Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Strategies for reining in Big Tech and Big Social Media

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

(This topic is important to us because of Big Media’s propensity for censorship. If they haven’t got round to us yet, just give them some time and more ambitious keeners.)

A number of strategies to limit their power or make them share the wealth are being evaluated, both among governments and private think tanks

A foreseeable difficulty with just repealing Section 230 is that the Reality Czar’s office may be no more likely to support intellectual freedom than the Big Tech moguls it replaces. With centralization comes central control. In any event, companies the size of the Big Techs and Big Social Media often compete on an equal basis of power in many respects with US states and smaller national governments…

Because crackdown-friendly media sources are influential, those who want the freedom to hear the other side must argue for the general concept of freedom of speech more persuasively than would have been necessary generations ago. As many have noted, there is nothing unusual today about people associated with universities or publishers who claim to feel threatened by hearing opposing viewpoints. Or that some even resort to violence to prevent the expression of opinions of which they disapprove. Any strategy aimed at preserving intellectual freedom must take their influence into account.

Some sources advocate just moving away from Big Social Media altogether, in favor of smaller alternatives with, perhaps, fewer ambitions.

News, “Can Big Tech and Big Social Media be reined in?” at Mind Matters News

The reformers’ current challenge is not shortage of strategies for reining in Big Tech and Big Social Media but evaluating their likely effectiveness.

Also: Nevada announces new cities in state to be run by Big Tech Caitlin Bassett: The zones promise technological freedom, but what are the dangers to handing so much political power to big corporations?
Nevada’s governor says that local government is “inadequate” for the fast pace of technological innovation, pointing to Disney World as a model solution.

You may also wish to read:

In Big Tech World: the journalist as censor, hit man, and snitch. Glenn Greenwald looks at a disturbing trend in media toward misrepresentation as well as censorship.

and

Could a Seattle law hobble Amazon’s unaccountable censorship? John West discusses Amazon’s vulnerability in Seattle with Kara McKinney at Tipping Point. Amazon’s recent forays into delisting books based on political considerations could be considered viewpoint discrimination in its home town.

Comments
The best way to proceed is to make a closed of conservative organization. That not only the producers are conservative, but the consumers of the products produced by conservatives, are vetted to be conservative as well. Like that you cannot watch newsmax, if you are not a conservative. That's how you can escape censorship, by socialists simply not knowing what you are saying.mohammadnursyamsu
March 19, 2021
March
03
Mar
19
19
2021
09:02 AM
9
09
02
AM
PDT
This isn't new, just a return to normal after the brief Hundred Flowers trick lulled us into complacency. Dissidents have always needed to find and create their own methods of communication, just as prey have always used signals unreadable by predators. Part of nature.polistra
March 19, 2021
March
03
Mar
19
19
2021
07:42 AM
7
07
42
AM
PDT
Why do these topics even matter when it is now blatantly obvious that our elections are fixed anyway, and that roughly 70 percent of our representatives are bought and paid for? The few of us who are interested in learning about controversial viewpoints, can still find those with only a moderate effort. The same moderate effort is required to unplug oneself from big tech. The Controllers only care about mass influence and mass obedience, the few dissidents do not matter to them as long as these dissidents are not attempting to rock the boat.Eugene
March 18, 2021
March
03
Mar
18
18
2021
08:15 PM
8
08
15
PM
PDT

Leave a Reply