Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Did microbes once thrive in arsenic world — a world without oxygen?

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Researchers think they have some evidence:

Billions of years ago, life on Earth was mostly just large slimy mats of microbes living in shallow water. Sometimes, these microbial communities made carbonate minerals that over many years cemented together to become layered limestone rocks called stromatolites. They are the oldest evidence of life on Earth. But the fossils don’t tell researchers the details of how they formed.

Today, most life is supported by oxygen. But these microbial mats existed for a billion years before oxygen was present in the atmosphere. So what did life use instead?

Our team of geologists, physicists and biologists had found hints in fossilized stromatolites that arsenic was the chemical of choice for ancient photosynthesis and respiration.

Pieter Visscher, Brendan Paul Burns, Kimberley L. Gallagher, “Ancient microbial life used arsenic to thrive in a world without oxygen” at The Conversation

Subsequent research showed a “vigorous arsenic cycle” in some modern microbes living in high-stress conditions in the Atacama Desert.

Well, there has to be some use for the chemical element arsenic. This one makes sense.

Comments
The modern arsenic-users are the most interesting part, and lead to questions that the article didn't ask. Is arsenic still an available 'switchover', perhaps through epigenes? For humans arsenic is more like a drug than a poison. In big sudden doses it's lethal, but some people have become accustomed to consuming it, and seem to be healthier than normal people as long as they can get their dosage. http://ultimatehistoryproject.com/arsenic-eaters.html This seems to imply that the cycle is still available "on command".polistra
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
08:06 AM
8
08
06
AM
PDT
Any nonsense qualifies as science today in order to explain away God.EugeneS
October 3, 2020
October
10
Oct
3
03
2020
02:59 AM
2
02
59
AM
PDT
I’m not sure about this. After the Great Oxygenation Event, arsenic compounds were much more toxic to life and enzymes were needed to confer arsenic resistance. The poor old prokaryotes had to go into detox.Belfast
October 2, 2020
October
10
Oct
2
02
2020
10:47 PM
10
10
47
PM
PDT

Leave a Reply