Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Dawkins Bravely Opposes Following the Herd (Unless It’s His Herd)

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Readers of this blog will know that my favorite game is “spot the irony” (based upon Monty Python’s “spot the looney” game).  Here a colleague from another listserve brings Richard Dawkins’ statement from “The Enemies of Reason”

We’ve got to go back to the evidence and see what is true. We must favour verifiable evidence over private feeling otherwise we leave ourselves vulnerable to those who would obscure the truth. We should be open minded, but not so open minded that our brains fall out.

The scientific method tests with objective observation and statistical analysis. Individual scientists may or may not be honest, but science with its’ safeguards of peer review and repeated experiment has scrupulous honesty built into it by design. Science replaces private prejudice with publicly verifiable evidence.

I have a hankering after what is actually true.

We are confronted by those who deny the evidence of the real world and instead bend reality around a dogmatic belief system handed down by tradition.

Sceptical rational enquiry is always the best approach. We don’t have to follow the herd, … instead we can think independently and be truly open minded. That means asking questions, being open to real corroborated evidence. Reason has liberated us from superstition and has given us centuries of progress. We abandon in at our peril.

Comments
So does the scientific method prove that we should only use the scientific method to believe something?geoffrobinson
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
11:01 AM
11
11
01
AM
PDT
Those scarlet letter t-shirts are the most bland looking things I've ever seen. But, check out the size of that A...cripes, could they have made it any larger? If I were an atheist, you'd have to pay me to wear it. Thank goodness someone with some design sense put together the Expelled apparel.Forthekids
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
10:50 AM
10
10
50
AM
PDT
Hey, it appeared! I take it back! :)ReligionProf
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
10:31 AM
10
10
31
AM
PDT
This is, like most things, a legitimate point (that reason can help protect us from superstition and from being misled and manipulated, which of course religion has been hijacked to do many times down the ages) and takes it to an illogical (indeed, irrational!) extreme. I've posted a critical review of Dawkins' book on my blog at http://exploringourmatrix.blogspot.com/2007/08/do-as-i-say-not-as-i-do-richard-dawkins.html To be fair, however, I was able to freely post these criticisms on the Dawkins forum. I find that my attempts to express critical views on THIS blog never appear. Irony, it seems, cuts both ways.ReligionProf
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
10:31 AM
10
10
31
AM
PDT
We should be open minded, but not so open minded that our brains fall out.
This almost a direct quote of what my extremely conservative pastor was preaching 20 years ago when the tolerance movement was just getting started. Back then, it was the tolerance folks who were advocating open-mindedness and acceptance of alternate viewpoints while the church was towing the line on truth. What an interesting twist that now it is the conservative crowd that is now talking about open-mindedness and such while the formerly-tolerant folks are not digging in their heels and need their secular "preachers" to give them rah-rah speeches about being open minded (but not too open, mind you).The Scubaredneck
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
10:27 AM
10
10
27
AM
PDT
We don’t have to follow the herd, instead we can think independently and be truly open minded
And that's why Richard encourages his flock to wear a uniform and follow him. See: The Uniform.scordova
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
10:20 AM
10
10
20
AM
PDT
Dawkins lacks outspoken secular critics. I fail to see how all atheists are of the same attitude as him... or is there now an issue with speaking against dawkins? Honestly, Dawkins isn't doing much for the atheist community other than protraying a militant hard lined atheist position (but I thought atheists were individuals [sic]) as well as banding them together. If all atheists are like Dawkins, doesn't that say something about atheism?bork
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
09:59 AM
9
09
59
AM
PDT
I just cannot ever think of Dawkins without thinking of his "matter of faith" in natural selection video. "It's just so coherent." he saysCollin
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
09:52 AM
9
09
52
AM
PDT
Praise be to Dawkins, Prophet of holy Darwin! Praise his name, he that liberates us from darkness! He that desires only truth and, alone among men, is unmoved by bias or desire! May He smite down the unbeliever in sacred Reason! May he destroy the forces of foul superstition! http://outrageoracle.blogspot.com/Charles Foljambe
August 24, 2007
August
08
Aug
24
24
2007
09:34 AM
9
09
34
AM
PDT
1 2

Leave a Reply