Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

If there is a moral landscape, is Sam Harris’s book a map?

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Here.

Mostly, he wants to rescue atheism from relativism: “If there’s no God, everything is permitted.” For this purpose, he posits morality as “an undeveloped branch of science.” The view that science should play a key role in deciding morality and law is not unique; it surfaced as early as 1911. In an editorial, Scientific American excoriated “The absurdity of legislation to cure social evils without scientific facts to base that legislation upon.” More on the earlier absurdity later.

Harris’s project starts with the following basic assumptions: “… science should one day be able to make very precise claims about which of our behaviors and uses of attention are morally good, which are neutral, and which are worth abandoning.”

Comments
Harris is an idiot but he's no fool. With a noxious built in audience and often equally noxious opponents his brand of poorly thought out and badly argued atheism gets him exactly the amount of camera time and notoriety that screams "profit". The Four Toads of New Atheism have simply stolen Gorgeous George's act and made a nifty bundle.lpadron
November 30, 2011
November
11
Nov
30
30
2011
12:33 AM
12
12
33
AM
PDT
“… science should one day be able to make very precise claims about which of our behaviors and uses of attention are morally good, which are neutral, and which are worth abandoning.” Lol.. Isn't science already trying to attempt this now? What would happen if science one day inferred that Sam Harris and his moral map needed to be terminated because it would be “morally good” for our society to do so? Would Sam contest to this “precise” scientific claim, or would he just man up and walk the gallows?KRock
November 29, 2011
November
11
Nov
29
29
2011
07:19 PM
7
07
19
PM
PDT
I would say that Harris is "climbing mount improbable".Christian-apologetics.org
November 29, 2011
November
11
Nov
29
29
2011
06:31 PM
6
06
31
PM
PDT
The Knock-Down Argument Against Atheist Sam Harris' Moral Argument – William Lane Craig – video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvDyLs_cReEbornagain77
November 29, 2011
November
11
Nov
29
29
2011
05:58 PM
5
05
58
PM
PDT
v.insightful & succinct .... thanks.celal777
November 29, 2011
November
11
Nov
29
29
2011
02:44 PM
2
02
44
PM
PDT
Morality is something designed into humanity. I believe Atheists actually have a more sensitive morality, this is why they end up hating God. Also I believe that focus on good and evil is not the focus we were designed to have (makes you hate God). Rather we were designed to have a God focus (makes things make sense). Damn that tree and it's fruit.Mytheos
November 29, 2011
November
11
Nov
29
29
2011
01:59 PM
1
01
59
PM
PDT

Leave a Reply