but there's ambiguity here. In the end, it's not 100% certain in every case.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
05:36 AM
5
05
36
AM
PST
Since humans have a rational nature - we have the capability of reasoning, we have "thinking powers" - the natural moral law is merely the moral requirement that we act in accord with our nature. To work for "Right reason" is to strive to think correctly and to seek to find the truth through reasoning. Living in accord with one's nature and bringing potential powers to actuality are good actions. To "do good and shun evil" is the basis of the natural moral law. Using reason powers correctly and well reveals the derivations of the natural moral law that are necessary for a moral life.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
05:31 AM
5
05
31
AM
PST
MatSpirit
How can this possibly not have anything to do with punishing great grandchildren because their great grandfathers hated God? We’re talking about God’s deliberate actions here, not cause and effect. As you put it, “If God chooses to withdraw life for a good reason, then it His wisdom, not his power, that justifies that act.” Could you please explain God’s reasoning here? Please don’t offer ‘reasons like, “They might be just as nasty as great grandpaw.” God doesn’t say anything about the kid’s morals, just their ancestry.
First, the term 'punishments' is synonymous with 'corrections' in this case. God does not punish for His own pleasure, or revenge or other bad motives. Punishments are corrections given for the good of His people. Evil actions and teachings by parents are inherited by children. If children are taught to hate Jews, for example, that is an evil that persists from parents to children. God corrects, disciplines, punishes bad actions - to create good. You've seen a spoiled child, certainly. A spoiled child is one who has never been disciplined (punished). To correct a child, with deprivations and considerate, loving disciplines - is to build good character in the child. Parents who spoil the child by rewarding bad behavior, only make the child's life difficult and God punishes bad behavior to correct it and make it turn towards good. Bad actions and teachings from parents can persist through generations and the consequence of those teachings are punishments and difficulties in life that also persist - until behaviors are ultimately changed.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
05:28 AM
5
05
28
AM
PST
jdk
That is, does the natural moral law self-evidently conclude that belief in Jesus should be held, just as belief against murder should be held?
StephenB explained it well, but just to add ... The NML is generalized principles. "To respect and care for the lives of other humans is good. To murder people is bad". "To give help to those in need is morally good. To steal from people in need is morally evil". Things like that. From those principles, others are derived. But belief that Jesus is true God to be worshipped is not a self-evident principle of the NML. It is derived, rationally from the NML.
Or is belief in Jesus an addition to following the natural moral law.
It's a logical or intellectual development of the natural moral law.
Could I believe in the natural moral law, and follow it well, but not believe in Jesus? Would I still go to hell in this case?
Great question with good distinction: "follow it well". If you were totally ignorant of all other things, had no access to greater knowledge, sincerely tried your best -- yes the NML is the best you would have. Some primitive tribe-person perhaps. However, the NML requires continued good-use and growth of our rational nature (our thinking power) to the best we can. So, if you have access to sincerely learning about Christ but refuse to do so ... that would very big problem. You couldn't say that "you're following the NML well" in that case.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
04:12 AM
4
04
12
AM
PST
MatSpirit Punishment that is communicated through generations is conditioned on "them who hate me". If hatred of God persists over generations, then the punishments (which are corrections - God's attempts to restore love to replace the ancestral hatred) will persist. Punishments, afflictions, hardships are logical consequences of the hatred of good (of God). The desired result of those punishments is a return to goodness - at which moment, the punishments cease and blessings are poured forth.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
04:02 AM
4
04
02
AM
PST
STephenB @222 Good points throughout. I accept the distinctions you offered. I was stretching the point to see where it could go, but I believe a good answer is that the NML gives firm principles and that we can reason to the best understanding afterwards.
It is clear enough to provide reliable guidance in situations that could include hundreds of possible combinations and permutations. What else could one want?
The most desirable thing would be to know for certain what the morally good thing is. But we do have the challenge of unknown situations, as you rightly said.
However, we have been left to figure some things for ourselves, and the problem of self defense is one of them. I submit that a reliable answer to that problem is the reasoned calculus, based on natural law, that we should apply only the minimum amount of force necessary to stop an aggressor, allowing us to err on the side of too much force?
I think God will judge this kind of action based on our knowledge and our response to conscience. As believers, informed by grace, we are not left with reason-alone or with a natural-law alone. We should always try to live in conformity with the Gospel - doing as Christ would do. Deciding a complex moral action without prayer - without seeking the light of grace and guidance from God - that would be a problem, as I see it. In the end, as you rightly say - we have to figure it out. The magisterium does not define the morality of every possible moral action. But we can also use actions that are so-defined, along with the natural law.Silver Asiatic
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
03:54 AM
3
03
54
AM
PST
Mat Spirit: Mat Spirit
Amazing
Not really. Let me try to help you out here. The context of our discussion (if that is what it is) centers on relationship between the natural moral law and the Ten Commandments, not the anomalous warnings found in the first commandment alone. Or again, the issue is the relationship between the implicit moral instruction apprehended in natural moral law and the explicit instruction taught in the Ten Commndmenets.StephenB
October 29, 2018
October
10
Oct
29
29
2018
12:20 AM
12
12
20
AM
PST
StephanB: "God is saying that He punishes idolators and will continue to punish them if they continue to worship false Gods. However, this is distinct from the Ten Commandments, which are not warnings or threats." Amazing.MatSpirit
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
11:39 PM
11
11
39
PM
PST
jdk:
I fall in group three: the non-believer.
Yes. That makes sense.
Am I not following the natural moral law by not believing in Jesus etc.? That is, does the natural moral law self-evidently conclude that belief in Jesus should be held, just as belief against murder should be held?
No. The natural moral law does not provide a direct epistemological pathway to Jesus. However, once one accepts the natural law as an objective fact, it prompts the next logical question: If such a law exists, doesn’t that require a lawgiver? If so, who might that lawmaker be? The obvious candidate would be God (but not necessarily the God/Man Jesus).
Or is belief in Jesus an addition to following the natural moral law.
That would be a second order question, or as you say, “an addition.” The first order question, alluded to above, is this: Does the natural law indicate the existence of a law-giver (God). The second order question(s) would be: Granted God exists, did He reveal anything about himself to us? Who, if anyone, speaks for him? What form does He take? The natural moral law does not help with these second order questions. This analysis must be done empirically. One example: If God were to manifest himself on earth, we would expect three things: [a] He should be pre-announced, [b] He should prove that He is God through his actions, and [c] he should never say anything contrary to right reason. That is the least he could do. So we line up the most prominent claimants. Socrates, Buddha, Mohammed, Dharma, Christ etc. All of them, but one, showed up at the last moment and said, “I am here, trust me.” By contrast, the Old Testament prophets told us centuries in advance what Christ would be like what he would do, and where (and when) he would be born. All of them, but one, were great teachers, but none claimed to be God. By contrast, Christ claimed to be God, performed countless healing miracles, demonstrated his command of nature, and rose himself (and others) from the dead. All of them, but one, established an impressive moral system, but none provided a complete moral perspective that reflected every aspect of human nature and one that provided information about our final destiny. By contrast, Christ explained the purpose of our existence and how to achieve it. So, the empirical evidence suggests that if anyone who claims to speak for God should be believed, that person would be Jesus Christ.
Could I believe in the natural moral law, and follow it well, but not believe in Jesus? Would I still go to hell in this case?
Except for those in category four above, trying to be good (or at least trying not to be bad) is a necessary but not sufficient condition for being saved. The reason for that is that a finite man, who has sinned, cannot compensate for offending an infinite God. That is why the infinite God/Man, Jesus Christ, took on human flesh to offer an infinite atoning sacrifice to an infinite God in the name of finite men. So being saved involves the act of being associated with that God/Man, who is our savior.
Can you explain how these two things are related.
Yes. In the final analysis, the reason people lose their souls is because they refuse to love. (God and their neighbor). The natural moral law, which includes the acquisition of such virtues as humility, prudence, temperance, fairness, courage, compassion, wisdom, persistence, self-control, and other traits, helps us to be more loving people and therefore, more likely to cooperate with God in his attempt to save us. Also, if we work to acquire these virtues from the bottom up by forming the right habits, God provides extra help from the top down in the form of corresponding supernatural virtues.StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
09:25 PM
9
09
25
PM
PST
re 224: Thanks for the distinctions.
I would say that those in the first group are in the greatest danger of losing their souls, followed by the second group, followed by the third group, followed by the fourth group.
I fall in group three: the non-believer. Am I not following the natural moral law by not believing in Jesus etc.? That is, does the natural moral law self-evidently conclude that belief in Jesus should be held, just as belief against murder should be held? Or is belief in Jesus an addition to following the natural moral law. Could I believe in the natural moral law, and follow it well, but not believe in Jesus? Would I still go to hell in this case? Can you explain how these two tings are related.jdk
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
05:34 PM
5
05
34
PM
PST
Mat Spirit:
“I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate Me,” don’t you understand?
God is saying that He punishes idolators and will continue to punish them if they continue to worship false Gods. However, this is distinct from the Ten Commandments, which are not warnings or threats.StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
04:47 PM
4
04
47
PM
PST
StephenB: ” Bad logic. The Ten Commandments have nothing to do with the punishment of great grandchildren.” Mat Spirit
What!? The Ten Commandments outright SAY that God punishes Children for the sins of their great-great-great grandfathers. What part of, “I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate Me,” don’t you understand?
I think I will pass on that one. Have a nice day.StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:57 PM
3
03
57
PM
PST
jdk: jdk:
Stephen, do you believe those who are apostate (who don’t believe in Jesus Christ) are condemned to hell in some sense – some kind of eternal condition of suffering, or at least lack of peace?
This is a very probing question, so I must make a few observations: By "apostate," I refer to someone who once believed in the whole of Christian doctrine and then simply walked away from all of it. By "heretic," I mean someone who continues to accept some parts of doctrine, and reject others for convenience, while falsely maintaining the Christian label. By "non-believer" I refer to one who simply doesn't believe in the Christian religion. By "pagan," I refer to someone who has never even heard of Jesus Christ. I would say that those in the first group are in the greatest danger of losing their souls, followed by the second group, followed by the third group, followed by the fourth group. I do think that a great many people will suffer eternal loss in hell, yes, but if it happens, it will be a product of their voluntary fault. Since the human soul is non-material, it will live forever in some condition or state because there are no material parts vulnerable to decay or destruction. Immortal souls must eventually go somewhere for eternity, so if they refuse heaven, God says to them, "OK, thy will be done."StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:49 PM
3
03
49
PM
PST
StephenB: " Bad logic. The Ten Commandments have nothing to do with the punishment of great grandchildren." What!?  The Ten Commandments outright SAY that God punishes Children for the sins of their great-great-great grandfathers.  What part of, "I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate Me," don't you understand? How can this possibly not have anything to do with punishing great grandchildren because their great grandfathers hated God?  We're talking about God's deliberate actions here, not cause and effect.  As you put it, "If God chooses to withdraw life for a good reason, then it His wisdom, not his power, that justifies that act."  Could you please explain God's reasoning here?  Please don't offer 'reasons like, "They might be just as nasty as great grandpaw."  God doesn't say anything about the kid's morals, just their ancestry. SB: "God does not or would not torture puppies. Indeed, I didn’t say anything at all about puppies. You just made that up. You seem to be arguing against yourself and doing it rather poorly." If God says He can punish humans for the sins of their long departed  ancestors, no mere puppy is safe. SB: "Christian morality also contains supernatural truths that must be revealed and accepted on faith. They cannot be arrived at by reason alone. " That might account for Lev 20:13 "If a man lies with a male as he lies with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination. They shall surely be put to death. Their blood shall be upon them." and Exodus 22:18 "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live." Do you even believe in witches?  Are they one of those things we just have to accept on faith?MatSpirit
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
02:12 PM
2
02
12
PM
PST
Silver Asiatic
I disagree here. I do not think that moral rule “we must only use the minimum force necessary” is part of the natural, objective, moral law. It is an idea that has been derived, by reasoning, from the natural law.
I agree that the concept is derived from NML and is not part of it, I should have made that distinction explicit and I am glad that you made it. However, that derivation serves as a reliable guiding moral principle. The word “necessary” provides sure, if not infallible, guidance. . .
But reasoning alone about morality cannot arrive at an absolute truth.
I don’t think you can make that universal claim. In most cases, it would be true. But in some cases, it is not. A logical deduction based on a true premise is just as certain as a self-evident truth.
In this case, “use only minimum force” – it points to the idea that “use of force” must only and always be the minimum. But why? Perhaps we say “use only minimum force necessary”. This is the same as “do only what is necessary”.
I disagree. To use only the necessary force is not the same as doing only what is necessary in the broader sense. It is not, for example, necessary for self defense to bind the aggressors wounds after you stop him or to press charges against him for attacking you. However, you can make a good argument for doing these things.
I think we end up with a very big problem here. “Necessary for what”?
Necessary for personal self defense.
First, can we ever know what is “truly necessary” to stop an evil action? I don’t think so.
Even without perfect knowledge, the principle serves to provide a moral check on our own potentially aggressive or vengeful behavior, similar to the principle that the punishment should fit the crime. If you don’t know for certain how much force is necessary, you can guess and err on the side of too much aggression. Again, this is reasonable. We are not after logical certainty. We are after what is morally reasonable – as opposed to the chaos of a mindless reaction. Without this principle we may well be tempted to kill those who slaps us in the face. That is the real point of Jesus' directive to "turn the other cheek."
But more importantly, why would the moral law say that we can only use “minimum force necessary to stop the evil action at that moment in time”?
I am discussing the moral law and its reasonable implications. If we cannot have both, then the former is not of much use. Indeed, it could even be misleading. If my life is being threatened, I am far better off knowing that I may, *if necessary,* kill my aggressor rather than simply understanding the principle “Thou shalt not murder.”
Why not “use necessary force to stop the evil for the forseeable future”? Wouldn’t that be more rational? The atom bombs in Japan were designed to stop the war for the forseeable future. Was this morally correct? It’s debatable.
I think you are getting pretty far afield here. With all those added variables, I would agree. However, in the limited context of personal self defense, we need solid principles that provide moral guidance and “thou shalt not kill” does not serve the purpose.
All we end up with is “the most reasonable moral norm” – it’s something worked out by human reason. Yes, it can be based on the natural objective law, but the derivation is never fully clear.
It is clear enough to provide reliable guidance in situations that could include hundreds of possible combinations and permutations. What else could one want?
That is why revelation is required. An official judgement from the Lawgiver is needed to firmly know the truth on debatable issues.fF
Revealed truth tells us many things that the natural moral law cannot approach, especially on matters of salvation, which is the only thing that really matters. However, we have been left to figure some things for ourselves, and the problem of self defense is one of them. I submit that a reliable answer to that problem is the reasoned calculus, based on natural law, that we should apply only the minimum amount of force necessary to stop an aggressor, allowing us to err on the side of too much force?StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
12:02 PM
12
12
02
PM
PST
StephenB With regard to the last statement, however, I would submit that the reasoning “method” is subjective, (what else could a cognitive exercise be) but it can provide knowledge of an unchanging objective truth that doesn’t require supernatural revelation for its confirmation. My view was incorrect on this - yes, thank you. I was using the term "objective" as the opposite of subjective. So, subjective being internal to the person, and objective being an external reference. But that it not the right understanding of what 'objective moral law' means. It is as you describe - so I appreciate the correction here. There is a difference between a moral idea that is arrived-at via reasoning versus something that is self-evident. But it may also be true that the natural moral law, while self-evident, always requires reasoning in order to apply it. In that case, it always has a 'subjective' aspect but it can arrive at objective moral truths. Ok, I definitely confused those matters - thank you.
(God exists, for example) I don’t think this has anything to do with Sola Scriptura. Indeed, it would seem to be the opposite. I am talking about the metaphysical object of the reasoning process while you seem to be talking about the epistemological task of apprehending it.
Sola scriptura requires a subjective reasoning process (epistemological method) to attempt to arrive at objective truths. But I don't think that a text that must be believed, on faith, to be revealed from God can be the correct source for reasoning about the implications of the natural law.
Thank you for that description. For me, any moral code that differs from “the objective, true moral code” (Catholicism in the broad sense, natural moral law in the narrow sense) is, by definition, subjective because someone made it up. I don’t think a subjective code suddenly becomes objective when it is passed on to someone else. If it is objective, it is discovered, real and true; if it is subjective, it is invented, unreal, and false. It either is what it is or it is not.
I think it's simple enough to say that there is one, objective moral code - as you state. It's also a very good point to wonder how a subjective code could become objective -- but as I was corrected on this, I was using the term 'objective' in the wrong sense for what is intended by it. So yes, you did indeed contribute excellent understanding of these issues and I appreciate it!Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
10:56 AM
10
10
56
AM
PST
Silver Asiatic
Here are some of the concepts and how I’m defining them. 1. Natural objective moral law (universal moral law, natural moral law). For me, these are self-evident, foundational, general moral concepts known to everyone. They are not the product of reason or argumentation. They are like the rules of logic – they are given to humanity. Like the Law of Non-Contradiction. Not the product of reasoning, but the basis for all reasoning. 2. Derivations of the natural law. These are moral principles that are worked-out from the first principles of the moral law (derived from the NML). These are changeable and more or less certain. No amount of reasoning can fully determine the truth of these. They’re always proximate. “Is the use of force morally justified in this situation”? These are debatable – they are not principles of the NML. In fact, they are actually determined subjectively (use of reason is a subjective method).
Good. These are useful definitions and we can do business on that basis. With regard to the last statement, however, I would submit that the reasoning “method” is subjective, (what else could a cognitive exercise be) but it can provide knowledge of an unchanging objective truth that doesn’t require supernatural revelation for its confirmation. (God exists, for example) I don’t think this has anything to do with Sola Scriptura. Indeed, it would seem to be the opposite. I am talking about the metaphysical object of the reasoning process while you seem to be talking about the epistemological task of apprehending it.
3. Subjectivism. For me, this is morality determined by the individual. The individual makes up his own moral code based on whatever sources or combinations of sources. This can be done entirely from reasoning and rationality. This is the basic understanding of secular morals where people choose whatever they think is right or wrong. The individual makes up the moral system and it does not reference any “object” – no objective source. I believe it actually could be a logical system and still entirely subjective. It’s personal and individual. Sola scriptura moral codes are actually subjective in this understanding.
Yes. Good.
4. Conformity or adherence to external moral norm. This is different from subjectivism in my view. You explained it as being subjective because someone else made up the moral code (like Hitler for example) so even though the adherent subscribes to it and didn’t make it up himself, it’s still subjective. But I view this approach as much different from “individual subjectivism” where the person just makes up their own morals. A person who believes that Islam or Judiasm is true, and adheres to the Koran or the Talmud – is embracing “an objective” (not “The Objective”) moral law. It’s not a personal code – it’s something external. It’s written down and can be evaluated (unlike personal subjectivism). It is consistent and follows some first principles (like “the Koran is truly revealed by God”).
Thank you for that description. For me, any moral code that differs from “the objective, true moral code” (Catholicism in the broad sense, natural moral law in the narrow sense) is, by definition, subjective because someone made it up. I don’t think a subjective code suddenly becomes objective when it is passed on to someone else. If it is objective, it is discovered, real and true; if it is subjective, it is invented, unreal, and false. It either is what it is or it is not. On the other hand, I can understand why you would say that a false doctrine can be objective insofar as it is the metaphysical “object” that the thinking subject is embracing. Perhaps we need to say that a doctrine can be subjective or objective in two ways. Again, it seems that I am doing metaphysics and you are doing epistemology. No problem, just an observation. In the end, I suppose it doesn’t matter what the label is as long as we know what is going on and how it relates to the truth.
5. Divinely revealed moral system – the true moral code. For me, this is Catholicism. Everything else is false to one degree or another. This system is based on the belief that there is an authoritative, true moral code – transcending human debate and argument. This system is accessible to reason and conforms to reason, but it is not the product of rational arguments.
Yes. Thanks again. It really helps to understand what you mean when you use these words. I hope I have provided the same service on my end.
StephenB
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
09:21 AM
9
09
21
AM
PST
jdk
But he can kill them? Correct?
God cannot kill an immortal being. So no, not correct.Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
04:35 AM
4
04
35
AM
PST
StephenB Here are some of the concepts and how I'm defining them. 1. Natural objective moral law (universal moral law, natural moral law). For me, these are self-evident, foundational, general moral concepts known to everyone. They are not the product of reason or argumentation. They are like the rules of logic - they are given to humanity. Like the Law of Non-Contradiction. Not the product of reasoning, but the basis for all reasoning. 2. Derivations of the natural law. These are moral principles that are worked-out from the first principles of the moral law (derived from the NML). These are changeable and more or less certain. No amount of reasoning can fully determine the truth of these. They're always proximate. "Is the use of force morally justified in this situation"? These are debatable - they are not principles of the NML. In fact, they are actually determined subjectively (use of reason is a subjective method). 3. Subjectivism. For me, this is morality determined by the individual. The individual makes up his own moral code based on whatever sources or combinations of sources. This can be done entirely from reasoning and rationality. This is the basic understanding of secular morals where people choose whatever they think is right or wrong. The individual makes up the moral system and it does not reference any "object" - no objective source. I believe it actually could be a logical system and still entirely subjective. It's personal and individual. Sola scriptura moral codes are actually subjective in this understanding. 4. Conformity or adherence to external moral norm. This is different from subjectivism in my view. You explained it as being subjective because someone else made up the moral code (like Hitler for example) so even though the adherent subscribes to it and didn't make it up himself, it's still subjective. But I view this approach as much different from "individual subjectivism" where the person just makes up their own morals. A person who believes that Islam or Judiasm is true, and adheres to the Koran or the Talmud - is embracing "an objective" (not "The Objective") moral law. It's not a personal code - it's something external. It's written down and can be evaluated (unlike personal subjectivism). It is consistent and follows some first principles (like "the Koran is truly revealed by God"). 5. Divinely revealed moral system - the true moral code. For me, this is Catholicism. Everything else is false to one degree or another. This system is based on the belief that there is an authoritative, true moral code - transcending human debate and argument. This system is accessible to reason and conforms to reason, but it is not the product of rational arguments.Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
04:15 AM
4
04
15
AM
PST
StephenB
Does that same natural moral law also tell us that we must not use lethal means unless no other means will suffice, or to make it even more clear, we must use only the minimum force necessary. Yes, it does, but not right away. In this case, the application of the NML requires the use of reason in addition to acknowledging what is self evident.
I disagree here. I do not think that moral rule "we must only use the minimum force necessary" is part of the natural, objective, moral law. It is an idea that has been derived, by reasoning, from the natural law. But reasoning alone about morality cannot arrive at an absolute truth. In this case, "use only minimum force" - it points to the idea that "use of force" must only and always be the minimum. But why? Perhaps we say "use only minimum force necessary". This is the same as "do only what is necessary". Is that a general, universal moral norm? "In all actions, do only what is necessary"? I think we end up with a very big problem here. "Necessary for what"? Well, we could say "use only minimum amount of force necessary for keeping peace in the community". Or "use only necessary amount of force to stop the evil action". Again, there are big problems here for "reason alone" to solve. First, can we ever know what is "truly necessary" to stop an evil action? I don't think so. But more importantly, why would the moral law say that we can only use "minimum force necessary to stop the evil action at that moment in time"? Why not "use necessary force to stop the evil for the forseeable future"? Wouldn't that be more rational? The atom bombs in Japan were designed to stop the war for the forseeable future. Was this morally correct? It's debatable. The point here - all of this is debatable. When trying to derive moral norms from the universal, it's uncertain. You and me could debate these sincerely. And in the end, we would not end up with a "universal, natural-law moral norm". All we end up with is "the most reasonable moral norm" - it's something worked out by human reason. Yes, it can be based on the natural objective law, but the derivation is never fully clear. That is why revelation is required. An official judgement from the Lawgiver is needed to firmly know the truth on debatable issues.Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:56 AM
3
03
56
AM
PST
OldAndrew
I’m not sure if you’re stating that Catholicism is the standard for adhering to the Bible and that deviating from it means picking and choosing parts to accept. Obviously I would strongly disagree.
How would you approach the Bible so that you are not picking and choosing parts to accept? ... and yes, I am stating that Catholicism is the standard, but we don't have to debate that.Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:44 AM
3
03
44
AM
PST
StephenB
Extending the point, there are many who try to say that Jesus’ teaching that we should “turn the other cheek” calls for pacifism. But as I am sure you know, that isn’t really true because what He is teaching us is that we must control our pugnacious nature. Clearly, the NML would never contradict scripture or vice versa, but this is one case where our immediate understanding of right and wrong will not suffice. We need to think about it before we have an accurate idea about what the moral law is telling us. The broader point is that the NML is inseparable from reason. Indeed, we must use our reason not only to make this very difficult calculation (thus far and no farther with the use of force), but also to even know that a calculation must be made. And what can we say about the extension of the wisdom about self defense to the highly complex conditions for a “just war,” which is informed by the NML but is miles away from being self evident.
Yes, but I do not think that we can reason-out what the true moral law really is. That is why we have the magisterium of the Church. Jesus' teachings are in terpreted in truth by divine authority. If it was a matter of rational arguments, there would be no true, authoritative solution to the problem. In fact, using reason alone is an exercise in subjectivism (problems with Sola Scriptura here).Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:41 AM
3
03
41
AM
PST
StephenB
I think the natural moral law could inform the civil law about such policies but not necessarily define them. I don’t think you can use the NML to say that it is always wrong to execute homosexuals, or that it is always right to do it, because circumstances matter. So we may have a meeting of the minds here.
Yes, we do! Thanks for a good explanation.Silver Asiatic
October 28, 2018
October
10
Oct
28
28
2018
03:38 AM
3
03
38
AM
PST
Silver Asiatic
With this, you should agree with me that the forbidding of the death-penalty against gays is not a question of the NML. In some instances (as in Old Testament times) that action was permitted as an act of justice, and preservation of the human community (dignity of humanity). So, it cannot be a NML to say that “it is wrong to execute homosexuals”. We believe that today because we apply the NML differently due to different social conditions.
I think the natural moral law could inform the civil law about such policies but not necessarily define them. I don't think you can use the NML to say that it is always wrong to execute homosexuals, or that it is always right to do it, because circumstances matter. So we may have a meeting of the minds here.StephenB
October 27, 2018
October
10
Oct
27
27
2018
11:06 PM
11
11
06
PM
PST
1 2 3 4 … 10