Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

At Science Daily: What makes the human brain different?

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

What makes the human brain distinct from that of all other animals — including even our closest primate relatives? In an analysis of cell types in the prefrontal cortex of four primate species, Yale researchers identified species-specific — particularly human-specific — features, they report Aug. 25 in the journal Science.

Baby chimpanzee (stock image).
Credit: © Patrick Rolands / stock.adobe.com

And they found that what makes us human may also makes us susceptible to neuropsychiatric diseases.

For the study, the researchers looked specifically at the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), a brain region that is unique to primates and essential for higher-order cognition. Using a single cell RNA-sequencing technique, they profiled expression levels of genes in hundreds of thousands of cells collected from the dlPFC of adult humans, chimpanzees, macaque, and marmoset monkeys.

“Today, we view the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex as the core component of human identity, but still we don’t know what makes this unique in humans and distinguishes us from other primate species.”

To answer this, the researchers first asked whether there are there any cell types uniquely present in humans or other analyzed non-human primate species. After grouping cells with similar expression profiles they revealed 109 shared primate cell types but also five that were not common to all species. These included a type of microglia, or brain-specific immune cell, that was present only in humans and a second type shared by only humans and chimpanzees.

The human-specific microglia type exists throughout development and adulthood, the researchers found, suggesting the cells play a role in maintenance of the brain upkeep rather than combatting disease.

An analysis of gene expression in the microglia revealed another human-specific surprise — the presence of the gene FOXP2. This discovery raised great interest because variants of FOXP2 have been linked to verbal dyspraxia, a condition in which patients have difficulty producing language or speech. Other studies have also shown that FOXP2 is associated with other neuropsychiatric diseases, such as autism, schizophrenia, and epilepsy.

“FOXP2 has intrigued many scientists for decades, but still we had no idea of what makes it unique in humans versus other primate species.”

Full article at Science Daily.

Research into comparative brain chemistry to try to determine what makes a human different than a chimpanzee will certainly yield some interesting results. But I believe that there’s something deeper than chemistry that makes us uniquely human. The worldview that excludes non-material realities will never perceive the God-breathed human spirit, without which we could only be dust.

Comments
A single mutation
Interesting article. The question is how important was this mutation. Was is just one of a thousand or was it an/the essential one. The review I listed above (#1) indicates there are probably thousands of difference between human brain development and any other species.jerry
September 10, 2022
September
09
Sep
10
10
2022
07:59 AM
7
07
59
AM
PDT
A single mutation: https://news.yahoo.com/makes-brain-different-neanderthals-174221267.htmlPater Kimbridge
September 9, 2022
September
09
Sep
9
09
2022
03:01 PM
3
03
01
PM
PDT
Jerry gets grumpy sometimes
Grump, grump, grump, grump… https://static.inspiremore.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/23113751/Bouche-Lee-the-grumpy-dog-7.jpg A great theory that explains the difference between the human brain and other species is pointed out and the discussion turns to “grumpiness” not the theory. How best to illustrate the shallowness of UD.jerry
September 8, 2022
September
09
Sep
8
08
2022
01:44 PM
1
01
44
PM
PDT
Jerry gets grumpy sometimes. Andrewasauber
September 8, 2022
September
09
Sep
8
08
2022
11:19 AM
11
11
19
AM
PDT
Jerry, Do you actually expect everyone here to know what you know and read what you read?relatd
September 8, 2022
September
09
Sep
8
08
2022
10:35 AM
10
10
35
AM
PDT
Probably the best review of this is by Wilcox. https://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/2016/PSCF3-16Wilcox.pdf But because the website where it is located is so religious oriented, it has zero effect even though few of the references or the discussion is about religion. For example, here is a quote from the paper
As for the genetic evidence, the unique character of the human mind is not due to a “magic genetic bullet.” There are not just a few major alterations, not just the injection of a “new” set of genes—although some new loci have been identified. Rather, based on differences with the chimpanzee genome, human neural development depends on the wholesale alteration of the control sequences of the majority of the genes acting in the brain
This is another indication that UD is not a serious site for ID as this paper hasn't been debated let alone read for understanding.jerry
September 8, 2022
September
09
Sep
8
08
2022
10:09 AM
10
10
09
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply