Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Intelligent voltage

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

There is an intuitive analogy between the basic operation of an electric circuit and how intelligent design works. In an electric circuit, a current flows in a load only if a generator provides voltage. In a system, organization can increase only if a generator of information provides intelligence. Consider the figure:

ecid

On the left we have an electric circuit, on the right intelligent design applied on a system. In the electric circuit an active component is necessary (generator) to power the passive component (load). Similarly, in the ID schema, an active agent (designer) is necessary to organize a passive object and make it a designed system. More generally, this ID model applies as well as to a problem to solve, a topic to examine in depth, a message to elaborate… whatever intelligence can create and illuminate.

The electric generator, when is disconnected from the circuit, shows a voltage (difference of potential). The ID generator (also called “designer”) shows potential intelligence when is at rest. Only when they are in operation, i.e. applied to a load or work, they cause a visible effect (electric current produced by the former, information injection produced by the latter). The electric current is a flow of electrons, information is a flow of bits.

For the electric circuit the Ohm’s law holds: current = voltage / resistance. Something similar holds for the ID circuit: information = intelligence / problem. Given a certain problem or system, more intelligent the generator, more the information it is able to provide to solve / design the problem / system.

Moral: who denies the ID inference for the natural systems showing organization is like who denies the necessity of a generator in a electric circuit. To affirm that “ID is not science” is like to affirm that electrical circuitry and its laws is not science. Moreover, who claims naturalistic origin of organization is like one absurdly claiming that in an electric circuit without generator a current could flow (see the figure below).

ecwg

It is obvious that a load connected this way is not powered. In fact the “ground” symbol means voltage equal zero. A load, whose two terminals are both connected to zero volt, has null potential difference applied, then zero current. Similarly, an organized system cannot arise when it is connected only to “chance and necessity”, represented by the “ground” symbol, which in this case means no intelligence. No intelligence, then organizational information=0. If there is no information there is no organization. As Norbert Wiener said, “The amount of information in a system is a measure of its organization”.

Comments
Voltage is required to complete an electric circuit. Therefore, an intelligent designer is required to produce information! It doesn't work for me. ///To affirm that “ID is not science” is like to affirm that electrical circuitry and its laws is not science. /// Electricity can be observed, studied and tested. Your intelligent designer has never been observed, studied or tested. It is just a figment of imagination.Evolve
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
08:38 AM
8
08
38
AM
PDT
Seems atheists, despite all their false bravado in 'science', are conspicuously missing from the honor roll of the men who harnessed electricity Michael Faraday Excerpt: Faraday remained absolutely committed to Biblical truth from early childhood throughout his long life. He would have been considered a “fundamentalist” Christian, had the term existed in his day. Nothing, not even the rising tide of skepticism in Britain leading up to the Darwinian revolution, shook his confidence in the word of God. ,,, Start listing the things that run on electric motors – automobiles, fans, clocks, airplanes, pumps, vacuum cleaners, and so much more – and you begin to get a hint of what Faraday’s work brought forth. Add to the list generators, transformers, electrolysis devices, electromagnets, and many other products of his lab, and Faraday’s importance to the history of science and technology starts to come into focus. It has been said that the wealth generated by the inventions based on Faraday’s discoveries exceed the value of the British stock exchange. http://crev.info/?scientists=michael-faraday James Clerk Maxwell Excerpt: no matter what other way you examine his life – intellect, personality, creativity, wit, work ethic, Christian character, integrity, breadth and depth of knowledge and accomplishments – Maxwell comes out on top. He pursued science with exuberance, and with grace and charm and unselfishness, giving glory to God. In his too-brief life of 48 years, Maxwell changed the world. Do you use a cell phone? A pager? A remote control for your TV? A radio? Television? You owe these inventions in large part to Maxwell. Radar, satellite, spacecraft and aircraft communications – any and every means of transferring information through thin air or the vacuum of space, comes out of his work. The inventors of all these devices all built on Maxwell’s exceptional discoveries in electromagnetism, discoveries that required the best in experimental method with the best in mathematics and theory. Maxwell discovered many things, as we shall see, but his crowning achievement was the summation of all electromagnetic phenomena in four differential equations, appropriately named Maxwell’s Equations in his honor. http://crev.info/?scientists=james-clerk-maxwell In his forties, Maxwell devoted himself to building the Cavendish Laboratory at Cambridge, named for the pioneering physicist who in 1798 first measured the gravitational constant G. This laboratory was destined to become the hub of many major discoveries in atomic and nuclear physics in the coming century. - Over the main entrance of the Cavendish Laboratory, the home of the Department of Physics in the University of Cambridge, is an inscription: ‘The works of the Lord are great; sought out of all them that have pleasure therein’.,,, The passage was placed there at the suggestion of Andrew Briggs, who was a PhD student at the time. Briggs is now Professor of Nanomaterials at Oxford University. He appreciated the Latin inscription of Psalm 111 verse 2 carved on the doors of the first Cavendish Laboratory, almost certainly at the instigation of the first Cavendish Professor, James Clark Maxwell. http://scienceandbelief.files.wordpress.com/2010/12/cavendish-new-inscription1.jpg http://scienceandbelief.org/tag/psalm-111/bornagain77
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
08:12 AM
8
08
12
AM
PDT
Nikola Tesla - reading amidst lightning bolts http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_u3D7kCdnYZs/TO5VodIE4fI/AAAAAAAAAEo/V59s0Yk14gY/s1600/tesla_colorado_springs_station.jpg NIKOLA TESLA - The Genius Who Lit the World - video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eoY_7mbm5ng Nikola Tesla was born on 10 July (O.S. 28 June) 1856 to Serbian parents in the village of Smiljan, Austrian Empire (modern-day Croatia). His father, Milutin Tesla, was a Serbian Orthodox priest.[15] Tesla’s mother, Duka Tesla (née Mandic), whose father was also a Serbian Orthodox priest,[16] had a talent for making home craft tools, mechanical appliances, and the ability to memorize Serbian epic poems. Duka had never received a formal education. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikola_Tesla#Early_years_.281856.E2.80.931885.29bornagain77
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
07:33 AM
7
07
33
AM
PDT
http://imgc-cn.artprintimages.com/images/P-473-488-90/60/6063/F3CD100Z/posters/gahan-wilson-gee-i-always-figured-him-for-no-1-new-yorker-cartoon.jpgReciprocating Bill
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
07:18 AM
7
07
18
AM
PDT
Reciprocating Bill you state
* Lightning strikes. *
Now I suppose you threw this out there because you believe lightning strikes to be 'natural'. But lightning strikes are not natural in the sense that they can not be explained without appeal to God. For instance,,
We Don't Actually Know What Triggers Lightning Strikes - Aug. 2013 Excerpt: Lightning is a natural electrical discharge—but scientists are still scratching their heads trying to figure out what triggers it. http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/new_scientist/2013/08/lightning_strikes_what_causes_lightning_is_a_mystery_could_it_be_cosmic.html Job 38:35 "Do you send the lightning bolts on their way? Do they report to you, ‘Here we are’?"
Perhaps RB you may claim this is just a 'God of the gaps' argument, but, as Lennox points out "God is not a God of the gaps, He is God of the whole show!". And it turns out that naturalists cannot explain the existence of a single photon in a lightning bolt without recourse to a 'non-local' beyond space and time cause. Quantum Mechanics has now been extended to falsify local realism (reductive materialism) without even using quantum entanglement to do it:
‘Quantum Magic’ Without Any ‘Spooky Action at a Distance’ – June 2011 Excerpt: A team of researchers led by Anton Zeilinger at the University of Vienna and the Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences used a system which does not allow for entanglement (of photons), and still found results which cannot be interpreted classically. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/06/110624111942.htm Acts 17:28 For in Him we live, and move, and have our being; as also certain of your own poets have said, ‘For we are also His offspring.’
Of related interest; Rainbows are formed by what are called ‘Quantum Catastrophes’. Thus, since I find Quantum Mechanical phenomena to be thoroughly Theistic, as to the necessity of providing a coherent non-local (beyond space and time) causation, that does not dissolve into absurdity as postulated ‘non-reductive’ materialistic causes do, then yes I actually do think God does form rainbows;
Quantum Catastrophes Excerpt: Catastrophes [1] are at the heart of many fascinating optical phenomena. The most prominent example of such a catastrophe is the rainbow. http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/~ulf/catastrophe.html 27 Amazing Miracles in Real Life Excerpt: Our son died of a brain tumor at 17. On the second anniversary of his death, as I was driving to work, a double rainbow appeared in the clear sky. One end was on the road in front of us and the other at the cemetery where he was buried. —Peggy H., Boone, North Carolina
Verse and music
Colossians 1:17 And he is before all things, and by him all things consist. The Thunder Rolls: Garth Brooks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rIV0oovj7vc
bornagain77
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
06:56 AM
6
06
56
AM
PDT
Niw, lightning depends on energy-driven separation of charges, then of course spark discharge in a context of ionisation. (cf Wiki here.) KFkairosfocus
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
05:30 AM
5
05
30
AM
PDT
Thanks Reciprocating Bill and bornagain77, "* Lightning strikes. *" Of course also lightning is no exception to the model. By the way, in the cartoons iconography, the arise of an intelligent idea is indeed symbolized by an electric light bulb turned on on the head. :)niwrad
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
05:20 AM
5
05
20
AM
PDT
Thanks kairosfocus and gpuccio, "Where’s de Designer?" The electric analogy stands on also about the ultimate source. Any battery of a circuit gets its energy/voltage from a power plant, in turn the power plant gets it from the earth's energy, in turn earth's energy comes from the sun, sun's energy comes from an initial cosmos' energy. Similarly, any information source comes from a parent source, until arriving to an ultimate Intelligent Source (called "Designer"). The electric / ID analogy is only an example of the universal paradigm of the "source / cause" that applies to everything.niwrad
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
04:45 AM
4
04
45
AM
PDT
Moreover, the ATP molecular machine (which is found at the bottom of the metabolic pathway diagram) is found to be 100% efficient (far exceeding man's capabilities):
Thermodynamic efficiency and mechanochemical coupling of F1-ATPase – 2011 Excerpt: F1-ATPase is a nanosized biological energy transducer working as part of FoF1-ATP synthase. Its rotary machinery transduces energy between chemical free energy and mechanical work and plays a central role in the cellular energy transduction by synthesizing most ATP in virtually all organisms.,, Our results suggested a 100% free-energy transduction efficiency and a tight mechanochemical coupling of F1-ATPase. http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/10/12/1106787108.short?rss=1 See also: Davies et al., “Macromolecular organization of ATP synthase and complex I in whole mitochondria,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences and: Tamás Beke-Somfai, Per Lincoln, and Bengt Nordén, “Double-lock ratchet mechanism revealing the role of [alpha]SER-344 in F0F1 ATP synthase,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Your Motor/Generators Are 100% Efficient – October 2011 Excerpt: ATP synthase astounds again. The molecular machine that generates almost all the ATP (molecular “energy pellets”) for all life was examined by Japanese scientists for its thermodynamic efficiency. By applying and measuring load on the top part that synthesizes ATP, they were able to determine that one cannot do better at getting work out of a motor,,, The article was edited by noted Harvard expert on the bacterial flagellum, Howard Berg. http://crev.info/content/111014-your_motor_generators Miniature Molecular Power Plant: ATP Synthase - January 2013 - video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XI8m6o0gXDY ATP: The Perfect Energy Currency for the Cell - Jerry Bergman, Ph.D. Excerpt: In manufacturing terms, the ATP (Synthase) molecule is a machine with a level of organization on the order of a research microscope or a standard television (Darnell, Lodish, and Baltimore, 1996). http://www.trueorigin.org/atp.asp The 10 Step Glycolysis Pathway In ATP Production: An Overview - video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Kn6BVGqKd8
At the 14:00 minute mark of the following video, Chris Ashcraft, PhD – molecular biology, gives us an overview of the Citric Acid Cycle, which is, after the 10 step Glycolysis Pathway, also involved in ATP production:
Evolution vs ATP Synthase – Chris Ashcraft - video - citric acid cycle at 14:00 minute mark https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=rUV4CSs0HzI#t=746 The Citric Acid Cycle: An Overview - video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6vQKrRjQcQ The Citric Acid Cycle: The Reactions - video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cXVleFtzeE
bornagain77
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
04:42 AM
4
04
42
AM
PDT
Nice analogy niwrad.
Electronic circuit http://www.freeinfosociety.com/media.php?id=1885 Map Of Major Metabolic Pathways In A Cell - Diagram http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/img/assets/4202/MetabolicPathways_6_17_04_.pdf manmade generator http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/teachers/images/turbine-generator.gif ATP synthase https://mcb.berkeley.edu/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=149&g2_serialNumber=2
bornagain77
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
04:41 AM
4
04
41
AM
PDT
* Lightning strikes. *Reciprocating Bill
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
04:23 AM
4
04
23
AM
PDT
niwrad: Very good! I like it. :)gpuccio
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
03:45 AM
3
03
45
AM
PDT
Simple, powerful analogy. Where's de EMF? Where's de Designer? KFkairosfocus
July 6, 2014
July
07
Jul
6
06
2014
03:42 AM
3
03
42
AM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply