Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

New Book on Arguing for Evolution

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Did you know that helping is evidence for evolution? As Randy Moore and Sehoya Cotner explain in their new book Arguing for Evolution: An Encyclopedia for Understanding Science, this and most everything else in biology proves evolution to be an undeniable fact. Altruism, they explain, may seem to be a “problem” for evolution. (They put “problem” in quotes because, of course, there are no realproblems for evolution. All those false predictions are simply explained by adjusting the theory.) In this case, most acts of so-called altruism are “anything but.” If an individual sounds an alarm to warn the others or dies to save the group, it is really just another evolutionary calculation. Does not such risky behavior maximize the chances that the all important genes will be propagated to the next generation? And so falling on hand grenades may seem to be a noble, heroic act, but actually it is simply a product of natural selection. As John Haldane once put it, “I would lay down my life for two brothers or eight cousins.”  Read more

Comments
Elizabeth, altruism is not a false prediction of evolution (by which I suppose you mean the Neo-Darwinian Synthesis), because the NDS predicts absolutely everything that exists and its opposite too. For example, do you need gradualism? We’ve got plenty of gradualism. You need something to explain the absence of gradualism in the fossil record? Well, we’ve got that too! It turns out that evolution is gradual when it needs to be slow and extra speedy when it needs to be fast. NDE predicts altruism and genocide. You’ve gotta hand it to a theory that predicts a behavior and the opposite of the behavior with equal alacrity.Barry Arrington
January 19, 2012
January
01
Jan
19
19
2012
03:25 PM
3
03
25
PM
PDT
In what sense is "altruism" a "false prediction" of evolution?Elizabeth Liddle
January 19, 2012
January
01
Jan
19
19
2012
01:56 PM
1
01
56
PM
PDT
I would cite the Cambrian explosion, the general trend towards stasis, irreducible complexity and the existence of an unfathomably sophisticated information bearing DNA, code as powerful evidence for evolution.Alan
January 19, 2012
January
01
Jan
19
19
2012
01:45 PM
1
01
45
PM
PDT
1 2 3

Leave a Reply