Fine-tuning and the claim that “unlikely things happen all the time”
|June 1, 2017||Posted by News under Fine tuning|
Often used to dismiss the masses of evidence for fine-tuning of our universe, as opposed to chance. From Tim Barnett at Salvo:
This response may have some rhetorical force, but it makes a fundamental mistake. To expose the error, let me give you another illustration. Imagine your best friend has been murdered and the lead suspect is on trial. In fact, DNA evidence puts the suspect at the scene with the murder weapon in hand. As a result, the defense attorney turns to the jury and says, “The DNA evidence makes it highly unlikely that my client is innocent. But unlikely things happen all the time. For example, for you to exist, your mom and dad had to meet, fall in love, and have sex at just the right time. . . .
Would any jury accept this response? I think we would have to say no.
But why wouldn’t they accept it? It is because there is a better explanation; namely, that the suspect really is the killer. More.
Note: Lots of good stuff to read at Salvo Online #41
See also: In search of a road to reality