Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

New science mythbuster book should be blockbuster

arroba Email

From a (paywalled) review in Science of Newton’s Apple and Other Myths About Science (Ronald L. Numbers and Kostas Kampourakis, Eds. Harvard 2015):

Before Columbus discovered America, people believed that the world was flat. When the apple struck Newton’s head, he discovered gravity and replaced God with objective truth. Gregor Mendel was a lone genius who discovered genetics. You will probably have heard at least some of these stories—you may even have believed them—but this delightful collection of short, thought-provoking essays shows that they are all myths.

So pointing out that the pop sci lore on these subjects is largely myth is now going mainstream? Used to be, earnest Christian profs wrote this stuff. They were correct, and often engaging, but who cared? Media could just shovel the myths anyway.

And what will become of the current war on falsifiability if it matters whether something is true or not?

Also from review:

Ron Numbers sets out to demolish the idea that social Darwinism was a major influence on American social theory during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. He offers a lot of interesting evidence, noting, for example, how seldom the phrase “social Darwinism” was actually used by politicians, businessmen, racists, and others during this period. Yet, the chapter doesn’t quite persuade, perhaps because when an idea is really widespread, its tenets are taken for granted by many who are unaware of their origins and, therefore, unlikely to reference the original theory.

Apart from buying the book (US$20.62), it might be worth buying the review (US$30), just to hear someone admit stuff so obviously true—and so widely denied for shameless political reasons. Anyway, now you know what to do with your holiday gift money.

From Amazon’s Publisher collection:

Twenty-seven popular myths about science and its history bite the dust in this engaging and timely book. In these essays, Numbers, Kampourakis, and a host of eminent experts set the record straight and explore how and why these myths become part of our collective memory?whether right or wrong. Each chapter offers important lessons about history and the scientists involved in some of our most significant discoveries. (Janet Browne, author of Charles Darwin: A Biography)

See also: Flat Earth award for mythmaking:

Now, the spherical nature of Earth became so much a part of popular culture that when Dante (1265-1321 CE) wrote the most famous poem of the period, the Divine Comedy, he put Hell inside Earth – a convenient location for the worst place in the universe because Earth was considered second worst – the heaviest place, to which everything fell.

I can’t decide what the award should be, but maybe someone will donate toward a work of historical fiction – a bodice ripper, perhaps, with lots of castles and shining armour. Fact-based books would be wasted on the recipient. More.

Will there still be science in 2020?


Darwinian racism

Follow UD News at Twitter!

its actually now so realized that people KNES the earth was round in the middle ages thats its become a myth that people don't know this! Robert Byers
Are there really any more myths in science than there are in any other human endeavour? George Washington never chopped down the cherry tree and Elvis really did die. I went through the chapter list and must admit that I am not aware of many of these claims. But of the ones that I had heard, I was also aware that they were not factual. I guess the Toronto education system does a pretty good job. Jonas Crump
Looking at the chapter list, I'd imagine the chapters about Myths 21,22 and 26 will be of particular interest to readers (and perhaps even News). Bob O'H

Leave a Reply