Memo to Sal Cordova: Massimo Pigliucci may be in transit
|March 24, 2012||Posted by O'Leary under Intelligent Design|
Yesterday, Cordova noted biologist Massimo Pigliucci, still in good standing (we think), saying stuff like
Theodozius Dobzhansky, one of the fathers of modern evolutionary theory, who famously said that nothing makes sense in biology except in the light of evolution (the phrase is, in fact, approvingly quoted by Pross). Problem is, Dobzhansky was writing for an audience of science high school teachers, and his statement is patently wrong, as an even cursory examination of the history of biology makes clear. For instance, developmental biologists had done a lot of highly fruitful research throughout the 19th and 20th centuries even as they ignored Darwin. And molecular biologists made spectacular progress from the 1950’s though the onset of the 21st century, again pretty much completing ignoring evolution.
Running a search through the files here, we find that Pigliucci was also the guy who checked out of “consciousness is an illusion,” to this extent:
For some time I have been noticing the emergence of a strange trinity of beliefs among my fellow skeptics and freethinkers: an increasing number of them, it seems, don’t believe that they can make decisions (the free will debate), don’t believe that they have moral responsibility (because they don’t have free will, or because morality is relative — take your pick), and they don’t even believe that they exist as conscious beings because, you know, consciousness is an illusion.
So Pigliucci is clearly not that guy who explained to firefighters that the bed was already on fire when he lay down on it … Keep file open.