Perry Marshall – Uncommon Descent

Intelligent Design Naturalism Origin Of Life

Show a naturalistic origin of life and win $10 million

Interesting to see Denis Noble taking part in the discussion.

Biology Cell biology Creationism Engineering Evolutionary biology ID Naturalism

Design Disquisitions: On Perry Marshall’s ‘Evolution 2.0’ & Confusions About Design

This week’s article at Design Disquisitions is about Perry Marshall’s ‘Evolution 2.0’ thesis and his criticisms of intelligent design. This article responds to some of his recent writings on his blog and his interaction with Stephen Meyer a few weeks back. Bottom line is, his philosophy of science has significant problems and he has some Read More…

Seversky Bornagain77/16 The ‘God of the gaps’ argument from Atheists and Theistic Evolutionists fails on so many levels that it is... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Seversky EDTA/4 Yeah, I hope humanist philosophers are daily taking a cold, hard look at humanity’s reality. I would hope so... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Seversky Maybe they fished for coelocanths – Early humans at Gobekli Tepe did...
Seversky I wonder what coelacanths taste like? – At Science: Coelacanths could live to...
AaronS1978 @ ChuckyD No matter how much you deny it evolution is your god of gaps it literally does the same... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
bornagain77 Jerry, "A “God of the Gaps” assessment is a logical fallacy. It is form of begging the question. It assumes... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
EDTA >" Some investigators are even experimentally recreating 12,000-year-old meals using methods from that time." We had those in my college... – Early humans at Gobekli Tepe did...
AaronS1978 https://neurosciencenews.com/genetics-aging-bacteria-18799/?fbclid=IwAR3-fBXPh41fDstFAxhfVnMN7xWxLI2-VupXjXfGig4T69hLGq6BeyH9I3o This relates a little bit of the topic above and I found it quite interesting – Surprise, surprise, the aging process is...
jerry A “God of the Gaps” assessment is a logical fallacy. It is form of begging the question. It assumes a... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Sandy Really? Come on….. :)) This is all materialists have. How in the world they don't hear the irony alarm. – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
chuckdarwin #13 John Lennox is an affable, somewhat impish purveyor of bromides. "God is not a ‘God of the gaps’ but... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Sandy propensity to import non-empirical explanations :)) Best explanation is the point of reference not materialist-naturalist dogma. Science is limited ,it's... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
bornagain77 Chuckdarwin claims that Meyer is making a "repackaged god of the gaps" argument. It might interest Chucky to know, (or... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Sandy Chuckdarwin No matter how much Meyer denies it, his “thesis” is simply repackaged god of the gaps… You are an... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
chuckdarwin #8 Kairosfocus When Charles S. Pierce, arguably America's greatest logician, innovated abductive reasoning (which is what Meyer touts using), he... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
Querius Japanese Koi live typically 25-35 years, but the celebrated Japanese scarlet koi, Hanako, lived to see her 226th birthday as... – At Science: Coelacanths could live to...
kairosfocus Martin-R I have utterly zero interest in loaded language debates starting with Anti-X'ers. I am highlighting that if there is... – Human cells write RNA sequences into...
kairosfocus CD, fallacious switcheroo; actually no matter how you package it your refusal to acknowledge cogency of inference on tested reliable... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
kairosfocus Jerry, hence, logic of being [yes, in the L&FP series], investigated from our participation in a going concern world. KF – Celebrity physicists are in a row...
chuckdarwin No matter how much Meyer denies it, his "thesis" is simply repackaged god of the gaps... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...
mohammadnursyamsu The God hypothesis is wrong, he should instead generically refer to "the creator hypothesis", or "intelligent designer hypothesis". Because by... – Humanist philosopher James Croft goes after...