Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Ryugu asteroid samples contain clues to origin of life, Japan scientists say

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Dust from an asteroid collected by a Japanese space probe contains clues to the origin of life, suggesting it was formed in space, scientists reported Friday.

Minerals of the Ryugu sample, reported on June 10, 2022 by Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA).
Constituent minerals of the Ryugu sample. (JAXA Press Release)

Japan’s Hayabusa2 space mission dropped samples from the asteroid Ryugu to Earth in the Australian outback in December 2020. It was then moved to Japan to be studied for insights into the origins of the solar system and life on Earth.

Scientists most recently announced the finding included nearly two dozen types of amino acids in the sample, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA ) said.

Finding amino acids is a big deal, because they make proteins and are necessary to support life. This is also the first time they’ve been found on an asteroid, the Japan Times reported.

USA Today

In considering the significance of this report, it is important to realize that finding naturally occurring amino acids does not amount to showing how life could form naturally. As discussed in my book, Canceled Science, “Amino acids, such as can sometimes form naturally, do not remotely approach the molecular complexity of even the simplest living cell. Believing otherwise is like finding a few brick-shaped rocks up on a hillside and concluding from this that buildings and whole cities arose by nothing more than the same blind forces that formed those rocks.”

Comments
Relatd:
I think farmers are aware of ways to keep the soil fertile.
The big, industrial growers till the soil. They "make up" for the lost natural nutrients by over fertilizing. This also causes problems. The largest contribution of atmospheric CO2 comes during the tilling season. So, clearly most farms don't know how to keep the soil fertileET
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
07:22 PM
7
07
22
PM
PDT
I don’t have any idea
Neither do I.jerry
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
04:39 PM
4
04
39
PM
PDT
ET at 82, I think farmers are aware of ways to keep the soil fertile. In fact, the United States has paid farmers billions of dollars to grow nothing. These payments are called farm subsidies. They have existed since the Cold War. And should one part of the U.S. experience a drought, farmers in other parts of the country can make up for the shortfall. Some alarmists are pointing to the war in the Ukraine creating a food shortage. That's nonsense. When Eastern Europe was part of the U.S.S.R., how much food did they send the U.S.? We even helped the Russians at least once when they had a bad harvest and needed grain, during the Cold War.relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
03:50 PM
3
03
50
PM
PDT
Jerry @ 81-- The 2020 picture is at low tide. The 1920 picture is at high tide. :) (just kidding- I don't have any idea)ET
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
03:23 PM
3
03
23
PM
PDT
Relatd- Animal agriculture hits hard at environmental change. See part 4 pertaining to landscape changes in comment 51. Also, urban heat islands are real. And if the farmers don't stop tilling and over-tilling the soil, there will be a severe shortage in food in about 60 years. The topsoil will be dead or gone. We didn't learn much from the dust bowl.ET
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
03:20 PM
3
03
20
PM
PDT
Sea levels now and then? https://img.99memes.co/images/34b353094a965ce38e06d3de98f8984f51a4b89a8b20b9a05f60ae7442237369_1.jpgjerry
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
12:49 PM
12
12
49
PM
PDT
Andrew at 77, No problem. Remember, the people working at Disaster Central need you to be worrying about the next planet destroying disaster as much as possible. Because they are planning on announcing more disasters. And convincing you to spend a lot of money to fix the climate problem, and more money for the next disaster after that. * Not paid for by the Global Cabal of Newspaper Publishers :)relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
12:03 PM
12
12
03
PM
PDT
"Folks, eat shrimp?" KF, Yes, and the climate change devastation continues unabated. ;) Andrewasauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
12:00 PM
12
12
00
PM
PDT
Folks, eat shrimp? That;s not far from eating bugs. KFkairosfocus
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
11:46 AM
11
11
46
AM
PDT
"I didn’t say that" Sorry, Relatd. I got caught up in the flaming passions associated with eating bugs and saving the planet. Andrewasauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
11:19 AM
11
11
19
AM
PDT
Too late, Relatd. Whatever we do.Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
11:18 AM
11
11
18
AM
PDT
"Our consumption of animal protein is the source of greenhouses gas and climate change." THE Source. Who wrote this? A five year old? No mention of cars or factories around the world putting tons of gases into the atmosphere? Reactive (meaning bad) gases?relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
11:13 AM
11
11
13
AM
PDT
Andrew at 73, I didn't say that. But the propaganda machine is growing increasingly loud because people who are already wealthy need to make billions more. Here is the guiding principle: There is no such thing as too much money. So - SAVE the planet!! Eat bugs! Buy an electric car! Buy! Buy! Buy!relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:59 AM
10
10
59
AM
PDT
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/science-environment-35061609 Me and Fred and Relatd say Up Yours, BBC! Andrew https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/02/how-insects-positively-impact-climate-change/asauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:49 AM
10
10
49
AM
PDT
I just had a hot flash of curiosity.
Hmm!
I’m wondering why you haven’t forced yourself to eat more bugs in light of the fact climate change is destroying the planet at an exponentially alarming rate.
Told you already. It's too late. Whatever we do.Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:46 AM
10
10
46
AM
PDT
Andrew at 70, I don't know if Fred would buy anything from me. But I do have this bucket of grubs... :)relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:35 AM
10
10
35
AM
PDT
"You mean I have to sell my beachfront property in Florida now?" Relatd, If you sell to Fred now, global sea levels will still rise but at a slightly decreased rate. Andrewasauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:30 AM
10
10
30
AM
PDT
Andrew at 68, You mean I have to sell my beachfront property in Florida now?relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:19 AM
10
10
19
AM
PDT
"Not sure if you ever experience curiosity, Andrew." Fred, I just had a hot flash of curiosity. I'm wondering why you haven't forced yourself to eat more bugs in light of the fact climate change is destroying the planet at an exponentially alarming rate. Andrewasauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:14 AM
10
10
14
AM
PDT
As of 2021, "While there have been requests for the FDA to regulate insects as food, there are currently no regulations specifically regarding edible insects in the United States."relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
10:07 AM
10
10
07
AM
PDT
Bugs/insects can be contaminated or carry bacteria or harmful chemicals.
These mealworms were certified food quality (allegedly).Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
09:56 AM
9
09
56
AM
PDT
“cultural aversion”? You mean culture was looking over your shoulder before you tried them? ?
There are other cultures where insects are a staple food. Even western culture was not always so fastidious with bugs. I recall an older cousin telling me that as a kid he once watched his father enjoying a dish of fried mushrooms, pushing the white grubs that had emerged from them into the cooking liquor to one side. Then my uncle scraped them up on a knife and ate the tasty last morsel, having saved the best till last.Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
09:52 AM
9
09
52
AM
PDT
Bugs/insects can be contaminated or carry bacteria or harmful chemicals. https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/eating-insects-safelyrelatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
09:51 AM
9
09
51
AM
PDT
And was the planet saved by your virtuous heroism?
No heroism involved, just curiosity. My curiosity overcame my irrational distaste. Not sure if you ever experience curiosity, Andrew. I'd beware. It can lead you to places away from your comfort zone.Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
09:43 AM
9
09
43
AM
PDT
FH at 60, "cultural aversion"? You mean culture was looking over your shoulder before you tried them? :)relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:54 AM
8
08
54
AM
PDT
"Eaten bugs? I’ve tried them" Fred, And was the planet saved by your virtuous heroism? Andrewasauber
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:28 AM
8
08
28
AM
PDT
Eaten bugs? I've tried them (well, mealy worms, mostly) prepared by some guy who had the idea of raising them as high-protein food. This was just before the Covid pandemic so I guess that didn't help his business Idea. Not much to say except overcoming the cultural aversion to be able to try them was the hard part. Also avoid the hard parts of any bug before eating.Fred Hickson
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:24 AM
8
08
24
AM
PDT
ET at 51, You just ruined everything! People have got to spend money. They've got to buy electric cars - which cost money. And then they have to spend more money... Sheesh.relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:17 AM
8
08
17
AM
PDT
AD at 48, Well, in some cases, if you wish hard enough, things you imagine to be true can be true... for a few minutes at least. Or blind, unguided chance created human beings - by accident.relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:15 AM
8
08
15
AM
PDT
Jerry at 53, Eating bugs? Blehhh...relatd
June 24, 2022
June
06
Jun
24
24
2022
08:10 AM
8
08
10
AM
PDT
1 2 3

Leave a Reply