Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Zebrafish made “a supreme evolutionary effort” to develop superior vision (better than Google Street View), say researchers

arroba Email
Zebrafish's near 360 degree UV-vision knocks stripes off Google Street View
larval zebrafish eye/U Sussex

From Phys.org,

A zebrafish view of the world has been forensically analysed by researchers at the University of Sussex to reveal that how they see their surroundings changes hugely depending on what direction they are looking.

The study of the colour vision system of zebrafish larvae, published today in Current Biology, reveals they use their near 360 degree view of their world to detect threatening silhouettes above them in black-and-white but can seek out the almost transparent single-cell organisms they feed on by detecting the scattering of light in UV.

Dr. Tom Baden, a senior lecturer in neuroscience at the University of Sussex who led the research, said: “By measuring the activity of thousands of neurons in the live animal while presenting visual stimuli, we established that different parts of their retinas, looking at different parts of the visual world, do different things. This multi-faceted view makes perfect sense for zebrafish as that’s how colour is distributed in their natural habitat. In their natural visual world, most colour information is on the ground and the horizon but above them the objects of most interest are dark silhouettes, so colour vision here is rather pointless.”

The study is the first in-depth physiological description of any vertebrate’s retinal setup for colour vision that uses “4 input colours” which includes a large proportion of non-mammal species such as most birds, reptiles, amphibians and fish. By comparison humans only use three and mice, dogs and horses only two.

The study found that zebrafish, who during larval and juvenile life stages live mostly in shallow, low current pockets on the sides of streams and rice paddies, only seem to use their colour vision repertoire for looking down and along the horizon, use colour-blind circuits for looking straight up and extremely sensitive ultraviolet vision for looking forward and upwards.

Now comes the thonk sound:

The zebrafish has made a supreme evolutionary effort to develop this superior vision, with about half of all its neurons inside the eyes making up nearly a quarter of their total body volume and requiring substantial metabolic investment. Similar ratios on a human being would mean eyes around the size of a large grapefruit which would require an optic nerve the width of an arm.More.

Hmmm. Is evolution the sort of thing about which a life form could make “a supreme evolutionary effort”? Doesn’t that sound too much like design? And all that equipment, all co-ordinated too…

PaV, hat tipped below, asks, “I wonder what the initial “fitness” benefit was for 360 degree eyes? If they didn’t have it, but needed it to find ‘prey,’ then how did they ever survive?”

Hat tip: PaV

See also: 530-million-year-old Fossil Has Look of World’s Oldest Eye (PaV)

Did the zebrafish get Nobel Prize in Physics Chemistry Physiology? Patents? OLV
“The zebrafish has made a supreme evolutionary effort to develop this superior vision,” Something must have been "supreme", I guess, if not the effort. The only way I can think of stating the same idea atelogically is: "These superior adaptations are supremely unlikely to have occurred except under a bizarre set of adaptive conditions that it takes an effort even to imagine." Jon Garvey
"The zebrafish has made a supreme evolutionary effort to develop this superior vision," How someone can write that sentence, as if it is suppose to make any scientific sense at all, without their head exploding is beyond me. Atheist's head exploding http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-cLb5LVVPC9Y/VIKDwEsTncI/AAAAAAAAIXk/A4Wx5GKLH5Q/s1600/head-explode.jpg bornagain77
Just more bizarre a/mat thinking. Actually kind of funny. I have to give these a/mats credit. They have a tremendous amount of faith in nature being able to do the impossible... over and over and over again. That's some strong faith. It's almost like... a... religion. Truth Will Set You Free

Leave a Reply