Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Claim: ET, if discovered, would change our morality

Denyse O'Leary
July 14, 2019
Culture, Extraterrestrial life, Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
arroba Email

It would be evidence that humans are irrelevant to the purpose of the universe:

However, ubiquitous life would also create new and unexpected problems for theism, by undermining some traditional arguments for divine benevolence and thus making it harder to believe that God cares about us. Theists argue that the best explanation for the existence of this Universe is that it was created by a benevolent God. One prima facie counter-example is offered by widespread, apparently gratuitous evil. This suggests instead a creator who is indifferent to the fate of individual human beings. Theists reply that, unless we suppose that God cares about rationality, knowledge or intelligibility, we cannot explain why this Universe is governed by regular intelligible mathematical laws. The Universe appears to be designed to be understood by its own inhabitants. So far as we know, we are the only inhabitants who could possibly understand it. So we must be essential to God’s plan.

The discovery that life is ubiquitous weakens this argument. If the Universe is teeming with life, then there are many other candidates for the cosmically decisive role previously occupiable only by human beings. Perhaps God cares that there be some rational beings, but is indifferent to their species, identity or numbers. Or perhaps God cares only for creatures who reach some threshold of wisdom or intellect that humans could never attain. God cares for beings who are sufficiently rational, intelligent, free or lovable. But it is human arrogance to assume that we are among them!

Sam Dresser, “The ethics of ET” at Aeon

And so on. Despite the fact that we have never found evidence of a single microbe, not a single microbe, anywhere but Earth. Not even a virus.

Funny how all road leads in the same direction, isn’t it? If we don’t find extraterrestrial life, humans are just a cosmic blip. And if we do find extraterrestrial life, humans are just a cosmic blip.

Jathink some people are convinced that humans are just a cosmic blip for reasons that have nothing to do with the state of cosmology, extraterrestrial life, or space aliens?

File under: Aw fer cryin’ out loud… is this what it’s come to?

See also: Tales of an invented god
and

What becomes of science when the evidence does not matter?

Follow UD News at Twitter!

Comments
Well the A/Mats do wish to build a faith based belief system as well. Lots of 'ifs' and then the false and fanciful prancing down their own path of 'if' ... if only they could find ET.... but yeah I already agree ET is already discovered ...and ancient texts prove this out God IS. ID points to this 'et'.... (but don't worry you no-believers... ET does not mean some Grey haired and bearded man seated on high.... it could just be a being far beyond our reckoning, capabilities... and approachable by grace).... Funny A/Mats... I still pray for them, as we should... they need it most. Trumper
I hate that argument soooooo much. We have an ET right there ^^^^ and it hasn’t changed my morality or belief in God. :-0 Seriously, the whole aliens with destroy your belief in God nonsense is some one controlling the narrative not so much talking to the truth. And generally the claim is always made by the opposite perspective to those that are religious It is harder to explain an empty and void universe then one filled with the creators creations AaronS1978
If the ancient texts, including the Bible, are to be believed, then E.T. has been discovered, long ago. ET
"Theists argue that the best explanation for the existence of this Universe is that it was created by a benevolent God. One prima facie counter-example is offered by widespread, apparently gratuitous evil. This suggests instead a creator who is indifferent to the fate of individual human beings." Yeah, well, maybe. Shamanism believes that God is generally neutral and that the immortal souls of all human beings go to Heaven, where they can experience God directly. There is no Hell. Why would a benevolent God create a thing like Hell? God didn't; Hell was invented by the rise of Professional Priests who needed to SCARE people into PAYING for professional clerics. The discovery of intelligent beings on other planets doesn't change ANY of that. It just increases the pool of souls arriving in Heaven. However, the discovery of intelligent beings on other planets might cause severe theological problems for "organized" religions because it will highlight the shortcomings in their theologies. vmahuna

Leave a Reply