Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

We Is Junk

Categories
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The quote below is taken from this week’s Nature magazine.

Since joining the blogosphere over two years ago, when challenged, I’ve invoked a scenario pretty much like the one the paper summary is making. I suspect Dave Scot has been making this argument for a longer period than that.

While still preliminary, I have to say that when Nature magazine starts running articles saying that “gene regulation — not the creation of new genes — has moulded the traits that make us unique”, then all that can be said is (a la Allen MacNeil): “Darwinism is dead. Long live evo-devo.” Is the war over?

Anyone who has ever put together self-assembly
furniture knows that having the right parts
is important, but what you do with them can
make or break the project. The same seems
to be true of the vast amounts of DNA in an
organism’s genome that used to be labelled as
junk. Studies now indicate that this DNA may
be responsible for the signals that were crucial
for human evolution, directing the various
components of our genome to work differently
from the way they do in other organisms.

The findings seem to bolster a 30-year-old
hypothesis that gene regulation — not the creation
of new genes — has moulded the traits that
make us unique.

While there’s not many particulars in what I’ve quoted, it strikes me as provocative enough to invite comments. Any takers?

Comments
One more thing, Allen also wrote:
Or, to put it in a way a journalist/literature critic might be able to understand, ID currently stands in relationship to science where literary criticism stands in relationship to literature.
As I've noted in the above post, Darwinism is really nothing more than a narrative gloss added to research done in the lab that was motivated by completely non-Darwinian thinking. Hence, IDist are reduced to "critiquing" the gloss. It all fits.PaV
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
11:27 PM
11
11
27
PM
PST
Allen MacNeil:
Interpreting other people's discoveries in the light of different theoretical models doesn't cut it. That's why Nobel prizes are awarded to the people making the discoveries, not to the people who figure out what they mean.
My sense is that what really happens in labs is that scientists ask themselves this primary and basic question of the life forms they work with: how does it work? They approach and design their work accordingly. Then, once they've made some inroad into understanding how something works, they then interpret this in Darwinian terms. IOW, Darwinism is ex post facto. An IDist working in the lab would be asking the same primary and basic question: how does this something work. The difference would be in how the results would be interpreted. But, Allen, a question: Were you predicting years ago that they would one day find regulatory elements in so-called "junk DNA", and did you anticipate that "programming" would be THE major part of determining biological form? These are the kinds of things that ID expects. What we read in the scientific literature is one "surprise" after another from Darwinists. I think this is a strong suggestion that conventional evolutionary thinking is off-target, while ID thinking is right on the mark. Why not, as Patrick suggests, work to fund ID research? Or is a hidden materialistic attachment to Darwinism preventing such a thing from happening?PaV
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
10:27 PM
10
10
27
PM
PST
The point of this post seems to be that what ID predicted, that there would be many coded functions contained in the "junk DNA" has proved to be true. What random origin theories predict is that there must be a lot of rubbish and junk that is either waiting for some future function or a vestage of some past function. We are finding higher and higher level codes in DNA. There is no way that this makes NDE more likely than ID as an explanation. The word "evolution" is always inserted somewhere in all these articles otherwise thay would sound like ID papers.idnet.com.au
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
09:45 PM
9
09
45
PM
PST
So, as soon as ID theorists stop spending all their time writing press releases and participating in debates, and start spending time in the field and in the lab doing actual scientific research, there might be a place in science for what they discover.
Alan, would you lend your name to support finding funding for additional ID research? I'm sure you believe that line of research will likely turn up fruitless in the end but I think you'd agree it's at least worth the time to investigate with seriously funded research.Patrick
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
09:24 PM
9
09
24
PM
PST
"...ID theorists stop spending all their time writing press ... and start spending time in the field and in the lab doing actual scientific research..." Here we go again at the very old, useless statement that basically implies that there are no "real" ID scientists in the real, working scientfic community. And the Darwimps are constantly doing everythin in their power to keep ANY ID specific realted research from happening. And that by age old terror tactics! It has only gotten worse in the last years. The NCSE, Darwin's "witch-hunters inc." insure that ID scientists will have hell to pay and blacklisting to suffer for even mentioning or countenancing the idea of proposing real-life ID oriented projects. Those who have tried have had evo-priestesses like mme. E. Scott to thank for the evil treatment they've received. So, what you basically throw out here is worse than a useless challenge. It is also a not so subtle, getting very old and moldly, underlying accusation. The usual one. Even more embarassing to you Allen, is this inane statement, "As long as ID theory remains essentially parasitic on biology and the other sciences, it will never be recognized as science." Q: Indeed, and just who do you think is spending millions and working so very hard with such vast and varied low-life tactics at keeping ID out the field?!? A: People in the darwinian fundamentalist, "don't disturb our Lord and Savior, Darwin or be damned", camp! "Darwin loves you", indeed. Your comment is like a tyrant telling his imprisoned victim to show proof of his innocence while still in the dungeon. Fortunately the dungeons doors have been shattered & ID is gaining on you Darwinos. Much more could be said, considering that most of the great discoveries of science were done by creationists or IDists. Even "natural selection" is an IDists term! The rest I'll leave to others if they wish to point out the facts to you. Pathetic. Shame on you!Borne
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
09:19 PM
9
09
19
PM
PST
jpark, if I recall the John Templeton Foundation had made several million dollars available and had solicited proposals for scientific research into ID. Some of that money may still be available.rrf
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
08:42 PM
8
08
42
PM
PST
To clarify* Few supporters = The massive crowd in America that vehemently attack ID, without knowing much evolution themselves. Not the upper echelon of biology prof. (though I doubt many of them even know).jpark320
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
08:15 PM
8
08
15
PM
PST
To be fair only a few supporters of evolution actually know what Dr. MacNeil is talking about... so isn't it a fair criticism about the supporters of evolution (perhaps not evolution in itself) that tout what Dr. MacNeil describes as a strawman as the truth? I think, its harsh to blame IDers for not breaking out much research esp. with the backlash associated with it. We can't even mention it in fear of alienation and being blacklisted, how are we going to get some lab space to do some research?!?! Mention that you believe in ID in mots labs and you will be frowned upon, let alone given some time to come up with a testable hypothesis.jpark320
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
08:14 PM
8
08
14
PM
PST
Allen, I can't help but to appreciate the extensive knowledge and insight you have into this astoundingly complex world of DNA. Thank you for explaining this about the "four (possibly five) functionally different kinds of DNA coding sequences". Very interesting. I have a question though: How does evolutionary theory help you in understanding any of this?Jack Golightly
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
07:53 PM
7
07
53
PM
PST
The idea that "Darwinists" are unalterably wedded to the model of "genes" that prevailed in the late 1960s is the strawiest of straw men. Here's what I recently wrote on this subject in my blog (see: http://evolutionlist.blogspot.com/2006/10/new-definitions-of-gene.html ): For years I have been teaching my students that a gene is a segment of DNA that codes for a single RNA molecule with a complementary sequence, regardless of whether that RNA molecule is translated or not. This definition takes into account the genes for the various rRNAs and tRNAs, which are not translated, and also other forms of non-translated RNA that have recently been discovered. By this definition, genes that code for mRNAs that are actually translated are distinguished as "structural genes," using terminology that was first developed to describe the Jacob-Monod model of the lactose operon. Using this same terminology, the gene that codes for the lactose repressor protein is a "regulatory gene," insofar as the repressor does not function in an "extrinsic" biochemical pathway, but rather participates in the regulation of other structural genes. However, the distinction between "structural" and "regulatory" genes outlined above is insufficient to describe the various kinds of genetically significant DNA sequences now known. For example, it does not include regions of the DNA to which protein regulators bind, but which are not themselves transcribed. It also does not distinguish between RNAs that are translated into proteins (either enzymes or repressor/regulator proteins) and those that are transcribed into RNA but never translated (such as rRNA, tRNA, and the newer non-translated RNAs). Given the foregoing, it appears to me that there are four (possibly five) functionally different kinds of DNA coding sequences: (1) translatable sequences: those DNA sequences that are both transcribed into mRNA and later translated into proteins, regardless of function (these can be further subdivided into proteins that participate in non-DNA related biochemical pathways and those that directly regulate DNA, but those seem to me to be classifications of the proteins, not the DNA sequences that code for them); (2) transcribable sequences: those DNA sequences that are transcribed into RNA (i.e. rRNA, tRNA, etc.), but are not later translated into proteins/polypeptide chains. Again, what the RNAs do after being transcribed is not a function of the DNA, but rather of the RNAs, and therefore should not really be used to classify DNA coding sequences; (3) binding sequences: those DNA sequences that are not transcribed into RNA nor translated into protein, but which function as binding sites for regulatory molecules such as repressor proteins, homeotic gene products, etc. While such sequences do not code for the production of a transcribed or translated gene product, they still participate in the regulation of other genes by serving as regulatory binding sites; and (4) non-binding sequences: those DNA sequences that are not transcribed into RNA, not translated into protein, nor function as binding sites for regulatory moelcules. Such sequences would include highly repetitive sequences, tandom repeats, "spacer DNA", pseudogenes, retroviral and transposon inserts (both "dead" and potentially "alive"), etc. This latter category could be further subdivided into "functional" non-coding/non-binding DNA sequences versus "non-functional/parastitic" non-coding/non-binding DNA sequences, depending on whether they arise as part of the functional architecture of the DNA (primarily of eukaryotes), or whether they arise as side-effects of the action of parasitic genetic elements, such as retroviruses or transposons. There may be other categories of DNA sequences that have other functions, but right now I can't think of any. Therefore, this is how I intend to teach the concept of a "gene" to my students at Cornell from now on. So much for the Beadle/Tatum "one gene, one enzyme" model, eh? And the classical Mendelian definition of "one gene, one phenotypic trait" is no longer viable as well... And if the Mendelian definition of the gene is now superceded, then the Fisher/Haldane/Wright model of genetic evolution (i.e. the core of the "modern evolutionary synthesis" of the 1930s-50s) has also been superceded. But, does this mean that the theory of evolution is dead? Not at all; not any more than relativity theory killed Newtonian mechanics. That's what happens to scientific theories. Scientists keep discovering new stuff, and the theories change accordingly. So, as soon as ID theorists stop spending all their time writing press releases and participating in debates, and start spending time in the field and in the lab doing actual scientific research, there might be a place in science for what they discover. As long as ID theory remains essentially parasitic on biology and the other sciences, it will never be recognized as science. Interpreting other people's discoveries in the light of different theoretical models doesn't cut it. That's why Nobel prizes are awarded to the people making the discoveries, not to the people who figure out what they mean. Or, to put it in a way a journalist/literature critic might be able to understand, ID currently stands in relationship to science where literary criticism stands in relationship to literature.Allen_MacNeill
November 10, 2006
November
11
Nov
10
10
2006
07:27 PM
7
07
27
PM
PST
1 2 3 4