Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Globalization threatens the “ecosystem” of science, says researcher


One of three such trends, according to a Cambridge nanoscientist, and author of The Secret Life of Science: How It Really Works and Why It Matters:

The scientific ecosystem also serves us in ways that are harder to articulate. It instills in us an appreciation for the beauty of mathematics, a belief in the inherent values of education, trust in the intrinsic worth of transnational intellectual communities, and interest in scholarly discussion.

Yet funders and governments have undervalued these essential ecosystem services. And the three trends mentioned above – globalization, digitization of knowledge, and the expanding ranks of scientists – are exacerbating the problem.

As globalization increases competition, it also reinforces certain narratives – such as those dictating which research areas deserve the most funding. In my meetings with government officials around the world, I have seen this firsthand. They trumpet the importance of science to their countries’ futures, and then identify the areas that they “uniquely” are spearheading. The areas are usually the same.

Just as “trending” topics in the media can come to dominate public attention, trending research areas attract the vast majority of funding. Support for parallel research in the same areas reduces the efficiency of each investment, and such herding behavior by donors may even preclude some of the most significant advances, which often come as a result of combining the results of seemingly unrelated research .Jeremy J. Baumberg, “What Is Threatening Science?September 21, 2018” at Project Syndicate

Well, the geniuses who draw trends together in a spectacular way do tend to be isolated individuals, often out of step with their fellows. Not very global, when you think of it.

See also: At the Guardian: The “widespread notion that academia is morally superior is ridiculous” “As outdated as bloodletting”

The people who can pull together and synthesize ideas aren't necessarily isolated or hermetic. For sure they're *separated from academia*, and separated from conformist places like NYC. Even Einstein, the role model for academia, was a patent examiner when he developed his big ideas. He was later brought into academia, but never became a proper academic. polistra

Leave a Reply