Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

The remarkable connection between mathematics and physics

arroba Email

As first noted by Nobelist Eugene Wigner:

In the latest issue of Communications of the Blyth Institute, Gordon Mullings presents his account of why that connection exists:

“Abstract: The Nobel Prize winning Physicist, Eugene Wigner, famously posed a powerful challenge (1960) by asking why is mathematics so effective, especially in the physical sciences. It is possible that the reason for the effectiveness of mathematics is not because mathematics is in any way causative, but instead because mathematics studies the structure of logical possibility and constraint. When plugged into a possible world, mathematics gives us the tools to analyze the logically possible outcomes. Therefore, when a possible world that is expressed mathematically sufficiently aligns with reality, mathematics becomes effective at expressing relationships and outcomes.”

According to Mullings, the reason for the association between mathematics and physics is not that the mathematics is causative but rather that mathematics studies the logical structure of possibility and constraint. As a result, if the mathematics successfully captures the possibilities and constraints in the real world, it will provide a tool for further analysis of potential possibilities.

Jonathan Bartlett, “Why Does Mathematics Interpret Reality?” at Mind Matters News

Also, introducing another article from the current issue of Communications: Are divergent series really an “invention of the devil”? The real villain in the piece is horrendously non-specific concepts of infinity. But that can be fixed. It turns out that hyperreal numbers (i.e., infinities that obey algebraic rules) resolve many of the paradoxes that previously plagued conceptions of divergent series. It is now possible to assign specific values to them. (Jonathan Bartlett)

Romans 1:20 "For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse." OldArmy94
Eugene, Interesting thoughts. However, I must note on the point: mathematics may indeed precede our world, but it cannot precede reality. Reality is whatever is or was, and were there ever utter non-being, such having no causal powers it would forever obtain. Indeed, a core of mathematics is necessarily implicated in there being any world whatsoever. So, as constraints on being, these will be present in any world. Beyond that, of course the physics of our fine tuned world shows profound insight and evident design to set a base for C-Chemistry, aqueous medium cell based life. Starting with nucleosynthesis. KF kairosfocus
The reason why mathematics interprets reality is that mathematics very likely precedes reality. The Designer knows math, while reality is just one enormous quantum computer, ultimately performing math. Humans have been gifted with ability to understand math (albeit rather rudimentary, at least for 99.9% of humans). Eugene

Leave a Reply