Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

The Theistic Geologist

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Three geologists stand at the foot of Mt. Rushmore. The first geologist says, “This mountain depicts perfectly the faces of four US presidents, it must be the work of a master sculptor.” The second says, “You are a geologist, you should know that all mountains were created by natural forces, such as volcanos and plate movements, the details were then sculpted by erosion from water and wind. How could you possibly think this was the work of an intelligent sculptor? Only a person completely ignorant of geophysics could think those faces were designed.”

The third geologist says to himself, “I don’t want to be seen as ignorant, but the faces in this mountain sure do look like they were designed.” So he thinks a moment and says to the second geologist, “Of course you are right, these faces were sculpted by natural forces such as erosion. Only an ignorant person would think they were designed.” Then he turns to the first and says, “But what a magnificent result, there obviously must have been a master sculptor standing by and watching.”

Comments
I wonder who the designer had in mind when she made this sculpture, and what message she was sending when she caused it to come crashing down.Arthur Hunt
April 14, 2013
April
04
Apr
14
14
2013
01:15 PM
1
01
15
PM
PDT
The difference between this and design in nature is that we don't know what nature corresponds with. A better analogy would be that aliens, not knowing what humans look like, saw Mt. Rushmore and tried to decide if it were designed.Collin
April 14, 2013
April
04
Apr
14
14
2013
01:08 PM
1
01
08
PM
PDT
Yeah, but what if those geologists didn't know anything about US history nor sculptures? And what about 3 geologists from another planet who had never seen humans? And what if their planet didn't have sculptures? :cool:Joe
April 14, 2013
April
04
Apr
14
14
2013
09:14 AM
9
09
14
AM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply