Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

New book: Psychology gone wrong?


From a review of Psychology gone wrong

They show how study results can get distorted and changed in re-telling. Remember the Little Albert experiment? An infant was conditioned to develop a fear of white rats by exposing him simultaneously to a white rat and a loud noise. This confirmed a popular theory, so it was immediately accepted as evidence that early childhood experiences could create lasting phobias that would extend to similar objects (in this case, to anything white and furry). Most psychology textbooks have misrepresented the facts about that experiment. They get the child’s age wrong, say he was conditioned with a white rabbit, and make up other stimuli that he supposedly reacted to, like a puppy and a teddy bear. Some textbooks even described how the researchers later “deconditioned” Little Albert, but that never happened. The research was done while he was in the hospital; they knew he would soon be leaving the hospital and it would be impossible to continue the research, and they deliberately decided not to decondition him. He died of hydrocephalus at age 6, so there is no way to know whether he would have had a lifelong phobia.

They uncover social control problems in the scientific community. Scientists who observed misconduct in their peers failed to report it in 36% of cases, and 69% of whistleblowers experienced negative consequences after reporting fraud.

Remember this when someone tell us that science is the best way of discovering truth. Maybe some day it will be. Always check Retractions Watch

Thanks, BA. Ross has an incisive mind, doesn't he? Happy Easter to you, Guvner. Axel
OT: from Eric Metaxas: Ross Douthat interviews himself. MUST READING. What an encouragement to know he is out there, using the gifts God gave him for God's purposes in our time. Christ is Risen! http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/05/opinion/sunday/rosss-douthat-interview-with-a-christian.html?_r=0 “He Is Alive Death is defeated Sin has retreated From the power of the Son” “He Is Alive.” – Third Day https://youtu.be/h4oqodNXzs0 Happy Easter, everyone! bornagain77
Yet phobias are simply memories that got stuck. They easil;y are triggered by wrong conclusions when we are dumb kids. The memory prevails over later conclusions. It shows the power of the memory. Animals also are controlled by the simple memory action and easily have fears of trhings that never goes away. It shows the triggering mechanism is king. nOt the memory itself. Saying one can't get a phobia easily is like saying one can't get a song stuck in ones head. yet we do and its not easy to get rid of it and its irritation. It shows the power of the memory. A phobia is just in the spectrum and so worse. Robert Byers

Leave a Reply