Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

We Is Junk

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The quote below is taken from this week’s Nature magazine.

Since joining the blogosphere over two years ago, when challenged, I’ve invoked a scenario pretty much like the one the paper summary is making. I suspect Dave Scot has been making this argument for a longer period than that.

While still preliminary, I have to say that when Nature magazine starts running articles saying that “gene regulation — not the creation of new genes — has moulded the traits that make us unique”, then all that can be said is (a la Allen MacNeil): “Darwinism is dead. Long live evo-devo.” Is the war over?

Anyone who has ever put together self-assembly
furniture knows that having the right parts
is important, but what you do with them can
make or break the project. The same seems
to be true of the vast amounts of DNA in an
organism’s genome that used to be labelled as
junk. Studies now indicate that this DNA may
be responsible for the signals that were crucial
for human evolution, directing the various
components of our genome to work differently
from the way they do in other organisms.

The findings seem to bolster a 30-year-old
hypothesis that gene regulation — not the creation
of new genes — has moulded the traits that
make us unique.

While there’s not many particulars in what I’ve quoted, it strikes me as provocative enough to invite comments. Any takers?

Comments
Professor Allen stated, "As to the question of patents, as I pointed out in my original post, Nobel prizes are awarded for discoveries, not applications (with the exception of the prize for physiology or medicine, which is sometimes awarded to the development of new diagnostic or therapeutic techniques). Therefore, no matter how revolutionary or useful, a new technology such as the one developed by John Sanford will not warrant a Nobel prize. However, a new discovery, such as the 3 degree black body radiation discovered by accident by Penzias and Wilson won them a Nobel prize in physics, even though the full theoretical explanation for the discovery was done by others." As I pointed out in my post. I put forth some sarcastic statements and then asked real questions about Modern Synthesis, EvoDevo, Cornerstone. You ignored the serious question and as I suspected you would answered the easy dunk. Will you not go on record to my real questions?Michaels7
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:04 PM
10
10
04
PM
PST
Allen MacNeil: "Was it IDers who figured out the constituents and operation of cells, or biologists, using the scientific method, as pioneered by Darwin? " Allen, you make it sound like Darwin discovered the "scientific method". I'm sure you don't mean that. But since you're talking about the "scientific method", here's what Roger Bacon has to say in the Novum Organum (in which he describes what we call as the "scientific method"):
Lastly, there are others who appear anxious lest there should be something discovered in the investigation of nature to overthrow, or at least shake religion, particularly among the unlearned. The two last apprehensions appear to resemble animal instinct, as if men were diffident, in the bottom of their minds, and secret meditations, of the strength of religion, and the empire of faith over the senses; and therefore feared that some danger awaited them from an inquiry into nature. But any one who properly considers the subject, will find natural philosophy to be, after the word of God, the surest remedy against superstition, and the most approved support of faith. She [i.e., natural philosophy=science] is therefore rightly bestowed upon religion as a most faithful attendant, for the one exhibits the will and the other the power of God.
Yes, that's right, the "scientific method" is meant to serve "faith", not eradicate it.PaV
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
01:00 PM
1
01
00
PM
PST
mike 1962:
whether or not variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and resulting in differential survival and reproduction has done this because we are still investigating such possibilities.
I would concur. I think we'll be seeing more and more collaborative efforts between life science type and those working in the physical sciences, with all of this opening up the door for the guys in information science. As John Davison would say: "How I love it so!"PaV
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
12:34 PM
12
12
34
PM
PST
Allen MacNeil (in response to Joseph): Two quotes: First
We don't yet know whether or not variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and resulting in differential survival and reproduction has done this because we are still investigating such possibilities. That's what science is all about: doing the hard work in the field and in the lab that either falsifies one's hypotheses or not.
Second quote:
. . . evolutionary biologists will continue to assert (with a century and a half of empirical evidence to back them up) that ID “theories” (which to date are no more than hypotheses) have no empirical support, and are therefore not science.
There seems to be a contradiction here. Either the 150 years of "empirical evidence" validates the "theory" or it doesn't. If it has been validated, then this "theory" should be making predictions, which, in turn, are either confirmed or negated, leading to either a strengthening of the theory or an ultimate rejection of the theory. If you are now in the lab doing all this hard work to figure out "whether or not variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and resulting in differential survival and reproduction has done this", then what are the "predictions" that are guiding your investigations? What, exactly, does Darwinism predict here? If you haven't any, then "variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and ... differential survival and reproduction" can never be falsified. So, please tell us, what is it you're looking for.? While you're mulling that over (as I stated when I posted this summary article) I "predicted" that junk-DNA would be found to be highly significant, and that it would be involved in the regulation of the coding (and the non-coding/binding ) portions of DNA, which is no more than what would be clearly expectated if one starts from a design perspective. These "predictions" have been borne out. But, as I posted a few days back, all of this is a "surprise" to Darwinists. This means, they are not only NOT "predicting" it, but flummoxed when they encounter it. So what good is this Darwinism that has a 150 years of proof, but which still is yet to be proven? If it can't "predict" anything, while a competing theory is accurately "predicting", then don't you think it's time for a change? And, BTW, there is "evidence" for ID. It's called IC. Meanwhile, RM+NS, the savior--via the Modern Synthesis--of Darwinism, has now been cast aside. Yet, somehow, Darwinism lives on. How is that?PaV
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
12:31 PM
12
12
31
PM
PST
Pav: "The problem to be solved, and the question to be answered, is: can NS, acting alone, bring about a “rearrangement” of the “genetic program” of a particular organism. I, for one, accept the “fact” of evolution (i.e., the fossil record), and I conditionally accept “common descent” (stochastic, versus continuous, descent has not been ruled out; but this is but a fine point), and I accept that there are many “mechanisms of variability”, but logically Darwinian evolution (i.e., variability, inheritance, fecundity) seems completely impotent in “stochastically” arriving at a new “program mode” for DNA/RNA information systems." Well put PaV. Reading this sort of thing gives me tingles of joy, because it is on this front where all the action lies. I predict it's going to be process control, and information theory types who will bring the next round of great gains here. Our bio system was come to be seem as a fantastically designed system "with the appearance of not being designed" on certain levels. The ultimate irony.mike1962
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:23 AM
11
11
23
AM
PST
Pav: "Do the “engines of variation” provide sufficient variation to move beyond microevolution to macroevolution." PaV gets the cigar today.mike1962
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:15 AM
11
11
15
AM
PST
On the heels of my last comment... Allen:
Was it IDers who figured out the constituents and operation of cells, or biologists, using the scientific method, as pioneered by Darwin?
Notice how you contrast "IDer" with "Biologist using the scientific method". You should know better than to claim that no true biologist would be an IDer.Atom
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:13 AM
11
11
13
AM
PST
MacNeill: "Actually, we do. As just one example, we know that a fusion of two chromosomes in a primate ancestor in the hominid line is correlated with the divergence between the line that led to humans and the line that led to chimps and other great apes." Correlated? That's not an indication of causation any more than the presence of raincoats on my kids somehow indicating that raincoats cause rain. Sorry, sir, now you're just being sloppy.mike1962
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:12 AM
11
11
12
AM
PST
Allen, I am among those here who appreciate your posts and as PaV pointed out, to me you fight fair. I feel that the longer you stick around here, the more the lights will begin to click on. It is good to have your ideas challenged and you are up-front in admitting that past NDE mechanisms (RM+NS) have proven fruitless in producing the change necessary for Macroevolution to occur. You propose new mechanisms. Good. When you discover that these new mechanisms for adaptation are non-random and built-in responses, (i.e. complex systems that themselves need to be explained), perhaps you will be more comfortable tenatively holding to the Design hypothesis.Atom
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:10 AM
11
11
10
AM
PST
MacNeill: "So the real question is, are the “engines of variation” sufficient to produce the raw material upon which natural selection operates, producing the adaptations we see in living organisms? So far, based on what we have observed in studying living organisms (and the genetic and developmental mechanisms by which they change over time) the answer is yes." So the engines of variation you speak of are sufficient for novel cell types, tissues, and body plans? Where has this been demonstrated empirically?mike1962
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
11:02 AM
11
11
02
AM
PST
#30 "Precisely; and how did we find out that cells were more than just bags of protoplasm? By doing a century and a half of intensive lab work, all of it originally stimulated by Darwin's testable hypothesis. Was it IDers who figured out the constituents and operation of cells, or biologists, using the scientific method, as pioneered by Darwin?" Please don't bluff. Darwin did not really influence how science in biology has been done. One thing is science, another darwinismkairos
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:59 AM
10
10
59
AM
PST
Thanks PaV and Jason for your comments. Concerning Al I wonder why he should put himself out of the religious realm. In his last messages he has just shown his strong faith ...kairos
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:56 AM
10
10
56
AM
PST
Kairos wrote: "But 150 years ago they thought cells were a mere biological jello; as you know things are now MORE AND MORE worse for susch a sort of speculations." Precisely; and how did we find out that cells were more than just bags of protoplasm? By doing a century and a half of intensive lab work, all of it originally stimulated by Darwin's testable hypothesis. Was it IDers who figured out the constituents and operation of cells, or biologists, using the scientific method, as pioneered by Darwin?Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:51 AM
10
10
51
AM
PST
BTW- If you think I'm being harsh. Go back through the various posts Allen has commented in and check out his often hateful remarks towards Bill, Denyse, and the rest of us. Some of his comments were so hateful they were actually deleted. One should expect more from a college professor, let alone someone who claims to want to add to the debate in a civil and polite manner, yet shows the opposite in 90% of his comments. When someone else comes here and shows incivility and calls names, attacks with bogus straw men, they are quick to get the boot. And for good reason. If you can't stop being arrogant and acting as if you're up on high looking down upon all of us fools- you have nothing of value to add to the discussion period.JasonTheGreek
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:31 AM
10
10
31
AM
PST
By the way- if you go to dr. al's blog- his top post is about atheism. Wait- I thought Darwinism didn't equal atheism? (gasp!) He shows his true colors when he says this of religion and science:
"Don't get me wrong: I don't begrudge religious believers their beliefs. But, if I had to make a choice and my life (or the life of someone I loved) were on the line, I would choose science every time. In other words, if it were a choice between a deeply religious but poorly trained doctor without much "bedside manner" and an atheist but highly trained doctor with the bedside manner of a Marine drill sargeant, I would choose the latter every time. And would I appreciate anyone praying for me? I would of course appreciate the sentiment, but would not expect it to have any effect whatsoever on the outcome. Unlike science, prayer has no observable effect on the course of events in the real, physical world...which is, as far as I know, the only world there is."
Like most atheists- Al wants to claim that science and religion are two opposite ideas, they can't come together, that religion is nonsense fantasy and science is the real world and common sense. Notice how there are only two choices- 'science or religion'...I assume from his comments he doesn't think you can have both. His mindset is probably why he never has anything of value to add to ANY discussion here.JasonTheGreek
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:23 AM
10
10
23
AM
PST
Allen MacNeil:
So the real question is, are the “engines of variation” sufficient to produce the raw material upon which natural selection operates, producing the adaptations we see in living organisms? So far, based on what we have observed in studying living organisms (and the genetic and developmental mechanisms by which they change over time) the answer is yes.
Allen, it's always nice to have you here posting. You fight fair; i.e., you punch us in the nose, but you don't kick us in the ribs. I'd like to take a "jab" at you right now if I can. Specifically, I disagree 1000% with what you identify as the "real question". The "real question" is not if the "engines of variation" are sufficient to produce the raw material upon which NS operates. The answer to that question is obviously "yes", since the world is full of variable species. The "real question" is this : Do the "engines of variation" provide sufficient variation to move beyond microevolution to macroevolution. That still is the debate here. I can't tell you how happy I am not to have people forcing RM+NS down my throat as THE answer to evolutionary diversity. Nonetheless, conceding the three dozen mechanisms of variation, there still remains the question of whether these "dozens" of mechanism can be "orchestrated" in such a way as to bring about large-scale changes in organisms. It would seem that Goldschmidt's "hopeful monster" would be just the kind of thing you'd be latching onto right now. Yet, even that doesn't get you out of the woods, since there now is this problem of "information systems". More and more, what we see coming out of labs these days is affirmation of DNA/RNA as a developmental program much like that of a computer program---only vastly more complex. The problem to be solved, and the question to be answered, is: can NS, acting alone, bring about a "rearrangement" of the "genetic program" of a particular organism. I, for one, accept the "fact" of evolution (i.e., the fossil record), and I conditionally accept "common descent" (stochastic, versus continuous, descent has not been ruled out; but this is but a fine point), and I accept that there are many "mechanisms of variability", but logically Darwinian evolution (i.e., variability, inheritance, fecundity) seems completely impotent in "stochastically" arriving at a new "program mode" for DNA/RNA information systems.PaV
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:21 AM
10
10
21
AM
PST
Look on the bright side th0- at least ol' white brows hasn't called us all anti-science fools as he did in a previous comment!JasonTheGreek
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:18 AM
10
10
18
AM
PST
More bunk from Al here. First notice the extreme arrogance. I wonder what his students feel like- knowing they're all so far below him...? Al wrote: "Actually, we do. As just one example, we know that a fusion of two chromosomes in a primate ancestor in the hominid line is correlated with the divergence between the line that led to humans and the line that led to chimps and other great apes. We know this because human chromosome #2 is the product of this fusion, a conclusion that is based on pure empirical genetic testing." This doesn't make any sense. We cannot genetically test the supposed last common ancestor, because we have no idea what it might have been. Chromosome #2 APPEARS to be a product of fusion, but this cannot, in ANY manner, be tested in any empirical manner. You can PROPOSE a fusion event, but you can't test it out. Mapping the chimp and human genomes won't help you out here either. Furthermore, there's NO way to test WHEN this supposed event took place. Let's say, for argument's sake, it IS a fusion event. We have no idea when it took place in time, where at in the 'line' from hominid to chimp to human, etc. He ends his comment with the usual fluff- ID isn't science, IDers aren't true scientists, they refuse to do lab work, they refuse to practice TRUE science, etc. If experimentation is what makes an idea science- I guess that means the idea of black holes aren't considered science. There are MANY things in science which cannot be tested empircally. A transition from one species to another is a prime example of what cannot be tested (Darwinists: "it would take far longer to show this than any human can live!") Don't buy the nonsense- experimentation doesn't equal science in the manner Al claims. No one has done an experiment to show common descent, so this very idea would be thrown our with Allen's double standards.JasonTheGreek
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:17 AM
10
10
17
AM
PST
#23
Referring to CSI, IC, and other ID ideas isn't doing science at all. It does not involve doing actual experiments or field observations, it simply relies upon conceptual arguements, arguments that so far have no empirical support.
The "conceptual arguments" you are referring are just based on the strongest and clearest empirical support: evidence of complexity and specificity (as far as known only realized by intelligent agencies) and huge experimental inability of the proposed undriven mechanisms to decently account for them. BTW, all science you are speaking about does really describe thinks that suggest evolution did occur but NOT how evolution did occur. Moreover, surely you know that since tens of years mathematicians have strongly criticized the optimistical and wishful claims coming from biologists used to sell NDE without an even small probabilistic proof. Apparently you are simply going on the same way.
Until IDers start performing actual experiments or gathering field data that clearly and unambiguously distinguish between EB and ID hypotheses, evolutionary biologists will continue to assert (with a century and a half of empirical evidence to back them up) that ID “theories” (which to date are no more than hypotheses) have no empirical support, and are therefore not science. But 150 years ago they thought cells were a mere biological jello; as you know things are now MORE AND MORE worse for susch a sort of speculations.kairos
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
10:04 AM
10
10
04
AM
PST
Joseph asked: "...why don't we know what mutations afforded what changes? " Actually, we do. As just one example, we know that a fusion of two chromosomes in a primate ancestor in the hominid line is correlated with the divergence between the line that led to humans and the line that led to chimps and other great apes. We know this because human chromosome #2 is the product of this fusion, a conclusion that is based on pure empirical genetic testing. Joseph also asked: "Why don't we even know whether or not ANY mutation/ selection process can account for the range of change required for Common Descent to be indicative of reality?" We don't yet know whether or not variation coupled with inheritance, fecundity, and resulting in differential survival and reproduction has done this because we are still investigating such possibilities. That's what science is all about: doing the hard work in the field and in the lab that either falsifies one's hypotheses or not. Referring to CSI, IC, and other ID ideas isn't doing science at all. It does not involve doing actual experiments or field observations, it simply relies upon conceptual arguements, arguments that so far have no empirical support. Until IDers start performing actual experiments or gathering field data that clearly and unambiguously distinguish between EB and ID hypotheses, evolutionary biologists will continue to assert (with a century and a half of empirical evidence to back them up) that ID "theories" (which to date are no more than hypotheses) have no empirical support, and are therefore not science.Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
09:08 AM
9
09
08
AM
PST
Sorry, there was an error in quoting a part of Allen's message. This is the correct text with the answer.: .........
“I find it hard to believe that a process as precise and well controlled as the transposition of genetic elements happens only by chance. ”
This is what is known as “argument from incredulity” and is no different from Erich von Daniken's argument that aliens must have built the pyramids and the statues on Easter Island because “it is difficult to believe that such primitive people could have accomplished this.” What a scientist does when confronted with something that she does not understand is to try to figure out a testable natural mechanism (or, preferably several) by which it could have happened, and then perform enough experiments to determine if there is sufficient evidence to eliminate most (or, ideally, all but one) of the possible mechanisms. Allen, the argument from incredulity should be supported in a better way (if possible at all). You are missing at least a fundamental point: nobody was so crazy to think that those artifacts could really be the result of natural forces; instead a precise inference of design (bingo!) has always been done and the only problem has been to eventually dispute if this could have been done by past men with their technologies. But this is a quite different point for only few people really think that aliens were the artisans because past men indeedd DID have the capability to design them. Instead the origin of life is “a bit” different if you consider that in this case it is non only a technology problem but, more essentially, a “design of complexity” problem. ........kairos
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
09:00 AM
9
09
00
AM
PST
“I find it hard to believe that a process as precise and well controlled as the transposition of genetic elements happens only by chance. ” Allen MacNeil: This is what is known as “argument from incredulity” and is no different from Erich von Daniken's argument that aliens must have built the pyramids and the statues on Easter Island because “it is difficult to believe that such primitive people could have accomplished this.” Alleged "arguments from incredulity" can be refuted by real data. Arguments from ignorance do not count. Allen MacNeil: What a scientist does when confronted with something that she does not understand is to try to figure out a testable natural mechanism (or, preferably several) by which it could have happened, and then perform enough experiments to determine if there is sufficient evidence to eliminate most (or, ideally, all but one) of the possible mechanisms. Dr Spetner has proposed a specific mechansim-> built-in responses to environmental cues, being one. He has also proposed a "non-random evolutionary hypothesis". So I would suggest getting off of your horse and face reality. Allen MacNeil: Only after this has been done is it legitimate to call the explanation that you have proposed a “theory” (i.e. a hypothesis that has been repeatedly teasted, but that has not yet been falsified on the basis of empirical evidence). By this criterion, ID clearly isn't a theory, it is at best an untested (and perhaps untestable) hypothesis. But also by that same criterion Common Descent doesn't qualify and the materialistic alternative to ID, ie sheer-dumb-luck, isn't even close to qualifying. ID can be tested by the concepts of CSI, IC and counterflow. Counterflow is how we knew about North Korea's nuclear blast. And when that is followed back, that is where we find CSI. Also "evolution via design" is a mechanism. Allen MacNeil: Darwin's theory made it possible to investigate the causes of biological diversity, and thereby sparked the formation of the analytical sciences of genetics, developmental biology, comparative anatomy and physiology, paleontology, historical geology, and ecology. IF, Darwin's theory made it possible to investigate the causes of biological diversity, then why don't we know what mutations afforded what changes? Why don't we even know whether or not ANY mutation/ selection process can account for the range of change required for Common Descent to be indicative of reality? And again why is wobbling stability what is actually observed, in nature and in the lab?Joseph
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
08:55 AM
8
08
55
AM
PST
#15, 19
So the real question is, are the “engines of variation” sufficient to produce the raw material upon which natural selection operates, producing the adaptations we see in living organisms? So far, based on what we have observed in studying living organisms (and the genetic and developmental mechanisms by which they change over time) the answer is yes.
Come on Allen; this is pretty wishful thinking. You should know that this confidence on the possibility that “engines of variation” had been able to drive evolution is based on a single observation (the life world such as we can observe it now) and on a classical circular reasoning. The fact that you convince yourself that this could be a real scientific argument does not change the raw fact: apparently no engines of that sort are a plausible explication of life.
“I find it hard to believe that a process as precise and well controlled as the transposition of genetic elements happens only by chance. ”
This is what is known as “argument from incredulity” and is no different from Erich von Daniken's argument that aliens must have built the pyramids and the statues on Easter Island because “it is difficult to believe that such primitive people could have accomplished this.” What a scientist does when confronted with something that she does not understand is to try to figure out a testable natural mechanism (or, preferably several) by which it could have happened, and then perform enough experiments to determine if there is sufficient evidence to eliminate most (or, ideally, all but one) of the possible mechanisms. Allen, the argument from incredulity should be supported in a better way (if possible at all). You are missing at least a fundamental point: nobody was so crazy to think that those artifacts could really be the result of natural forces; instead a precise inference of design (bingo!) has always been done and the only problem has been to eventually dispute if this could have been done by past men with their technologies. But this is a quite different point for only few people really think that aliens were the artisans because past men indeedd DID have the capability to design them. Instead the origin of life is "a bit" different if you consider that in this case it is non only a technology problem but, more essentially, a "design of complexity" problem.
Only after this has been done is it legitimate to call the explanation that you have proposed a “theory” (i.e. a hypothesis that has been repeatedly teasted, but that has not yet been falsified on the basis of empirical evidence). By this criterion, ID clearly isn't a theory, it is at best an untested (and perhaps untestable) hypothesis.
It's strange; if you read NDE for ID, this seems exactly the scientific status of NDE ...kairos
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
08:52 AM
8
08
52
AM
PST
"I find it hard to believe that a process as precise and well controlled as the transposition of genetic elements happens only by chance. " This is what is known as "argument from incredulity" and is no different from Erich von Daniken's argument that aliens must have built the pyramids and the statues on Easter Island because "it is difficult to believe that such primitive people could have accomplished this." What a scientist does when confronted with something that she does not understand is to try to figure out a testable natural mechanism (or, preferably several) by which it could have happened, and then perform enough experiments to determine if there is sufficient evidence to eliminate most (or, ideally, all but one) of the possible mechanisms. Only after this has been done is it legitimate to call the explanation that you have proposed a "theory" (i.e. a hypothesis that has been repeatedly teasted, but that has not yet been falsified on the basis of empirical evidence). By this criterion, ID clearly isn't a theory, it is at best an untested (and perhaps untestable) hypothesis.Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
07:44 AM
7
07
44
AM
PST
As to the overall question of the value of evolutionary theory to biology, an historical analysis of the development of biology indicates that Darwin's publication of the Origin of Species in 1859 laid the foundation for the entire science of biology. Prior to 1859, there was no "science" of biology in the way that there was a science of physics or chemistry. What Darwin's predecessors did was called "natural history," and like history in general, it was virtually entirely descriptive. Science is much more than simple description. It includes an empirical analysis of causes and effects, which are assumed to require only natural causes until the evidence absolutely requires otherwise (which so far hasn't happened). Darwin's theory made it possible to investigate the causes of biological diversity, and thereby sparked the formation of the analytical sciences of genetics, developmental biology, comparative anatomy and physiology, paleontology, historical geology, and ecology. By providing an empirically testable hypothesis for the diversity of life, the theory of evolution provided an empirically testable mechanism for biological cause and effect, and initiated the transformation of "natural history" into the modern, evolving science of biology.Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
07:21 AM
7
07
21
AM
PST
Allen MacNeil: Descent with modification is so firmly grounded in empirical observations that even one of the founders of ID (Michael Behe) wholeheartedly supports it. It doesn't matter who supports what. What does matter is what does the data "say"? And guess what? Observational data tells us that wobbling stability is the norm and that only wishful thinking can get around that observation. The bottom-line is sexual reproduction put an end to evolutionism. Common descent cannot be objectively tested. It is beyond the realm of modern science to do so for reasons I have provided- the main reason being we do NOT know what makes an organism what it is and we know that although genes may influence every aspect of development they do NOT determine it. Allen MacNeil: The ID strawman of “random mutation” hardly encompasses a tiny fraction of what we now recognize as the “engines of variation” the comprise modern genetics and evo-devo. I would say the "strawman" is all yours- or perhaps you could explain this: Mutations are random And then we have the following from Dr Spetner discussing transposons:
The motion of these genetic elements to produce the above mutations has been found to a complex process and we probably haven't yet discovered all the complexity. But because no one knows why they occur, many geneticists have assumed they occur only by chance. I find it hard to believe that a process as precise and well controlled as the transposition of genetic elements happens only by chance. Some scientists tend to call a mechanism random before we learn what it really does. If the source of the variation for evolution were point mutations, we could say the variation is random. But if the source of the variation is the complex process of transposition, then there is no justification for saying that evolution is based on random events.
Joseph
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
07:20 AM
7
07
20
AM
PST
As to the question of patents, as I pointed out in my original post, Nobel prizes are awarded for discoveries, not applications (with the exception of the prize for physiology or medicine, which is sometimes awarded to the development of new diagnostic or therapeutic techniques). Therefore, no matter how revolutionary or useful, a new technology such as the one developed by John Sanford will not warrant a Nobel prize. However, a new discovery, such as the 3 degree black body radiation discovered by accident by Penzias and Wilson won them a Nobel prize in physics, even though the full theoretical explanation for the discovery was done by others.Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
07:11 AM
7
07
11
AM
PST
In comment #2, Jack Golightly asked "How does evolutionary theory help you in understanding any of this?" At its broadest, evolutionary theory encompasses two basic ideas: "descent with modification" (Darwin's original term for what we now refer to as phylogeny) and "natural selection" (the "mechanism" by which Darwin proposed that descent with modification was caused). Descent with modification is so firmly grounded in empirical observations that even one of the founders of ID (Michael Behe) wholeheartedly supports it. Natural selection, however, is another story. According to Darwin, natural selection is the inevitable result of three pre-conditions: variation, inheritance, and fecundity. Given these three pre-conditions, some individuals survive and reproduce more often than others. As a result, their heritable variations become relatively more common over time in the populations of which they are members. What many people (including many evolutionary biologists) have often misunderstood is where the real "engine" of evolution is among these preconditions. As John Endler has pointed out, this "engine" isn't natural selection itself, as it is simply an outcome; a result of the operation of the "engine". So where is that "engine", the thing that actually drives the origin and diversification of new phylogenetic lines? It is, of course, in the processes that produce new variations. Selection, be it artificial or natural, is limited by whatever variations are present. Furthermore, the effect of selection is to decrease variation, by removing those variations that result in decreased survival and reproduction. So, the "engine" of evolution is really encompassed by those processes that produce variations (i.e. differences) between individuals in populations. This is why some astute IDers point to the source of variation as the locus for the operation of the IDesigner. They realize what evolutionary biologists realize: that there is virtually no dispute about the mechanisms of inheritance nor the Malthusian "laws" of fecundity nor the "iron rule" of differential survival and reproduction. The source of all new forms (what Darwin called "endless forms most beautiful") is the "engines of variation." And so, the reason that evo-devo is sparking a revolution in evolutionary biology is that it provides an empirically testable set of mechanisms for the production of new variation. Notice I said "mechanisms" - i.e. there are many such mechanisms. The ID strawman of "random mutation" hardly encompasses a tiny fraction of what we now recognize as the "engines of variation" the comprise modern genetics and evo-devo. Evolutionary biology therefore helps us find these mechanisms by first asserting that they exist. We see overwhelming evidence that descent with modification has occurred, evidence so overwhelming that even the most dedicated IDers agree with it. This requires us to enquire what "mechanisms" must have produced this change. And the answer is, the mechanisms of genetic and developmental variation. This summer, our evolution/design seminar spent an evening listing off an briefly describing these mechanisms. We came up with a list of three dozen, everything from single nucleotide point mutations (i.e. substitutions, insertions, and deletions) to whole genome fusion events (such as often happens in hybridization between different species of plants). The list of different ways that variations can be produced is huge and growing, which means that the "engines of variation" are multifarious and extraordinarily effective. And, as far as any current statistical analysis has shown, they are also effectively random. That is, a blizzard of new variations is produced in every generation of every population of organisms. Under natural conditions, selection elminates all but a small fraction of these (under domestication many more survive, as Darwin first proposed). So the real question is, are the "engines of variation" sufficient to produce the raw material upon which natural selection operates, producing the adaptations we see in living organisms? So far, based on what we have observed in studying living organisms (and the genetic and developmental mechanisms by which they change over time) the answer is yes.Allen_MacNeill
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
06:57 AM
6
06
57
AM
PST
"We can't even mention it in fear of alienation and being blacklisted, how are we going to get some lab space to do some research?!?! Mention that you believe in ID in mots labs and you will be frowned upon, let alone given some time to come up with a testable hypothesis." I think the problem with this is that the DI claims it has spent millions on research, and there are supposedly a growing number of scientists who support ID. Johnny B even gave me a list of scientists who are apparently doing ID research so i think it's unfair to say it's impossible. "Not the upper echelon of biology prof. (though I doubt many of them even know)." What Allen said was in one of the first lectures of my degree, and none of the stuff he said or PaV quoted is particularly controversial. "Alan, would you lend your name to support finding funding for additional ID research?" I think the problem with this is that to my knowledge there are no specific ID research proposals and no indication that anything would come of it. After a decade and supposedly millions spent with next to nothing to show for it people have a right to be sceptical. In any event a lot could be done with a computer and acces to journals so it really isn't too expensive. "The point of this post seems to be that what ID predicted, that there would be many coded functions contained in the “junk DNA” has proved to be true." We've known this for decades though. I once worked on investigating functional RNA sequences that came from the 'junk DNA' and I had to regularly read papers from th 80s that talked about what Allen is describing. The rate at which we find these things has accelerated exponentially in the last few years though so you hear a lot more about it. "We are finding higher and higher level codes in DNA. There is no way that this makes NDE more likely than ID as an explanation." ID will never be seen as an 'explanation' until it is fleshed out into a proper theory. Something like the ide of frontloading seems like a small step in the right direction. "They approach and design their work accordingly. Then, once they've made some inroad into understanding how something works, they then interpret this in Darwinian terms." A lot of them do, a lot of them also use the theory to make predictions about what they will find. "Were you predicting years ago that they would one day find regulatory elements in so-called “junk DNA”, and did you anticipate that “programming” would be THE major part of determining biological form?" I think people knew about these things before the term ID existed. "We might observe a change of direction back where theist win the bulk of scientific awards as they did so in the past." I don't see how theists winning scientific awards would make a difference. A great number of the people I work with are theists, there are a great number of Evangelicals and other Christians in the royal society in the UK. "Has PZ produced any Patents? Dawkins? Dennett?" Dont know but I know of a great number of 'evolutionist scientists' who have. "Which is it? Evo Devo, the Cornerstone of a “More” Modern Synthesis? Or, Superceeded and The Four Gene Types?" Both, the modern synthesis has been superseded by a more modern synthesis. The fact that there isnt really standard terminology is annoying but doesn't change this. Basically evodevo, developmental plasticity, epigenetics and systems biology have expanded the theory. As Allen pointed out this might be analogous to Newtonian gravity being superceeded, but we are still in the transitional phase. I dont expect to see this stuff in highscholl textbooks for at least a few years yet.Chris Hyland
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
03:21 AM
3
03
21
AM
PST
Dr. MacNeil, A Nobel "Peace" prize was awarded to Yasar Arafat. I'm not impressed with their choices as of late. You are observing a change in worldviews over time. I'd expect evolutionist to recognize historic reality. We might observe a change of direction back where theist win the bulk of scientific awards as they did so in the past. Do you so easily ignore one of the worlds leading genetic scientist, Dr. Sanford? I wonder... is he Nobel worthy? Not that 25 patents in groundbreaking genetic research amount to much. Just surprised you overlook one so near. His work is not considered IDist, but Creationist I guess? Has PZ produced any Patents? Dawkins? Dennett? Did a Google search. Four words; "Professor Allen MacNeill patent." See what the first entry pulls up... http://www.google.com/search?q=Professor+Allen+MacNeill+patent&start=0&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official It was a surprise seeing you listed along with Dr. Sanford. Paraphrasing Dr. Sanford, "evolution was a complete waste of his time." MES is superceeded? Old news? I do not remember seeing this announced by evolutionist. Lets see, Is MES superceeded? October 2005, Abnormal Interest; "Relaxed, clear, informative, straightforward, matter of fact, PZ Myers teaches us about the modern synthesis in biology and debunks Intelligent Designs creationism all in 44 minutes and six easy lessons." Is the reviewer totally ignorant of Meyers commentary or is Meyers out of touch with your teachings? I have not listened to the audio, but the review is straight forward. Here's the Link: http://www.telecomtally.com/blog/2005/10/pz_myers_on_evo.html Or did Modern Synthesis change after October 2005? Maybe its improved... From a posting by Esperanza, commenting on the book; Endless Forms Most Beautiful, Chapter 11, by Carroll. "Chapter 11 concludes the book with summaries of how Evo devo is so important in biology today. Evo devo is the cornerstone of more modern synthesis. Genes per se were not “drivers” of evolution."" So, is Evo Devo the "cornerstone of "more" Modern Synthesis"? Was this predicted by Evolutionist? Or did it take 60 years for it to be recognized? What date did EvoDevo become the "CornerStone" of MES? Or of Evolution for that matter? Certainly that would be in todays high school textbooks, correct? I need to check. Anyone else know? As defined, Cornerstone = basis: the fundamental assumptions from which something is begun or developed or calculated or explained; "the whole argument rested on a basis of conjecture". How does a recent discovery become a foundation for "more" of something if the foundation did not exist in the past? Can it be that evolutionist are merely adapting discoveries into their beliefs systems? Though I was initially sarcastic in rebuttal to you and for good reason; this is a legitimate question and not offerred as antagonistic. Because if the Post at PZ and Carroll are saying EvoDevo is the "Cornerstone" of More Modern Synthesis, but you are saying, MES has been superceeded, then something is not copasetic. We've come to a crossroads. And this one's not in Georgia. Which is it? Evo Devo, the Cornerstone of a "More" Modern Syntesis? Or, Superceeded and The Four Gene Types? How are IDist, or no, lets stop there and be more direct.... How am I, supposed to understand Evolutionist when it appears definitions are not formulated clearly within your own scientific community? It certainly is not for a lack of effort in reading the material. I am clearly out of my league with you and others. But pardon me for observing, no wonder there is confusion. If those in the field cannot agree. I do not mind being told - We don't know. I realize the general public, myself included can be hard to teach. We do not do this for a living and our knowledge base can be rusty. But I want to make something very clear - that does not translate into - we cannot learn given the same amount of class and lab time. We all take different paths in life. And while I do understand how the learned can lose patience with the uninformed. Professors should not lose patience when they themselves cannot present a consistent picture to the students at large. Am I wrong in seeing a disconnect within your own community and asking such a straight forward question? It appears to me, monumental changes are taking place. Finally Professor MacNeill, you say; "Therefore, this is how I intend to teach the concept of a “gene” to my students at Cornell from now on." You did not teach this concept of genes before now? Do I understood you? I want to know where; "from now on", enters into your classes as new teaching for genetics material. Did you not teach this in 2005/6 - Fall/Spring/Summer/Fall? And you will be teaching this as "new" material for 2007? You have been generous in opening up class time to review of ID. For that I am thankful. And I do appreciate your efforts here. But I am curious. Will you teach EvoDevo as the "Cornerstone of More Modern Synthesis" or as Superceeding it? Regards...Michaels7
November 11, 2006
November
11
Nov
11
11
2006
01:04 AM
1
01
04
AM
PST
1 2 3 4