Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

At Mind Matters News: Why many now reject science… do you really want to know? Part 1

Categories
Intelligent Design
Philosophy
Science
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

COVID demonstrated — as nothing else could — that the “science” was all over the map and didn’t help people avoid panic:

Science-sponsored panic probably drove up the damage from COVID. Jay Richards, one of the authors of The Price of Panic: How the Tyranny of Experts Turned a Pandemic into a Catastrophe (October 2020), has noted, “In working on the book, we watched social media and platforms such as Google Search manipulate news coverage of the pandemic. It was, honestly, terrifying to watch important stories and studies get buried in real time on Google searches. It was also distressing to watch Twitter and Facebook attach warnings to the advice and viewpoint of scientists who urged calm and caution, while boosting the views of “officials” such as Anthony Fauci and WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom.”

And, just as most of the world was getting the impression that the pandemic — and the panic — had largely run their course, up pops a proposal in 2021 for a “reality czar” to fight disinformation and misinformation, as if all of that were coming from non-government or non-science sources. The proposal was (we are told) put on hold after the fear of just consequences prevailed.

News, “Why many now reject science… do you really want to know?” at Mind Matters News (July 17, 2022)

Takehome: As the panic receded, the government started setting up a disinformation board to target NON-government sources of panic, thus deepening loss of trust.


You may also wish to read: Did social media panic drive up the damage from COVID-19? Richards: It was, honestly, terrifying to watch important stories and studies get buried in real time on Google searches. Social media did a very good job of panicking the population about COVID-19, instead of relaying facts, says Jay Richards, an author of The Price of Panic.

Comments
@30 So about mass hysteria just a quick quip back in 2010 I contracted version of H1N1 and the doctor had prescribed to me multiple antiretrovirals to fight it, it was the sickest I’ve ever been He told me very specifically not to get onto social media and tell everybody I had this This of course was during Obama’s presidency COVID-19, exact opposite, get on social media and tell everybody you have it so they stay away from you and quarantine This is just my personal experienceAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:48 AM
11
11
48
AM
PST
"Do you trust your doctor? Why?" Relatd, I do not trust my doctor to put me absolutely above all their other concerns, no. I don't even trust my wife, who I know loves me, that far, that either would never be capable of a selfish act. They and I are both are fallen people, like I have been trying to explain to you. And if the pressure on a Doctor is great enough, there is no reason to think they wouldn't conform. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:46 AM
11
11
46
AM
PST
Jerry at 32, That is exactly right. Now that Leftists/Liberals control the media, they have no choice. That and they have to make lots of money. The world is going nowhere. People on UD can talk to their doctor and dump social - it's only there to make money and spread propaganda - media. Social media sows confusion. Fire bad - social media bad. Does anyone here actually want to be confused? Does anyone here think social media is trustworthy?relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:38 AM
11
11
38
AM
PST
Their primary job was and is creating hysteria.
They are just following orders. Meanwhile, the world is going around in circles. Especially at UD.jerry
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:35 AM
11
11
35
AM
PST
Andrew at 29, Don't you dare invent things I didn't say. Answer the question: Do you trust your doctor? Why?relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:34 AM
11
11
34
AM
PST
Andrew at 25, I watch 2 minutes of TV news in a 5 day period at most. I do not trust the media at all regarding this. I have ZERO trust in the media regarding this. I have condemned media reports regarding this. Why? Their primary job was and is creating hysteria.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:32 AM
11
11
32
AM
PST
"Make up your mind." Relatd I have. I try to have a realistic relationship with people. That means Titles like Doctor don't confer trust. You seem to think they do. Good luck with all the jabs. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:31 AM
11
11
31
AM
PST
AS1978 at 26, My point is: I'm not confused. Social media is crazy talk for the most part regarding this. Anything that might be factual is buried under crazy talk.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:29 AM
11
11
29
AM
PST
Andrew at 24, Make up your mind. I'm trusting my doctor, but, according to you, they "... lie, just like everyone else." So which is it? What about your doctor?relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:27 AM
11
11
27
AM
PST
@Realtd No? So you believe you won’t receive pushback about your line of thinking from the people you just insulted by calling them irrationals? And they are irrationals because they don’t have your line of thinking. And this is based on you working in business monitoring media. I’m sorry I’m very confused on what you mean by 19AaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:23 AM
11
11
23
AM
PST
Relatd, Are you one of those lemmings who watches press conferences and admires the stuffed labcoats and stethoscopes the pols trot out for the cameras? They are real doctors, get it? Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:21 AM
11
11
21
AM
PST
"So, I should tell my doctor “I don’t trust you?” That is stupid." Relatd, You can tell your doctor whatever you want. If your doctor isn't trustworthy, you could let them know and find another doctor. It's not rocket science. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:18 AM
11
11
18
AM
PST
Andrew at 22, So, I should tell my doctor "I don't trust you?" That is stupid.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:16 AM
11
11
16
AM
PST
"Stop trusting doctors?" Relatd, The only doctor you have to worry about is your own doctor. And to give that one doctor carte blanche over your life is stupid. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:10 AM
11
11
10
AM
PST
Andrew at 20, Stop trusting doctors? That's your answer?relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:06 AM
11
11
06
AM
PST
"the ONLY source of information that should have been used throughout the current health crisis is your doctor" Relatd, Let me update you: Doctors are not immune from pushing unproven/unnecessary/dubious chemicals on people. They have no special charism for ethics. They toe the party line, worship Mammon, and lie, just like everyone else. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
11:02 AM
11
11
02
AM
PST
AS1978 at 18, No. I work in a business and monitor the media. I know what I'm talking about. Again, the ONLY source of information that should have been used throughout the current health crisis is your doctor, NOT social so-called media.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
10:34 AM
10
10
34
AM
PST
@Relatd Your last comment @17 is a perfect example of what I was talking about before Because all you will accomplish by calling everybody “irrationals” here is create more push backAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
10:25 AM
10
10
25
AM
PST
Andrew at 14, Don't you start, OK? Or are you joining the group of irrationals here? Vaccines were produced by various companies and billions have been given out to help protect the people from some virus. That is the whole answer. If you have another answer, let's hear it.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
10:16 AM
10
10
16
AM
PST
"If the answer is vaccines then the answer is vaccines." Relatd Which vaccines were the answer and to what question? Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
10:04 AM
10
10
04
AM
PST
@14 *sigh*okAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
09:26 AM
9
09
26
AM
PST
AS1978 at 12, So what? Elon Musk has billions and is not involved in creating pharmaceuticals. If the answer is vaccines then the answer is vaccines. Someone has to make them.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
09:18 AM
9
09
18
AM
PST
And that was just a quick brief skim It took me about two minutes and 30 seconds to find those and copy and paste them to the site there’s many many more, is there anything else you would like me to post for you since the Internet is not my friend because I found all of this easily on the Internet I didn’t even have to look into my archive where I save these files at https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-tyne-58330796 https://www.foxnews.com/us/detroit-tv-news-anchor-dies-covid-19-vaccine https://sharylattkisson.com/2021/08/news-anchor-dies-of-blood-clots-after-covid-vaccine/ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9270125/Former-Detroit-TV-anchor-Karen-Hudson-Samuels-dies-taking-vaccine.htmlAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
09:18 AM
9
09
18
AM
PST
https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/21/business/covid-vaccine-billionaires/index.html https://rumble.com/vp7isp-dr.-fauci-admits-vaccines-did-not-work-as-advertised-and-that-vaccinated-ar.html https://www.woodtv.com/health/coronavirus/fully-vaccinated-michiganders-can-take-masks-off/ https://nypost.com/2021/05/13/biden-great-day-for-america-as-vaccinated-can-lose-masks/ https://www.fda.gov/vaccines-blood-biologics/vaccines/acam2000-smallpox-vaccine-questions-and-answers I found all of these pretty easy on the Internet so I don’t know what you’re talking aboutAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
09:11 AM
9
09
11
AM
PST
AS1978 at 7, Where the heck are your sources for your statements? I don't believe anything you wrote based on information I got from people in health care as opposed to the crap on social media. The internet is not your friend regarding this subject.relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
08:40 AM
8
08
40
AM
PST
No one should listen to no one on social media. So-called social media is NOT a legitimate news source. It is not to be trusted. At all. Social media is designed to create drama and can be manipulated by anonymous elements and NO, I am not talking about the government. Throughout the FRYING PAN-SCHMEMIK, your doctor and ONLY your doctor should have been your only source of information. THE ABOVE BOOK IS A PILE OF GARBAGE designed to spread the wrong ideas and capitalize on a product called CONFUSION. Avoid it. ISN"T IT OBVIOUS that protestors of all kinds were granted instant immunity? Isn't it obvious that things could have been done differently regarding distributing food and clothing? Isn't it obvious that certain businesses closed so they could be bought later?relatd
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
08:37 AM
8
08
37
AM
PST
@8 learned is right When you have a government declare that all asymptomatic people must wear masks because you can’t tell if they’re carrying diseases, however they have no symptoms, but six months later our president declares that people that have had the vaccine now can takeoff the mask because they have reduced symptoms and therefore spread the disease less, begs many questions There were too many incidents like this from locking down and destroying businesses because Covid, but allow mass nationwide destructive protests of BLM(Covid took a break) coupled with nine new billionaires thanks to Pfizer and Moderna. It’s stuff like this that made people start questioning things And instead of trying to rationally flush things out and discuss this with people that had concerns about these types of things people like Sev regurgitated THE EXACT SAME statements like “that’s just a conspiracy theory”, “you don’t understand THE science”, and “you are a science denier” which created even more push backAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
08:25 AM
8
08
25
AM
PST
Sev
The disinformation about science, particularly COVID and climate change, is about political influence
We could apply that to political motives from the left-wing progressives. Science is not politically neutral, unfortunately. It's a human activity and subject to biases and distortions and non-scientific interests.
and an instinctive resentment of being told what to do by those who know more than you do.
Not instinctive but a learned-resistance to people who have proven themselves untrustworthy.
The answer is conspiracy theories and telling yourself that you know more about stuff than some ivory tower academic.
Academic knowledge is not the same as wisdom. Having a degree from a credentialing-agency does not mean that you deserve authority over people. Respect must be earned. Respect can be lost when knowledge is abused. Ivory tower academics are known for hubris and foolishness - we see evidence of this almost every day on U.D. with some of the things academics say. In those cases, having basic common sense means a person will know quite a lot more than pseudo-scholars do.Silver Asiatic
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
07:55 AM
7
07
55
AM
PST
@Sev lol spoken EXACTLY like a brainwashed liberal By the way I followed nothing but Covid science which was often done by people conveniently from China and often wrong or inaccurate but science is ever changing right? What you’ve done there is a liberal character assassination so you can continue to believe that there was nothing wrong with the science However our government tried to mandated relatively ineffective vaccine, that now many people know is ineffective, that can be dangerous, has some pretty nasty side effects, and Fauci just recently said “it really doesn’t stop the spread” Remember that’s how you kept people safe from the spooky Covid if you didn’t get the vaccine you ran the risk of spreading it to somebody and killing them Some conspiracy theorist huh? Oh wait I’m just pointing out a glaring hypocrisy on how this was managed. All of these things are true and do not rely on liberal character assassinations of people that descent from your personal opinion And yes I am very well aware by calling you a brainwashed liberal I’m character assassinating you no differently than when you said everybody’s answer is a conspiracy theories and don’t believe those ivory tower academics. Here’s the reality our government, specifically your Democratic Party, based policies and mandates off science that was inaccurate at the time That was a big mistake and people have lost confidence in science and the institution of science because of this It’s politics that has directly harmed the credibility of science, and science is a human institution that can be easily bought. (We can start with tobacco companies and go from there if you need examples of science being bought) And when a governmental institutions force people to do things based off of science and then that science changes three months later those people might have a tendency to start questioning both the government and scienceAaronS1978
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
07:10 AM
7
07
10
AM
PST
"resentment of being told what to do" In contrast, Sev wants to be told what to do by his betters. It's only right that he serve them. Andrewasauber
July 18, 2022
July
07
Jul
18
18
2022
06:32 AM
6
06
32
AM
PST
1 … 5 6 7 8